Planning Commission - Regular Meeting

Hello. Welcome to the meeting of the Paris City Planning Committee. Can you hear my voice? It's 6.03 p.m. It's good here because it's cool. It's okay if the meeting goes on for six hours. Yes, good. Then today's meeting will start with attendance confirmation.

Now, we will begin the National Day Ceremony. Please stand up. Please put your right hand on your chest.

Are you ready? Let's begin. Today, I am going to talk about the National Day Ceremony. I swear. Now, let's move on to the approval of the City Planning Committee's meeting on July 15, 2026, which is the fifth case. Are there any corrections, deletions, or errors? Yes, I see. Now we will only ask for citizens' opinions on Act A. Please come forward if you have any opinions on the approval of the approval of the approval of the approval of the approval of the approval of the approval of the approval of the approval of the approval of the approval of the approval of the approval of the approval of the approval of the approval of the approval of the approval of the approval of the approval of the approval of the approval of the approval of the approval of the approval of the approval of the approval of the approval of the approval of the approval of the approval of the approval of the approval of the approval of the approval of the approval of the approval of the approval of the approval of the approval of the approval of the approval of the approval of the approval of the approval of the approval of the approval of the approval of the approval of the approval of the approval of the approval of the approval of the approval of the approval of the approval of the approval of the approval of the approval of the approval of the approval of the approval of the approval of the approval of the approval of the approval of the approval of the

Thank you.

Now, let's take a look at the terms and conditions of the 6A of the Public Investigation and the terms and conditions of the 6A of the Public Investigation. This case is to review the construction of a 3,227-square-feet convenience store, auxiliary vehicle gas station, beer and wine sales, 20 major sales facilities, and a 991-square-feet automatic car wash. The development company requested an extension of the project, which was composed of the following requests due to the lack of attention. The first request is a conditional use permit that allows the operation of the vehicle gas station, beer and wine sales at the same time, and the second request is an exception permit that allows major sales within 1,000 feet of the church. The person in charge is Alfredo Garcia, a sub-designer. 현재 비공개로 진행 중인 통신이 있습니까? 현장 방문 일정이 있나요? 아니면 이 안건에 대한 임시위원회 회의가 있나요? 저는 현장 방문을 하거나 가끔 차로 지나가면서 확인합니다. 네. 알겠습니다. 어제도 여러 번 현장을 차로 지나갔습니다. 네, 이번에는... In Paris, Garcia. Thank you for your introduction, Chairman.

Hello, members of the Planning Committee. Oh, I'll stop talking for a moment. It's my mistake. I thought it was 6A, not 6B.

There is a memo sent to the chairman of the planning committee. The updated approval conditions for the 6A case are below. I'm trying to help you. Approval conditions for the 6A case are 33. Look at number 33. It is the border between the south and the east. The application developer must cooperate with the owner of the surrounding house to remove the existing fence installed along the east and south borders and replace it with a 8-feet high split-face block wall, and the block wall must be placed at a 100-feet interval with a decoration protrusion. This case was submitted on August 19, 2026, and the number 33 for section 6A is recorded. Thank you. Thank you for your help.

I will give you a brief explanation of the project. This proposal is 3,227 square feet of convenience stores, gas stations, beer and wine sales, 20 major sales permits and 991 square feet of automatic car wash. This case was approved by the Senate on July 21, 2021. Since then, the City Planning Committee of June 16, 2021 has recommended approval, and this recommendation includes the specified modified approval conditions below. The modified condition is to add 50% of the width to the south and east footings and change the operating time of the car wash to 7 a.m. to 9 p.m. These conditions are included in the approval conditions of the plan-related documents in front of you. However, as I mentioned earlier, the approval period was terminated on July 27, 2025, because the applicant did not submit an extension request due to negligence. If the developer submitted an extension request, the approval would have been valid until July 27, 2027. Therefore, the applicant would like to request the approval of the previously approved project to proceed with the construction. Regarding the location, the site is located within the specific planning area of the Paris Valley Business Center. The use of land is for commercial purposes. On the other side of Rider Street, there is a Riverside County Support facility on the north. On the east and south, there are existing single-use and mobile homes, and on the west side of the Paris Boulevard, commercial and industrial buildings are mixed. The picture you see here is the image of the suburb looked south-east from the Paris Boulevard and Rider Street intersection. This is the Google image of the suburb looked south-east along Rider Street. Another picture is the Google image of the suburb looked east along the Paris Boulevard. Here, There is a sub-planning area. The purple square represents a convenience store with a size of 3,227 square feet. The red square on the south side is an automatic car wash with a size of 991 square feet. The green rectangle following the Paris Boulevard represents a gas station canopy with a size of 2,000 square feet, and the yellow square represents the location of a garbage collection. This project offers 35 parking spaces. 2 of these are disabled parking spaces, 8 are electric vehicle-only parking spaces, and 4 are spaces that allow electric vehicles to enter and exit according to the CBC regulations. The entrance route is designed to allow vehicles to enter and exit along the Paris Boulevard and Brother Street. Regarding the dam and the fence, the applicant is going to build a split-face block dam 8 feet high on the south and east of the border. Here is a conceptual landscaping plan. The applicant suggested a strong landscaping of 21.1% above the landscaping area, i.e. over 24,000 square feet, which is much more than the development standard 20%. The applicant suggested a plan that exceeded the development standards of a specific plan. All items are consistent. We requested an exception permit to sell beer and wine within 1,000 feet of the New Creation Church. The employee in charge completed the necessary investigation to support the exception permit based on the support of the church and Riverside County Security Office. Beer and wine only need a storage space of at least 45 square feet, which is only 1.39% of the entire 3,000-square-feet sales space. Also, you need to consider the distance from other important facilities. There is a Paragon Park 2,600 feet away, and there is a Valverde Elementary School 4,000 feet away. This distance is much more than 1,000 feet. Also, the applicant must comply with additional specific standards related to mainstream sales Here, it includes employee training related to drinking, the prohibition to display drinks in the entrance hall, the prohibition to sell drinks, the prohibition to sell drinks, the prohibition to enter open drinks containers, the prohibition to install security systems, etc. All employees must be over 18 years old and the drinks must be put in a bag and sold. Here is the entrance to the convenience store building. The changes were not limited to the previously approved content. As you can see, the architectural style is modern. The applicant suggested vertical and horizontal expression. The use of cool colors goes well with the stone banner, and the horizontal elements add interesting points to the entire building. Mr. Cerviz, would you like to hand over your name card? This is the inside of the gas station canopy. And this is the inside of the washroom. The gas station canopy and the washroom building maintain the same consistency in terms of construction style, materials and color. Regarding the environmental impact assessment, the project is unconditionally exempted according to the SQA, which is a urban redevelopment project. In addition, a notice was issued to related institutions and landowners within 300 feet of the business site. The opposition to the project has not been received. Therefore, this evening, the staff confirmed that the project of the planning committee is unconditionally exempted from the urban redevelopment project, and based on the above survey results, it is recommended to adopt 2616, which was approved by the PC to approve 210,021 and the variance for the purpose of using the cup according to the approval conditions. In addition, we will modify Plan Option 33 and restore the previously submitted memo. This concludes my presentation. If you have any opinions at the committee meeting, please let me know anytime. Thank you very much for your presentation. I'm not sure if you or the representative are here. Yes, this is Mike from Fate & Associates. All right.

If you want to make a presentation, you are always welcome.

Can you tell me your name? Yes, I see. Hello, my name is Mike McFarland. McFarland, McFarland. I'm from Dayton Associates, and my address is California, Santa Ana Park Center 701. I won't make a presentation separately. And I wanted to thank the employees. If the paperwork hadn't been done in time, I wouldn't have been able to be here today. But thank you so much for being able to come. Once again, thank you for your help. If you have any questions, please let me know anytime. Thank you. Now, is there anyone in the committee who has any questions?

It's not a debate, it's a question about the applicant or the city. Yes, I'll give you a few simple questions.

Did the New Horizon church pastor and the police re-confirm the approval? Or did you do it based on the approval content for 2021? Yes, Vice President. Yes, I contacted the security guard and the church pastor to get the latest confirmation of the project approval. All right. Does the applicant have any problems with changing the color of the exterior wood? I hope the building will change to a more brownish color, not a grayish monochrome color like it is now. I'm sorry. I'm alive. If you have a specific color you want, please let me know and I'll change it without any problems. You're talking about the wood trim, right? Yes. Wood panel. That's right. Darker. Brighter. Uh... You want to change it to wood or brown, right? Yes. I don't think there's a problem. I don't know exactly what it means. Are you saying you want to make the color brighter? Or are you talking about the synthetic black part? That's right. The rest is oil paint. I don't have a problem. But the wood trim siding. Only the synthetic black part. Yes, yes. I want to change it to a color closer to the wood color. Yes, yes. I don't have a problem. Oh, I'm sorry. Can you decide that with the employee in charge? I looked at the case data, and it seems that there is a slight mismatch in the content that the city council is trying to promote in relation to the gas station regulation. Yes, one of them is to be limited to two streets per intersection, and the other one should be more than 200 feet away from the residential area, about 60 meters away. How far is the distance from the residential area in the current situation? I know it's close, but it's regulated. Is it applied from the border to the land border? Or is it applied from the disease to the wall? That's the city in charge. I'll ask the planner. Not yet. Because it's not in the law. Yes, Mr. Lopez, I'll tell you. The regulations are not in the law yet. It's just a matter of order from the Senate. Mr. Benjamin, Michael. Can you hear me? Yes, as I just said, the city council asked the employees to prepare a related request proposal to be reviewed by the city planning committee and the city council. But that regulation has not been adopted yet. All right. So you're saying that the current project does not apply to that regulation? That's right. All right. And... Ah, I would like to ask about the 8-feet height of the dam along the south and east sides of the sub-district. Did the applicant communicate with the local residents and get permission to install the dam? Did you check if there is no problem? Yes, we are willing to cooperate with the residents. In the worst case, we will proceed only within our sub-district. We have assumed the worst situation. We are ready to cooperate with the residents. Yes, I think I saw a document saying that the chief is invading about 4 feet to the inside of the sub-district of the sub-district of the sub-district of the sub-district of the sub-district of the sub-district of the sub-district of the sub-district of the sub-district of the sub-district of the sub-district of I saw that the project was approved in 2021. Is the main sales approval included in that approval? Yes, that's right. All right. There are no more questions. Thank you. Thank you. This is a question about engineering.

이런 프로젝트의 경우, 일반적으로 몇 건의 시간 연장 신청이 허용되나요? 세 건입니다. 네. 세 건입니다. 그리고 이번에 기한이 지난 신청 건 이전에 몇 건의 연장 신청이 접수되었나요? 한 건입니다.

네. 한 건입니다.

그럼 오늘 밤이 프로젝트가 승인되면 기한이 다시 시작되어 추가로 세 건의 연장 신청이 허용되는 건가요? 네. 맞습니다. 네. Do you know the approximate distance between the nearest house near the washroom and the southern border? It's 25 feet. Yes, it's 25 feet. And the data. There was a link that was connected to the MND document, but was there technical research data in the MND document? Yes. Then how was the sound research result?

I don't remember the decibel number exactly, but I think it was appropriate. At the time, the committee considered noise reduction as the most effective way to reduce sales hours from 11 o'clock to 9 o'clock, considering additional trees and 11 o'clock. Yes.

Did the research on the atmosphere quality proceed? Yes, there was an atmosphere quality study. Yes. And that study has already analyzed the situation of the area where the air pollution is serious in the north, east, and west of the Gyeonggung-eup area.

We confirmed that the atmosphere quality has improved in terms of biodiversity and ancient biodiversity.

And I also know that 7-Eleven will no longer be a branch. That's right. Do you know if there is a new branch? As of now, there is none. Yes. That's all for the questions. Thank you. I think there will be another question if I ask an engineering question.

I want to tell you some of the things they raised in my opinion. One of them is noise reduction research, when the distance is long. There must be a sensitive subject, but I didn't see that part. It is affected by the distance from the residential area to the car wash, but the general gas station can't help it, but it seems to have built a wall at a height of 25 feet because of the car wash. That's right. It's to block the noise. The main reason for the 8-feet wall is because of the noise problem. Anyway, we would have asked for it, but the important thing is the noise problem. Well, there's one more thing I'd like to tell you, and it's item 17 of the COA. I'm sorry I'm a little meticulous. It says RTA. This means that the existing bus stop on Rider Street will be transferred to the east side of the Rider Street entrance. It's impossible without RTA approval. So I think it's better to put in a phrase called approval condition. It's an approval condition and you can't move it as you please. It doesn't matter what phrase you put in, but it's better to put in the content that RTA approval is necessary. Ah, Mr. Chairman, how about adding the contents in the planning review process to the condition book, especially engineering condition 15 and 23? Yes, that's good.

Yes, now I'm a little relieved. I don't know what's going to happen to these institutions. Oh, that's right. You pointed it out well. Or you can just say, I didn't approve it, so I have to withdraw. Then you're going to see a huge loss. Yes.

I think it's very good. And one more thing. In an administrative aspect, Jack talked about wood, I'm talking about the bright color of the building, that is, the aesthetic side. I don't know what you think, but honestly, it's a bit dark. So, whether it's white or other colors, the color that suits you is the wood part. In other words, it's a story that only applies to the beautiful part, the stone part. We're just talking about the color of the building. The color is quite dark. So is there a way to make it a little brighter? I think I said it was a beautiful white. I don't know exactly what color it is, but I've never heard of a beautiful white. Anyway, I hope it's a brighter color. This is an administrative problem. I'm not saying I'm going to choose it myself. If it's not a whiter color, I'd like it to be a little brighter. Because Bato shopping across the street. The center is a white building, but it stands out and has a white interior. It's one of my requests to make the atmosphere a little brighter. It's one of the few things that a developer should add. It's just a color problem. It's not a design or anything else. It's just a color. Um, finally, and the price is like this. If you show me the land plan again, can you tell me where the electric car charging station is? Electric car.

I don't think the charging station is marked on this land plan. Yes, this plan is a plan approved by the CBC Code Regulation. So, the construction manager bet on the installation of an electric car charging station. Yes.

If the applicant's developer is here, where will the charging station be located? Can you tell me the approximate location in this plan? Is it in the south? There's a car wash in the south, so I can't do it. And there's a garbage collection center. Next is the east. Honestly, I don't know. I'm telling you based on 1 million patients. There could be about two. Yes, I think two or three parking spaces of this size will be needed. Power supply should also be considered, but the back of the building or

I think it's logical to the south, or I think it's possible to install it in the parking space next to the car wash. However, if there is a regulation related to the ADA-EV for electric cars for disabled people, it is necessary to decide where to install the ADA-EV parking lot that is made according to the standard.

Approximately near the garbage collection box. I think we can install it around the yellow part. About four spaces. I don't know what that space is for. Yes. I think those four spaces are probably where it's going to be installed. Yes. If you think logically, you're going that way. Yes. Yes. Yes. Do you have any more questions? I've already answered you. Now, come on. Yes, do you have any more questions?

I have one more question. Yes, we know that we are voting on the change of purpose and the installation of the cup. I don't know exactly because it's not in front of me.

And the third item in the resolution should be in line with the general plan, and the other is the installation location, operation advice, and operation method, which will probably be a few 달락.

There will be about 20 to 20 달락 in the PDF file. I don't know anything else. I think that's the main content. Yes, the cup survey results will start from page 20 of the PDF. Yes, attention.

This is the key content that should be investigated.

Section 1, 2, 3, 4, and 5 are the basic cup survey results. And from section 4 of page 22, additional survey results are obtained that are necessary for mainstream sales. Section 1, 2, 3, and 4 of the additional components are the results of the additional investigation. Yes, I understand. Thank you. In relation to the major sales, the previous information approved in 2021 is also applied to this case as well. However, the so-called excessive numbers are not included in this case, so it is based on the previous case. This is actually an extension of the deadline, so we are reviewing the content that was processed 5 years ago. Yes.

Since the main sales permit has not been issued, there is no over-the-counter phenomenon in the population survey area. I only got one permit, but nothing was issued. So this is the first case in this area.

아, 그렇군요. 네, 길 건너 7-11은 제외하고요. 그 구역 밖에 있네요. 네, 네, 네, 네. 지금은 괜찮습니다. 조용히 하세요. 잭, 괜찮아요. Yes, thank you very much. Do you have something you missed?

Yes, thank you. We will now have time to listen to the citizens' opinions on this case. If you would like to make a suggestion to the Planning Committee, please tell us for three minutes. You can come out as a single person now. Do you have a proposal? Yes, I do. Hello. I'm sorry to bring the team members today.

Hello. Thank you for taking the time to tell me tonight. I may have missed it in this chaos, but if it is a project that has already been approved, it should be carried out as it is. I agree that the color composition needs to be improved. To make this area a little brighter, improvement is needed. Because of the various restrictions on the surrounding environment, it is already a relatively rough space visually. So, I think we can consider using at least a little more luxurious materials. For example, fiber-based cement is not completely impossible, but it is more likely to exceed the budget than a project of this size. Second, it would be better to install sufficient lighting. In Paris, there are many places where people naturally wander around like this. Especially near Avocado Street. If there is a shortage of light or a shortage of traffic, more people will gather. The small square I'm talking about, Root Jerk, Root Jerk. It's close to the park, so it seems to be active. Of course, merchants and lenders may not always like such situations. So, I think it would be good to develop a solution that can resolve such problems and improve them in this development. If a project is considered not to proceed as it is now, I think it is necessary to review that part when considering that there are already many car washes and convenience stores on the streets of Paris. I just searched for a car wash, and there's a quickie and a quickie. There is also a self-washroom that is washed with coins, and all of these places are about 1.6 to 3.2km from 1 to 2 miles. Well, this area is already full of this type of development. However, as I said before, this is a story that only applies to those who have such a choice in Goryeo. Otherwise, I strongly recommend that this area be developed as beautifully as possible using its diverse landscape, splendid interior, and expensive materials. And, um, for the residents of the neighboring area, noise reduction is essential. I don't live in this area, but I know that the residents are trapped in a really small space. It's diagonal. At the end of the east, there is a huge warehouse looking down on the backyard, and now a very noisy building is about to enter there. So I think we have to do everything we can for the residents. Thank you for your time. Have a good evening. Thank you so much. Yes, thank you. Hello. I think other people want to say something. I can't see other people.

Now, after the public opinion hearing, I will return to the committee and proceed with the opinion and debate. I have no problem with this project. The fact that it has been approved in the current form is a great help to the project. The security office said it was okay to change the purpose. I reported it to the church, and the church said there was no problem. I don't think there's a big problem because there's no place in this area that's been approved. I agree with the color change proposal. Other than that, there's no problem with the project. There are no concerns about changing the purpose. In this position, I don't think there is a problem with the main sales itself, but there is a concern about the project itself, especially the permission related to the gas station. I don't think it's true what we wrote down when we talked about this problem. Well, let me tell you about the third survey result on air maintenance, safety and public welfare. The residential area that the gas station and the car wash area are close to is already in a state of overproduction, the gas quality problem is serious, and there is a lot of traffic. I don't think adding a 24-hour gas station and car wash here will help air maintenance. Therefore, I cannot make such a conclusion. Yes, therefore, I think there is a problem with the cup installation. Yes, I am. I think it's a good idea to have a small business center in this area. This area desperately needs a grocery store. It would have been better to have a small neighborhood market. However, I don't think it's enough to solve these problems with 8 feet height in a situation where traffic and noise are added. So, in my opinion, it is a big obstacle to this project and I am opposed to it. This project has been approved once before. 그런데 제가 색상표를 기억하려고 하는데, 음, 안타깝게도 색상표는 확실히 마음에 들지 않습니다. 해먼들, 위원님과 저는 색상표를 수정해야 한다는데 동의합니다. 차체, 색상과 합성, 흑연 색상을 업데이트해야 합니다. 물론 세차장에서 발생하는 소음 저감 문제도 여전히 우려됩니다. It's another car wash, but unfortunately, this car wash was approved five years ago. But I think this project can be carried out. As you know, there may be a problem, but if there is a loan problem or a similar problem within the area, I think it can be solved sufficiently through security or land monitoring. Yes, that's right. I think a lot of questions have already been asked to me, and I think the first thing that comes to mind is the answer. I've been to the security office and church. If the buildings right next to me are the problem, I don't care. If they don't have a problem, I don't have a problem either. In the end, it seems to be a color problem. Yes, we also want car wash service, but car wash companies don't like it very much. I think that kind of situation will come soon. But this is an economic decision, and it's not a problem that we can do. In the end, it's a problem that we have to make money. I think we need 29 to 30 car washes. People still drive their cars dirty. I've never seen so many car washes like this. But if you only enter the car wash for economic reasons like gas stations, In the end, office buildings will continue to be needed. Yes, we need much more multi-generation homes. In my opinion, multi-generation homes are first, not gas stations. It doesn't matter who listens. In my personal opinion, multi-generation homes are much more needed than 10 buildings at once. However, regarding this project, considering some of the things we discussed, In particular, I think it is a good idea to choose a bright color to harmonize with the surrounding environment. And as far as I remember, there was a discussion about replacing the wooden structure. I don't know if we talked about that discussion. The dam is really terrible. I've been there recently, and it was built when I bought a house near here in the late 80s, and it's still falling apart. It's like a tilted tower. So the durability is too low. The plastic team can't solve that problem. But 8 feet, about 2.4 meters, is 6 feet, about 2.8 meters, much lower. The 8-feet team will definitely make a difference. I'm considering other options, but this plan was approved five years ago. I remember exactly what happened five years ago, and at the time, as a co-chairman, There were many difficulties, but I don't think there are any problems. In my opinion, some of the things I talked about here are administrative problems, and some of them are already known, but it is especially important that the landscaping is 27% better. This is a much higher standard than the required standard, and I think the landscaping space between the hall and the building is very important. Another important point is security. The lighting and security are essential in that area. My wife often goes to Ira Luzerke, a Jamaican, and I know Luzerke very well. However, the atmosphere in that area is completely different during the day and at night. The lighting is really important. There are beautiful parks in that area, but this building is located in Motungi and is not far from the Dutch Brothers, which will be built someday. I'm not going to talk about that today, but my point is that I have no problem. But color composition is just one of the many considerations. The cooperation between the fence replacement and the owner of the house is an important problem. So, in my opinion, it would be good to consider various situations. Well, then, if there are no more necessary situations, let's look at the additional situations. 혹시 마지막으로 다른 요청사항이 있으신가요? 네, 금색 건물이나 금색 막대 장식은 원하지 않습니다. 네, 알겠습니다. 다음은 그 부분입니다. 걱정하지 마세요. 어차피 그렇게 하지는 않을 겁니다. 제안 내용을 살펴보겠습니다. 언제든지 수정하거나 추가 사항을 제안하셔도 됩니다. 요청사항을 읽어보겠습니다. The requested content is an exception for the operation of the vehicle gas station and the use of conditions for selling beer and wine, the I-20 license for external consumption, and the sale of grain within 1,000 feet of the church. The main requirements we request are 300 square feet, about 274 square meters of convenience stores, gas stations, beer, and grain sales. The key content is as follows. The project is excluded from the review as a non-progressive development project according to California Environmental Quality Act CEQA 15332, and it is limited to 3,227 square feet, 278 square meters in size, including auxiliary fuel. beer and wine sales, over 99,991 square feet, about 89,000 square meters, use permit for the construction of an automatic car wash, cup 26-0001 and use permit 26-00001. This is in favor of approving the conditions and additional provisions included in the decision. The first is the 33rd item, which is about the south and east border lines. In the 33rd item of 6A, the applicant developer cooperated with the surrounding residential owners to remove the existing fence along the east and east border lines and replace it with a 8-feet-high partition block wall and to install a pillar at a 100-feet interval. Number 17 is COA. RTA will refer to engineering items 15 and 23 related to inspection and approval. This is because it is part of the approval condition. There are also conditions for engineering. Number 15 and 23. Yes, I think this is it. And the color of the building is an administrative matter. So even if it's not white, it's better to use a brighter color. 그냥 한 가지 색상일 뿐이고, 말씀하신 것처럼 나무는 화강암인데 흰색보다 밝은 나무색, 더 갈색에 가까운 색으로 하는 게 좋겠어요. 이건 행정적인 문제고요. 또 다른

It would be better to use a bright color for the car body color. Yes, that's right.

And one more thing is to mark the location of the electric car charger in the sub-design. It's not marked, so I can't be sure if it's a must. Theoretically, we discussed it, but it's one of the suggestions that should be marked in the sub-design. The number of chargers required depending on the area and other general requirements. I heard that the southern region was designated, but from the point of view of engineering such as electrical equipment, which position would be appropriate? I think I've explained everything if I haven't missed anything. Yes. Then do you agree with this project approval?

We will submit an approval document including additional conditions. Yes. Isaac Lopez. I don't know. I agree. The vice president has agreed. Menz. Opposite. Lopez. Agree. C. Blee. Agree. Hammond. Agree.

3 votes in favor, 1 vote against. Thank you. Thank you.

Now, let's move on to Section 6B, Section 26 of the Zoning Code. As proposed by the city of Paris on the 26th of June, when the zoning code was revised, the 19th zoning code of the city of Paris was revised in accordance with the regulations of the 19.8.1 housing unit regulation and the 19.8.7 appropriate convenience facilities and housing regulations. I think the applicant, Paris, should immediately reject the proposal. All right. The mayor, Mr. Rafael Garcia, requested for action. The project is not subject to the California Environmental Quality Act. Based on the survey results included in this resolution, the Paris Regulation 19.8181, Ad.6, Regulation 19.8787, Ad.6, Ad.6, Ad.6, Ad.6, Ad.6, Ad.6, Ad.6, Ad.6, Ad.6, Ad.6, Ad.6, Ad.6, Also, there is an employee announcement, and I think you need to re-arrange ADO and Junior ADO. This is my request. Hello, members of the Planning Committee. The item in front of you tonight is a request for a request for a request for a request for a request for a request for a request for a request As you know, over the past few years, the state government has drafted various laws related to these types of buildings. As a result, we are trying to maintain consistency with the relevant laws and laws that are drafted by the state law and are continuously drafted. In addition, there are also provisions on providing reasonable convenience for disabled people. Therefore, in order to comply with the rule of law, we propose a proposal for the provision of ADU and JEDU provisions in 1981 and 1987. This is to provide clear standards and procedures for JEDO and JEDO, and their expansion and reasonable convenience supply requests. To explain the difference between JEDO and ADO in more detail, ADO is a system introduced a few years ago to provide the second residential space in residential areas in the central government. For years, in some cities in particular, there was a very strict restriction on the use of the second residential unit, ADO, In the case of an exception, the scope of use was very narrow. In this situation, a new law was passed, allowing the owner of the house to install the second housing unit. Generally, these housing units are called ADOs. ADOs can be attached or separated from existing homes, and there are a few requirements for the area, but basically you have to have a bathroom and kitchen. The difference between ADO and JEDO is that ADO can be built in various forms such as attachment, separation, expansion, and renovation, but JEDO is very limited. JEDO only means the renovation of some of the existing homes. Therefore, it cannot be a new building or a new structure, and it is not a separated form. It must be included within the existing home. For example, if you want to renovate an unused additional family room or living room, you can do that. However, you must meet a few conditions such as adding a bathroom facility or installing a shared bathroom and adding a kitchen or cooking facility. This is the purpose of the law. What we are going to do today is It adds clarity so that the zoning code document fits the purpose of the law. For this purpose, we will divide it into several categories and review it. The first is to modify the terms included in the zoning code and update the definition and reference points to maintain consistency with the current law. In addition, the application process is clearly defined to clarify the completeness, review, decision, delivery, and approval schedule. In 1981, the 050 factory added a clear text about the permissible area for ADU and JADUS. Some of the development standards have also been updated to clarify specific conditions related to the size of the ADU and JADUS, the size of the entrance, the residence of the owner, and the restriction on ownership. In addition, we are proposing solutions for unauthorized or illegal ADU and JADUS, including measures that can legalize unauthorized homes. In 1981, Article 150 includes specific housing requirements, including the government's requirements and the ADO application for approval. Finally, we are adding a sentence on reasonable convenience standards. The purpose of this procedure is to provide objective standards to evaluate requests in line with the 1987 Fair Housing Conditions. According to the California Environmental Quality Act, CQA 1506-1B3, the zoning code submitted to you tonight is excluded from the application of CQA according to CQA 1506-1B3. In other words, the limited zoning code is unlikely to have a major impact on the environment, so it is not applied by CQA. According to the CQA 1506-1B3, the project is excluded from the CQA application target, and based on the survey results included in the resolution, it is recommended to approve the 26,000-year-old Zoning Code, which has been updated to update the regulations related to the provision of 1,987 rational convenience, and to approve the 26,000-year-old Zoning Code. This concludes the presentation. If you have any questions about the case, please contact the employee anytime. Thank you for your time. Thank you. You have a lot to say. Who wants to go first? All right. Let's go back to the past. No. 2. One of the key contents of the presentation is about the purpose of 19.81.010.010. If the method of the California government law is in conflict, California government law comes first. This is the core. We must follow the California government law. If our opinion is not important, we must live up to it. One of them is the rational side. It may not have been specified in detail, but there are also AD units. Whether it's a Junior ADO or a regular ADO, reasonable convenience is a basic requirement. I had to add these things and there were a lot of related sentences. There are a lot of good things in there and good work is being done. Um, I... As I said before, the biggest difference between the two is... Um, in the case of Junior ADO, people who talked about it on YouTube, you know what I mean, right? Whether you own a house, rent it, or simply rent the space and use it, you have to come to the city hall and report it as ADO, that is, Junior ADO. What does that mean? In other words, I'm living there, and I'm just adding this. I can't say it's Junior ADO. Someone has to live in that facility, and that part is connected to the house, or as I said before, it's called Grandma's Room. I'd like you to explain. The name is not very good. It's not Grandpa Byulchae, it's Grandma Byulchae. Anyway, Grandma Byulchae used to be a separate building from the main body. The bathroom or other convenience facilities were separated by Byulchae. Now we call that place an ADU. Right. But the Junior ADU is used as part of the main body. Part of the house is designated as an ADU. Right. But the question is, you can often see people install indirect lighting in their rooms like this, but that's not the case. Yes, to be honest, you can't call that a Junior ADU. It's a way of adding a third address. There are many restrictions. It should be part of the body. So, to use such convenience facilities, you have to pay part of the house. In general, it's not always like that, but there are certain requirements. For example, the kitchen and bathroom should be included. Depending on how to proceed, you can choose a cost-effective method, but in general, you need an architect. The person in charge comes and designs.

Provide a blueprint, a new entrance location, and a system.

The system will clearly indicate the space to be included in the flatland. There are also a few limitations. For example, the area of the system should not exceed 650 sq. ft. If necessary, there are exceptions to make a small extension to create an entrance, but it is basically limited to 500 sq. ft. Therefore, we will check these standards to see if they meet the requirements of the main government. And I think I need to make this part clear. Of course, there must be a kitchen, kitchen space, and bathroom. The bathroom here means a hygienic space. And it is possible to rent or rent that space. Junior Diploma JDO is also possible. However, in my opinion, the parking space is not necessary because it is attached to the house within a radius of about 1.6 km from the traffic network. That's right. Then the parking standard will not change. However, if it is within 1 mile like SB79, SP79 is not applied. What law is applied? SP is a law related to ADO, but there is a limit that you cannot request additional parking space for JDO. That's right. If it's within 0.5 miles, about 800 meters from the traffic network, that's just an additional exit-related regulation. There is a part that has not been changed in the existing regulations. In this case, if it is within about 800 meters from the public transportation station, you cannot ask for additional parking space.

Yes, it's similar to SP-79, but it's not completely the same.

Yes, if you take a closer look at the meaning, it uses a very specific term. Almost everything can be applied. For example, if it is operated at a specific interval like a bus stop, it can be applied anywhere. Therefore, it is highly likely that most homes in the city will meet the conditions. Wow, I see. To add a few more things about small ADUs, There must be a separate entrance with the main house, but there must not be a separate bathroom.

However, if there is no separate bathroom, there must be a separate entrance with the main house, and there must be an internal entrance that connects directly to the living room. So, if there is no private bathroom in the JADU, there is an additional restriction that there should be an internal entrance between the house and the JADU. And the definition of JADU is that it should be located in the house and the area should not exceed 500 sq. ft. and there should be a kitchen. 또한, 소유주 거주 요건이 있는데, 즉 부동산 소유주가 주택이나 JADO 중 한 곳에 거주해야 한다는 거죠. 네, 그 차이점을 이해했습니다. 다른 질문 있으신가요? 제가 J님께 여쭤보려고 했는데, 음, 저는... It's a bit complicated and difficult to understand. I understand that reasonable convenience is not directly a threat, but I don't know if it came from HCD or where it came from and if it can be expressed more simply because the sentence is quite complicated. Yes, that phrase was brought directly from the Public Housing Act. It's a federal or state public housing law, but it seems to be a state law, but there is a similar federal law. Therefore, it was brought from the law as it is. In my opinion, it is to show that Lee Jeon-si's decision was quite subjective. In other words, in order to approve a reasonable convenience supply, it was necessary to confirm that the reasonable convenience supply requested by the City Development Service Director does not have a negative impact on the use of surrounding real estate. It can be seen that the decision made by the Director is somewhat vague and subjective. Therefore, the purpose of the revised Public Housing Act is to provide objective standards. Um, so first of all, The required reasonable convenience is not a direct threat to the health or safety of others. In other words, it should be confirmed that there is no serious risk of physical harm or significant physical damage to other people's assets. And in the next sentence, we talk about how to judge it. It is stated that the provision of convenience is a direct threat to the health or safety of others or a significant physical damage to other people's property is based on individual evaluation based on objective evidence rather than a simple guess or fixed concept of convenience or a specific disability or the entire disability. It is to prevent the fixed concept of how the fact that the disability is related can have an impact on the decision of the director, whether it is conscious or unconscious. The ultimate purpose of this law is to protect the rights of the disabled and to ensure that the disabled are treated and discriminated against fairly compared to non-disabled people. In other parts, it is stated that all six conditions must be met in order to be recognized as a regional convenience facility.

In other words, the person in charge must meet all six conditions in order to approve reasonable convenience. Therefore, if one of these is not met, reasonable convenience cannot be approved. For this reason, the law must be amended so that the person in charge does not be forced to follow standards that can violate the Public Housing Act and other standards. In most cases, the resident who is trying to install a disabled convenience facility, JADO, does not have the right to make the unit accessible. However, because it is a commercial real estate, especially an apartment, and because it is a commercial building, a certain ratio of 5% must be guaranteed to be approachable. In other words, regardless of these six numbers, 5% of the limited units must be accessible under certain legal conditions. It will probably be regulated according to the California Construction Law or similar laws. However, the 19.87조, which we are reviewing these changes, is not a separate topic, but a topic of another kind, not related to ad hoc housing. The reason why it is mentioned with the ADO amendment is because it pointed out that not only the ADO group in Seohan, which was sent by the HCD Housing Development Department, but also the standards should be amended. Both groups are related to housing, but the 19.87.070 group must be clear that it is not applied to those who simply build an ADO. For example, it is for those who want to get out of the obligation to comply with certain area setting regulations. For example, it may be stated that iron bars cannot be installed in the front yard between houses and roads. However, if there is a person who needs a fence for safety reasons, such as having an disability or having an unmarried family, you can request reasonable convenience to be exempted from the district setting regulations after the disability. This is the case. Yes, I understand. Thank you for your explanation. 문구가 다소 복잡해서 이해하기 어려웠지만 도움이 되었습니다. 안타깝게도 주정부는 모든 것을 명확하게 규정하지 않고 배타적, 이기보다는 포용적인 방향으로 규정을 마련해 놓는 경우가 많습니다. 당신은 아주 친절하게 대해 주고 있고 저도 주정부에 아주 친절하게 대할 겁니다. 하지만 그 사람을 건드리지 않겠습니다. 특히 직접적인 위협이 되는 상황이었으니까요. 좀 과장된 표현이긴 하지만 요점은 그리고 이 부분으로 마무리하겠습니다만 만약 소형 부속주택 ADO 을 짓는다고 가정해봅시다. This is not a story related to the Disability Discrimination Act, but if an disabled person wants to build a private house with a separate entrance, they have to install a slope. Then, should they have all the items they need in the shower room? If there is a person who claims that the Disability Discrimination Act, ADA, should be adhered to because the private house is attached to the body and there is a separate entrance, There is a problem. What happens in this situation? Yes, I think that those who build private homes must abide by the construction law. However, I do not think that the disability discrimination law must be obeyed. They build their own buildings on their own land. The city must abide by ADA, the American disability law, for public property and programs, but I do not know if ADA will be applied if a self-employed person wants to build an ADO villa in his house. If a young person wants to connect an ADO to a house with a separate entrance, even if it is not an ADA regulation, Yes, that's right. The same goes for those who rent an ADO. The responsibility for reasonable convenience is between the building owner and the city. They say this. I have a real estate of my own, but I cannot comply with the construction law requirements applied to me. However, because I am disabled, I must be exempted from these conditions. I need reasonable convenience to not be discriminated against by my disability and equal treatment of non-disabled people. Theoretically, it is more likely that someone will build a single-use residential facility, JADO, with a disabled tenant, and provide the tenant with the convenience they need. However, if you want to help the tenant of a building, you can request a reasonable convenience for these conditions set by the city because it will help the tenant in the city. I don't know if that's the same kind of connection as the person applying directly to the city. I don't have any details. In my opinion, I think you can apply for this kind of disability protection or flexibility for a rich family living in your real estate. But I'm not sure if that applies to the person. As of now, there is no information about that part. Yes, residential buildings. So, I think it's grade 4. If someone chooses to improve the approachability of the unit, they can choose the necessary convenience facility level. You don't have to have a complete convenience facility, and if you want to, you can do that. It's a good example of a slope. Uh, the common cases can be applied to scenarios. For example, let's assume that there is a staircase that leads to the front door to the owner of the house. Generally, the staircase is almost the same height as the finished floor. However, it is not allowed to install a 경사로 in the 안 마당 후퇴 구역, although the owner's parents or family members need a 경사로 because they are old people. In addition, in the case of a single house, the installation of a 경사로 in the 건축법 is not a matter of duty. Therefore, the city cannot refuse the request and say that these structures cannot be installed in the 안 마당 후퇴 구역. In this situation, someone comes and says, I have a disability or someone in my family has a disability, so please allow me to set up a slope in the after-retreat area in the front yard. And they will submit documents that show that it is reasonable and fair and that we can cooperate. If the reasonable side can be accepted without provision, that is also another option. However, for example, if a slope is needed, this is a common situation. It doesn't happen often, but it does. Once or twice a year, when such requests come in, we try to provide as much convenience as possible. This is a law that applies regardless of whether it is an ADO, a subordinate housing unit, or not. There is no difference for us. It is not important to have a permanent residence permit. As soon as someone requests, they can be applied to the relevant law if they can meet six conditions and justify diseases or other reasons. Yes, I understand. My main concern is that there is a separate entrance to the GDA, a general residential unit, and there is a separate entrance, so you have to go in from the side, not the front door, and there is a door 10 feet high. So if you just try to solve the problem, they will go to the city hall and reveal my position, and I will reveal my position. They will contact you. The point is that I am a former city official. I always have a strong desire to protect them. What I'm telling you is that they don't know anything. They only contact people with a lot of money. I'm just here to let you know. The point is that if you plan to pay the cost, you have to allow them to install a slope in a separate entrance. Of course, such a situation may never occur, but if a separate entrance is not good, it can be a problem. The only brain tumor was on the side, not the front. However, if you have to pay for a separate entrance, people generally want a separate entrance, a separate kitchen, and a separate bathroom. However, since there are many elderly people in this city, In a situation where you don't know when to retire, such a problem can occur. So I'm always moving forward with these problems. That's why I'm causing trouble. That's right. But I think it's out of the frame. And I think it's worth thinking about. I don't have to do that, but what should I do? There are a lot of expressions here, but the point is that this scenario can occur, and I don't want to be trapped in such a situation. As you know, the main government just gives this and that. I'm just saying that this is how it should be done. But what's really important is that the city government implements it. That's the key part. I'll write something down in a document. You have to do this. Yes, then how should we generally implement it? Anyway, that's all I want to say. I won't take any more time. I think I've covered a lot of things. And overall, it's very good. If you have any other opinions, please let me know. Yes, please wait a moment. I want to check if you all understand. All right. I'll have public comment time from now on. If you want to make a comment on the planning committee, please come forward. Anyway, I have to tell you. Please come out in a group. You can tell me for three minutes. There is no public comment time now. I'll finish the public comment time. Now, freely tell me about the debate, analysis, criticism, and praise. All right. All right. Thank you for answering so many questions. As you know, our committee is meticulous, so there will be some points to point out. No matter how good the presentation is, I will always find something to catch. Have fun. All right. I'll go back now. I don't want to give anyone the right to speak. All right. The item is the zoning code. It is the Zoning Code 26-00004. Zoning Code Zoning Code 26-00004. I have made a suggestion at 1 o'clock. I'm sorry. This is the Zoning Code Zoning Code Zoning Code. Oh, I see. I made a mistake. Thank you. The request was made by a good choice. Thanks to you, I was able to face the crisis. Article 26-15 of the case is based on the contents of the case based on the contents of the contents of the contents of the contents of the contents of the contents of the contents of the contents 감사합니다. 추가된 내용은 없었던 것 같습니다. 몇 가지 추가 설명이 필요합니다. 네. 승인 동의가 있습니까? 제가 승인 동의를 하겠습니다. 네. 제가 찬성하겠습니다.

Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes.

Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. This consent has been approved. Yes. Thank you.

You were trying to get me out. Oh, I see. Thank you. Now it's time to listen to the citizens' opinions on the 7th case. The citizens who want to make a suggestion to the Planning Committee on the missing cases can speak at any time. If you come out as a representative and wait for the chairman's call, you can speak for 3 minutes. Since there is no opinion, I will end the citizen opinion hearing and move on to the case. I don't think there is a case number 8. Then, I will move on to the report and notice of the committee in the case. Mr. Lopez. Yes.

No, I don't have anything to say. I just thought summer was over too soon. The kids went back to school. I think it's been about a week already. I hope the kids have a good new year and I hope you have a good time with your parents. Thank you to the parents who wake up in the morning and take the kids and prepare them. I hope the kids have a good new year and a good summer. And I hope you all have a good night. I agree. Congratulations on the start of the new year, and I hope you have a good flu season. Please get the flu vaccine. I got it today, but I thought I should let everyone know. It's free, so please get it. I don't have anything else to say. Welcome back, everyone. I'm looking forward to the next meeting. Yes.

That's right. It's been a long time. It's not bad to think about how to hold a meeting again, but I think it will get better in the future. Thank you. And thank you for waiting patiently. There are a lot of things going on in Paris. And to talk about the target, whether you like it or not, I've been there about three times, and it's really huge and clean. I'm sure you'll be a strong competitor to Walmart. The parking lot is really well made. I'm usually a critical person, but the parking lot is really well organized. And I think the school is getting better and better. It's definitely better. It would have been nice if IHOP was painted white. I don't know who made that decision, but that's another story. Um, I think you should have some continuity. I don't know if we should discuss that part again. Anyway, I think it's a really good place and worth visiting at least once. Better Buzz is doing well. I live 2 minutes away from there and see it every day. It's getting better and better, so there are positive changes happening. Dutch Brothers is also going to open soon, but I think the battle between Betabuzz and coffee is taking place in the city. I really understand. Yes, that corner is getting more and more lively. I'm grateful. And later, I have to ask what happens to the right-hand support fund. I've always been curious about this. It's nice to have CVS on the stairs. Anyway, the school has started again. Some schools started on Thursday, some on Wednesday. Anyway, the school has started again. The weather is too hot. I hope the children don't get too tired. It's okay because there's a shade and water. Now, we will deliver updates and notifications to the planning staff. Thank you.

On September 2, the Pacific Lantana, Pacific Lantana residential development project, which was postponed in July, will be discussed again. It is located on Match Road, Match Road. Today's meeting is just this. Also, I'm glad that Target Target store is coming in. It's a cool store and the parking lot is always crowded. Right. I will let you know as soon as building number 8 is confirmed. Many new things are happening in Paris, and you will see many construction sites in the future. Many really good things are happening in Paris. Thank you.

Ah, then shall we talk again later? I will tell you about the meeting of the City Planning Committee held in October. Yes, I understand. You can announce it now.

Yes. On October 14, there is a symposium of the City Planning Committee in Irvine City. It is an event that is held all day. If you want to attend, please let Silvia know. I will make a reservation. Irvine. Oh.

Lawyer, would you like to serve the meal? You can come to the office.

I'll guide you. We'll serve you. Yes, that's right. Yes, yes, thank you. Yes, Sylvia, thank you. This person is really a regular every time. Then, if you don't mind, I'll end the meeting. If you don't mind, it doesn't matter who you choose. If you don't mind, I'll all agree. I know the air conditioner is on, but you still have to get out of here. You get it, right? Yes. Thank you to all of you who watched. Have a good night.