Library Commission - Regular Meeting

Monday, January 27, 2025
Transcript
Video
Agenda

About this meeting

Government Body
Library Commission
Meeting Type
Library Commission
Location
Hayward, CA
Meeting Date
January 27, 2025

Transcript

376 sections (from 460 segments)

0:000

Hello?

0:402

people. Thank you. For those who are able and would like to please stand for the pledge

1:050

Thank you.

1:092

Miss Murphy, do we have any teleconferencing or consideration?

1:13 – 1:270

We do not. Commissioner.

1:282

Commissioner. Commissioner.

1:360

Commissioner. Would be there to Commissioner Porter? Commissioner. Here. Commissioner Commissioner. Purcell? Here.

1:442

Commissioner Stangaya? Present. And council member Roach? Present. Thank you. Do we have any public comments today?

1:52 – 2:070

We do not. Thank you. However, has everyone had a chance to, review the minute? Do I have a motion for the floor? Motion will do it. Thank you. Do I have a second? One second.

2:092

That's Commissioner Fredericks? Thank you. Commissioner Porter.

2:152

you. Do we have any discussion? Any corrections?

2:220

No? Call question?

2:252

All those in favor

2:250

of approving the minutes as written, say aye. Aye.

2:292

All those opposed? Thank you.

2:340

With regard to new business, we have

2:36 – 2:512

guests today, so I'm gonna make a motion to change the agenda a bit. I would like to move to, move item d, update on libraries and immigration issues in front of item a.

2:530

I move that we move

2:552

item d in front of item a.

3:000

I have a motion

3:012

on the floor. Is there a second?

3:033

Yes, sir.

3:04 – 3:152

Thank you, Commissioner D. Miguel. Any discussions? No. I've called the question. All in favor of removing item d and from item a,

3:150

say aye. Aye. All of the opposed say nay.

3:202

Thank you. Do we have

3:210

a motion to approve the rest

3:232

of the agenda as is now with the with the mood item?

3:270

Motion to approve what you said.

3:322

The agenda has to be as amended. Is there a second? I'll second that. Thank you, commissioner Porter. Any discussion?

3:412

Nope. A call question. All those in favor, please say

3:430

aye. Aye. Those opposed, say nay.

3:472

Thank you. We will begin with our guests.

3:52 – 4:140

So Yes, please. Good. So we have with us today our city attorney, Michael Lawson, deputy city attorney, Salita Walz. Is that correct? Yes. He is the attorney. Yes. Yeah. Okay. So just I did send out before we go in that.

4:14 – 4:510

I just want to mention briefly. I sent out some information to you as you all know with our Jason. With our change with our new president and some. Lot of questions about these issues. And in 2017, also, when president Trump was in power, we had similar situations.

4:51 – 5:350

A lot of the local policy states and local policies sort of seem to run contrary to what is happening and what the direction we get from the federal government. So this is some different agencies or special agencies that collect information about the public in a difficult situation. In 2017, the the California attorney general's office put out guidelines on how to respond if we get requests for information and the cases involving integration issues. And we have updated that information now and resent it out to us. So I did send it out to you.

5:35 – 6:090

It's called promoting safe and secure guidelines for all. And just to give you a little background on this, this is also they've sent out directions to schools, to colleges, various similar routes about a similar situation. And we already, in the library, had very strict privacy and confidentiality laws, which have nothing to do with integration. It certainly has to do with how we protect information. So a lot of what you said does fit in exactly with what we do.

6:09 – 6:320

But in addition to that, the city for this Sanctuary City. On June 2017, the city council passed a resolution declaring us Sanctuary City, and so that also has certain good protections. And so with that, I'm just gonna turn it over to our attorneys to if you have something to add, or we can do it in the discussion.

6:35 – 7:133

Let me start by introducing myself. Michael Lawson, city attorney. I'm joined with by Sandita Waltz, who actually serves as the legal counsel to the library, and she's the a team. I'm the b team. No. No. I'm just. So I'm just gonna let me just make a few opening comments. Unfortunately, the federal government is not our friend. I'm very involved in the city attorney's activities around the state.

7:14 – 7:433

I attended a session last week of new mayors and council members in Sacramento, like, 400 officials. This is a Northern California session. There's a similar session in Southern California later this week. What are the issues that I'm hearing? Immigration, birthright citizenship, gender identification issues.

7:45 – 8:243

Then over the weekend, I think about 12 inspectors general were fired. They serve as the independent watchdogs of various federal agencies. They are appointed by Congress. It's unclear as to whether the president had that authority, but all three branches of government are no longer independent here. So more to the point this morning, federal ICE immigration customs enforcement officers conducted a raid at a Home Depot type facility in San Jose.

8:24 – 9:223

And as I understand that they did not necessarily give notice to the Santa Clara Police Department, which is typically just typically been their practice. It is possible that those kinds of raids can take place here. The mayor and city manager and police chief and Hayward have been collaborating on Ben and O sessions. They've developed, really clear communications messages that are going out to the public, to the school district, to the sheriff, to nonprofit community based agencies with the idea of making sure that we have clear and accurate information, up to date information to the extent possible. And I believe that the mayor will be making a very clear statement tomorrow night at the council meeting, so you might wanna listen in.

9:22 – 9:503

I'm not sure what point in the meeting that that will occur, but the messaging will be real clear and will support and align with the city's sanctuary city declaration from 2017. And nothing has changed in that regard. And I believe that, the library director has shared the attorney general's messaging for libraries. I have a copy. I have one copy in case you don't have that.

9:51 – 10:233

As well as the city's, administrative regulation. I also have that with me. So just with that introduction, you know, let me just, back up and allow Sangeetha to make additional comments specifically to the library. And please note, we actually have had not on immigration issues, but we've had FBI agents come to the library wanting information about patrons. That was about two years ago.

10:23 – 10:573

Very interesting experience in dealing with a federal investigative agency coming to a library. So it happens. They come without warrants, and we push back. So that's one thing that really stands out about federal investigative agencies even when there was a fairly sympathetic federal administration. Okay? I don't think there are any rules anymore, quite frankly, and I don't think anything is predictable anymore. So

11:00 – 11:241

I don't I don't know what to add to that, to be honest with you. I I think that often we know what you know, like, the beta news changes rapidly. I you know, I think there's been discussions about whether we want to do sort of an internal policy, you know, that that's different what we already have. But it you know, I think to sort of highlight my goal and JC's point, we didn't have procedures now. We have policies now.

11:24 – 12:121

We had a conversation just last week with, you know, PD sort of Hayward Police Department. The fact the police chief highlighted for us what their current practice is when, you know, when and if there is a raid, as as Michael mentioned, we should check we should be getting notified. They they are not, required to assist, just as library employees are not required to proactively assist. If if an ICE agent walks through the door, we can't we can't hinder their their front like, you know, we can't hinder them, but we can't we don't we don't have to assist. We can, and I would say, you know, in most cases, if they have a document and we you know, you, staff will have the opportunity to say we need to speak to someone.

12:12 – 12:521

We need to speak to an administrator. We need to speak, like, legal counsel. And and I think, really, what what this is gonna depend on is is everyone having sort of stay calm in crisis. Right? These may seem like sort of crazy times and but, you know, I think at the end of the day, we'll, you know, we'll rely on on staff to to stay calm and say, look. We need to we need to look at this further. We, you know, need to we need to pass the bond to put someone above us. We need to to seek legal counsel. And there is room for that in in state law. There was room for that in our, you know, in our existing policies.

12:521

And and I think I don't know. Beyond that, I'm I'm not sure what else to add.

12:580

I'd like

12:58 – 13:113

Sandipa to share how library staff are being trained. What can you share with the commission and with us about I think we can with you. I'm sorry.

13:110

Yeah. If I don't know. Yeah. So thank you. Thank thank you for that.

13:18 – 13:570

So we do have very strict policies in place because, again, as I said, California has very strict laws about confidentiality and privacy. So every staff member who comes in gets trained in this, and I actually orient every staff member myself. But we do talk about this. Any request for private information about the about about a patron, what they're doing in the library, what they're reading, any of their address, any of that information, we do not give out. The only time any information is given out is when we have a legal court order or subpoena.

13:57 – 14:410

And this applies to ICE agents also because ICE agents typically will come with what they call administrative and advance order, and that is not a court order and not a subpoena. So that you know, the only person who is authorized to give out information about patrons, that is myself. So they all know any request that comes has to be referred to them without out of them reacting to. And when when we get that, our policy is always to go to the security and its office. And I will tell you, I have dealt with this from the time of the terrorist, you know, when the and the Patriot Act was passed.

14:41 – 15:180

It is a very similar situation already. So I feel to dealt with this over the years. Like, we resolved, like, we expect this. Know, me take this call to get talk to the library director. Also, if ICE agents are not allowed any public service, they're not allowed into the areas that are not

15:452

I'm sorry. That's.

15:474

We don't need information on in person status.

15:51 – 16:160

So all we may possibly have is an address. Right? Correct. So you only need the address for establishing residency for purposes of the library part. Right? Correct. Why do you need to retain the address? We do need to retain the address just in our records because people do come. We come communicate with the patrons all the time. We send them emails.

16:16 – 16:410

We send them so we do need that information. But, generally, the email Right now. Email or phone number, I'm thinking. So why do we even why do we even need to retain addresses for these by ICE agents? Can't we just establish residency for purpose of library card, have a phone number or a text on file, because that's how I've only been communicated with by email, not even by phone.

16:41 – 17:220

So is there really a need to keep that information for future possibly used by us. It's a it's a very good point. We do not all of our patrons have email or could communicate through electronic means, but we do oh, pardon me. Yeah. But we are just but it is something it's a good point. We could see if there's some way for us to to do with that. But I we can look into it, but we do use addresses. We do use. And, also, part of our whole the way California libraries are done is we do we have to be a California library resident Yeah. To get a free IP card in California.

17:220

So that's part of we go through the process. We do regularly update that information check, but it's a good point. I can take it back and see if that is if that is an option for us.

17:331

Can we communicate bands to the library? Like, for example, if someone is banned from you, is that

17:400

the sort of information you

17:411

might communicate over with the full address?

17:43 – 18:140

Or Yeah. We always would use that. Yeah. For all well, that's a very good point. For all legal purposes, we would need the address. At least for now, I don't know. I'd have to look into It's I think we can just say it's. Question for. I can't imagine what ICE would want to do with letter records except finding addresses. Is there something else that you anticipate an ice warrant or ice and peanut might be requesting from the vet?

18:163

Certainly, one of the warrant. Yeah. But what do

18:200

they see what do they see? What do you anticipate the language will be? You Do have an idea along that line? How would you capture lives? Experience

18:30 – 19:173

so, one, it's our understanding, and it's only an understanding from what we read, is that ICE is for example, ICE conducted a raid in Kern County last week at a, like, an agricultural like, a dormitory where ag workers work. And Kern County is probably pretty sympathetic to law enforcement advice. Mhmm. So I don't think they have a problem finding the facility. What we're told is that ICE has specific criminal targets presumably based on investigative material that's been compiled.

19:17 – 20:023

So they have names, and that's what we're told. Our experience with the FBI, the library, a couple of years ago Mhmm. They were looking for a specific user. They had a name. And, apparently, they had information that the patron was using computers for access, Internet access. They did not have a warrant. And so even though they had some suspicion with the name, they didn't have a warrant including probable cause. So they were not allowed to have that information. So I think we would have the same protocol for I showing up asking for specific library users. We want a warrant.

20:03 – 20:173

We want a declaration of probable cause. Whether or not they have specific specific criminal investigation, I think at a minimum, we would want that kind of order and justification.

20:201

Know, that's probably what they're looking for.

20:230

They'll have some computers that they know. Yeah.

20:26 – 21:163

I mean, just we are being, I think, reasonable using our past experience, but I think we're gonna have some challenges. You know, I think we're gonna be dealing with some new protocols, and we're gonna just have to be thinking strategically, going forward. Now there is litigation that's been filed. There's been class action litigation filed, by a number of federal, state attorneys general to enforce, you know, state law on immigration policy. I don't know how federal judges are gonna handle this kind of litigation, but that may be the only protection we have, at least in the short term.

21:17 – 21:353

I would support Genti's real common sense direction to the library staff, and that is be disciplined, be cool, be thoughtful, and don't back down. We're not gonna get arrested. Library staff will

21:352

not get

21:35 – 22:183

arrested for, just expressing library policy. Those agents will leave, and they'll go away. They might get loud. They might get threatening, but they don't have any authority to arrest any any city staff. So I very much support what we're trying to do really at the counter level, if you will. But there are gonna be a lot of unknowns with this going forward. A lot of unknowns. It's already started in a week and a half into the, you know, the administration. They don't have any they don't have any progress. But I really appreciate your point.

22:19 – 22:420

That's less helpful as we can. If they get the records, the records can very good use for them if all they got is the phone number and email. You know? And if there's 20 people by the name of Jose Gonzalez, who could they gonna be? So I'm just trying to think he'll make it more vague just in anticipation of the fact that, you know, you might get a federal law a law passed.

22:422

Well, you know sort of up ends everything.

22:44 – 23:073

Email addresses or phone numbers, like cell phone numbers or even landline numbers. You know, they probably have to go to Verizon or AT and T or, you know, Xfinity to actually get the names, addresses, and more detailed information. We don't have So but, you know, they'll probably do that if they

23:07 – 23:200

actually want that person. But it's another stumbling block. Makes it a little more difficult. Or have a question. Yeah.

23:20 – 23:395

I was wondering just from the conference point of view. So first of all, I guess if there's likely policy, it will not trump state law. Right? So so I guess the staff will know I mean, they understand we have policy. You have I mean, if, for example, whoever's coming in is citing a lawful requirement, then, of course, we comply. Like, they have a warranty compliant procedure.

23:39 – 23:530

But dietary policy sorry. Dietary policy is based on state law. We haven't made it up. So we cite exactly what laws they are. So we all our privacy confidentiality is all based on state law. We

23:54 – 24:203

examine warrants. We examine subpoenas. Those are come over to our come over to our office right away. So anything that says, you know, warrant for, you know, customer x, there has to be a detailed declaration behind that. Our office is gonna look at that closely. So just handing it to a staff person is just not gonna work. So the I

24:205

I couldn't stop with the task for reasonable time to, you know, get legal

24:571

You can do additional training in 2017 in response.

25:00 – 25:280

So I was not here. I was in Montgomery County, but we did. And all did. We all it's very much, you know, something that all IPs are dealing within California. Yeah. But we don't over here have a policy based on that. But, you know, what the attorney general is asking us to do is make sure we have a new policy so we won't call that. Yeah. We just have our regular privacy issues.

25:33 – 25:583

No. I've not read at least so far about libraries being targeted. This morning, it was like a Home Depot, type facility, having agricultural facilities, dorms, things of that nature. But churches and schools are not safe spaces. Libraries are probably not gonna be safe spaces. Mhmm.

26:03 – 26:456

And I'm not going to guess 100% on warrant, okay, to do what the law says. I'm just thinking to you, like, what 2017 was about. I reported somebody who lives in Hayward to the FBI, and or I said they needed to be reported repeatedly because they said they wanted to be at January 6 and were threatening to kill me. So we might be seeing things like terrorists are using the library to harass people. So that might be the other side of it. You know, trying not to get traced and going through the library because we're gonna have a lot of terrorists released, and there are some in the area.

26:483

Yeah. I think about 1,500.

26:506

Yeah. Well, there were a lot that weren't caught. There are

26:535

a lot who were not caught. That's correct. Okay.

26:556

And there might be people it's like, you wanna go after the other, you know, you've got some. I don't know. I'm just you know, that would be nice, actually.

27:050

I think that's a different issue than. Well, I gotta be saying.

27:096

But it would be the same policy. You know? You have a warrant. You don't come.

27:17 – 28:013

These are some really, really good questions. Really, really appreciate your thoughtful support of library, library staff. I think we wanna be, rational, disciplined, but also nimble and flexible. There are a lot of lawyers, around the state, public lawyers, private lawyers who are who who really understand the urgency of the moment. There are a lot of, at least in my profession, a lot of online forms trying to give us as much information that is accurate.

28:01 – 28:333

But it's sort of like a moment by moment kind of a deal. Right? So I think Sandeep and I are really up to date. We're communicating with the city manager, the mayor, the police chief. And they are, by the way, having daily meetings just to sort of understand what's happening at least at the city level in order to adjust communications and strategies. There's a lot going on locally, statewide, in response to what's happening generally.

28:340

I don't. Don't know. The last word on this.

28:36 – 29:054

I was just gonna say because there's so much chatter online about ICE agents being spotted around town, and I wonder if some of it is just fearmongering people just trying to rile people up. And so I know the city then is you know, the the chief tries to sort of dispel those rumors when he can, you know, confirm it. And I you know, I'm glad that everybody's responding so quickly and trying to get the word out that this you know, there was one Southland Mall. I said that Southland Mall, that wasn't true. And so I think, yeah, people are purposely fair at this point.

29:050

I do have one question about this, though.

29:06 – 29:184

So if somebody was a patron in the library and, say, ICE came in and tried to sort of question somebody, you know, and they were able to get this card, that doesn't stop ICE from potentially detaining them. Right? They could still detain them if

29:180

they had some suspicion.

29:204

They're just not giving them any extra information to is that right?

29:24 – 29:551

Yeah. ICE will continue to. We can't hinder if they're here to depict someone. If they're here, like, we can't hinder them in any way. We don't have an obligation to assist or provide information. Mhmm. But but, yes, they can go about their work as long as it's in a public space. So we can't and we mentioned we can't you know, they can't be in, you know, private spaces, employee building spaces. But, yeah, you're right. If they're here detaining someone and that's something that we should just allow them to do, unfortunately. Is

29:560

there a warrant? Could they go on the apartment's fences? If they had a warrant, we would take it to the school attorney to make sure it is

30:046

But then they could. Is that a warrant?

30:061

Depending on, you know, we would review it and if it seemed legitimate and yeah. They make you

30:130

Perfect. Then

30:14 – 30:313

And I would distinguish, an arrest warrant with search warrant. Search warrant would have to specify, you know, specific areas. It's a private area. The warrant would have to specify that. There would have to be a declaration around that. But, Katie, can you sort of explain the the red cards?

30:35 – 31:160

Red cards, these are cards that you can hand to a NICE agent if they're coming into your house or coming onto your private space, and it basically talks about your constitutional right to protect, do not allow other people to talk to your into your home. And it basically says, I have to write to a lawyer, and you can't come into my house. So that and so we actually do have one of the things that I'll just say part of this is part of what we do as the primary we are one of by a lot of them are more trusted government agencies. Most people are very comfortable over here. We do a lot of citizenship programs.

31:16 – 32:010

We do bilingual you know, we do literacy programs. We've had a lot of programs where some and we don't ask. I do. Do I have to have you documented with legal people in this country? So we do have this. A lot of people in who are asking for our services, so we've made these available. Or and this, again, twenty seventeen, this is what we all libraries all libraries were doing. We're doing this now also. But I just want to say one of the big fears that are going on, they do come to us for information, whether they're looking for a lawyer. There is a lot of fraudulent services that become available where people will say that I am an immigration lawyer, and they aren't an immigration lawyer.

32:01 – 32:310

They are they are trapped into and then are reported. So there is a lot of fear between more reliable sources. It is a very difficult time, I would say, the public. It is very stressful for the staff also when they're dealing with questions like that all the time, and people really don't know what's happening at personal lives. So it's been a very, very tough time. That's one of the things. We're just trying to make these available. You don't have to go and ask us for it. It's just time out there for you to do.

32:32 – 32:441

The city website has resources available too, and I can read those reviews on Google. So if that's something that the public wants to know more about, you know, that's all should be information on the city websites.

32:46 – 33:313

So let me just say, and I mean this in a good way. The library is our most fun fun. The library gives us questions that I've never seen before. It's just an international center. I mean, everybody comes to the library, young, old. Just there's just an amazing array of questions and challenges that come from the library. And you all are just a great client, and I mean that in the best way possible. I think we just love I mean, you might think that the police department might be the busiest one, and it's not. It's the library. Would you agree?

33:311

I don't know. I don't know about that.

34:40 – 34:520

This is the time when I bring our mid year budget review to show you where we are and how we are how we're positioned. So maybe just for the next. Sorry. One second. Okay.

34:522

It was it was the additional documents emailed from director Abbott. It's not

34:560

the first one, but the second. It's not that's not progressing. Yeah. Oh,

35:186

Yeah. We'll just scroll like this.

35:194

It's not going into presentation mode.

35:21 – 35:320

Okay. So just go to the next screen. No. More. It's not moving. Oh, it's not going on there?

35:324

Well, it's on there. The first slide is there.

35:35 – 36:040

If you just didn't encode it. No? I I can't. Well, as as we're getting this, I can just tell you. So we are right on target the way they're doing, we should be you know, we are right where we should be.

36:04 – 36:220

It's one of the only areas where we look like we have spent more than we should have is in salaries, and we are at about 67% of what we above our salaries at this time. And the reason okay. Okay. Got it. Okay.

36:22 – 36:500

There you go. Alright. So that's just an overview of what we how we get our money. We depend on the general fund, but I'll tell you one of the things we have done really well this year is we have actually almost well, over 20% of our budget is through grants and donations. We've purely done an exceptional job raising money because the general fund doesn't give us very much funding.

36:50 – 37:200

And so that's what our it looks like. Most of our money comes from the general fund. We get some from grants and donations. We have some, which is still continuing from the Americans, the ARPA funding, which was the American Rescue Plan. And that was that was during the pandemic, and so we have to spend that by 2026. So we will give it some time, but we still have some money back from from that. That. The next screen. Okay. So this shows you how we spend our money.

37:20 – 37:530

Majority of our our money goes towards salaries and benefits. Internal service charges are things like our IT and our cleaning, you know, things like that, facility maintenance, all of that. So you can see we have very little what we call discretionary funds. There's a little bit for supplies and services, and that's really what we where we have some discretion and for other nations and events. And this is our expense categories.

37:53 – 38:150

We you can just go to the next one. And ARPA expenses, we've spent that. That has been largely for tech lending library is what we've used it for. Some of it is for our lease branch renovation. So this is where we are.

38:15 – 38:520

I was just saying. So in salaries and benefits, a we're little bit higher than we want to be, which is at 67%. But the only reason for that is because of the the negotiated cost of living increases for our for all of the different union groups. And those that's why it looks like we're at 67%, but the city will adjust it because the when we made our budget, we made it based on the previous pre COLA salaries, but now there have been increases. And so it looks like they'll put a little bit higher than we should be, but we're actually right on target.

38:52 – 39:160

And that should be by March, that should be fixed. So next. This is our materials budget. It just I'm just showing you that we're really right on target for everything where we should be. We thank you for getting us the extra money for the for our materials last year. If you remember, you all advocated for us. And so but we're doing really well, and we are, again, right on target.

39:193

This is

39:20 – 39:400

next screen or chart. Okay. And the reason I just showed that you can't really see it very well, but we are for the first time in I don't know how many years, all our positions are filled. We have no. I do. That's good. I'm really, really proud of that. That's that's been amazing. Those of

39:402

us who've been around a long time ago.

39:420

And and you know what that means. I forgot the agency for us to be in a situation, but I feel really proud of that. So no one better quit or get an

39:522

Yeah. Exactly. And

39:56 – 40:330

so, again, we are fully just fully staffed, fully filled all positions, and no new positions. So we, at this point, we're not expecting to have anything, ask for anything, not even the next budget. So with your requests with your requests have to be, you know, very specific. They have to be needs based and defensible, so it has to be something really, really, like, critical in that way. We are not as I said, we've actually we are fully staffed for the first time in a very long time, so we are not making any requests.

40:33 – 40:440

Can. Okay. And with that, do you have any questions? First off, the Sorry.

40:443

Yes. You perceive that the revenue for the the grant is gonna stay the same next year? Does it

40:52 – 41:140

It will be it will be lower. So we actually for example, we have close to $800,000 in there for the Weeks branch renovation. Okay. So it will definitely be best next year because that was a onetime grant. But a lot of the other things, you know, tend to be I I'd say we think close to what we have done in previous years since the.

41:163

Mhmm. Do you foresee that being or how is that being a large problem? Having less amount of money.

41:26 – 41:490

No. It will be okay because this was a specific brand for a specific project once that project is done. So the vibe we are really good about, we don't get a lot of the extra money from the city. So we try to make sure we find sources. So for example, both of our bookings were big big expenses, and for both of them, we went and found a donor, and we went and found.

41:50 – 42:320

So we will try to do that, but we've been lacking so far. Commissioner Ford has a question. To staff center that just got underway in terms of being built, would you anticipate that would be built? And do yours will your staff have a have a role in a particular part of that statin? Yeah. So I did actually give up. I did I know I gave a good update on that last time. Let me see if I can find my sheet. But we will be in phase two. Our right now, we're in phase one.

42:32 – 43:140

Phase two starts next year, and we have our satellite branch in the back. So we hope by 2027 to have our satellite branch over there. Okay. You'll you'll have additional staff designated for that branch. Oh, we have no additional staff. What we would do is it's not gonna be a big branch. It is a satellite, as I say, a satellite branch. So right now, the way we're planning it is to have some, you know, staff sort of circulating in there. It is something we might depending on how big it is, how busy it is, we might have to go to the city doctor for additional staffing, but it was not. Okay.

43:14 – 43:440

I'll just. Okay. We yeah. We'll be at the next one. Professional development type of the library. Like, for the librarians who wish to attend my conferences, that's all included. It's sweet, take it out to a bar of supplies and services, that's where we do everything. Yeah. Yeah. Oh, that the friends part is sort of our brand.

43:45 – 44:170

Okay. So we accept donations. Living within our needs. And and doing a good job. Testing director. Annual report and stats, please. Alright. So I am very excited. I sent out a new I'm sorry. The plus one had some.

44:17 – 44:500

So I was thinking I found out what I sent it So out. We changed it up a little bit from the previous year. So one of the things you have been asked me when we sent out, we this is what we shared with the public, and so we really it's very simple, but you're gonna ask me to count because I don't compare it with previous years. And so I just want to tell you, give you some of these amazing numbers. So last year, our total cards, we had a hundred and fifty two hundred two thousand and ninety nine cards.

44:50 – 45:100

Our number of cards now is a 189,301. That's a 24% increase. I just also want to say K word's population is a 160. Now you say how We have a 189. So that just shows you how popular our library is.

45:10 – 45:420

It's pretty standard. If you have about 80 of your population in cards the number of cards is 80% of your population that's considered 35, you can see we are well. But one of the things and which we are continuing to work on right now, we have we I looked at the number of A world residents that actually have cards, and so that's a 108,552. So about 57% of percent of the cards we have are Hayward residents. The rest staff, we will complain about the area.

45:42 – 46:110

But, also, you need to be aware, Hayward residents also have cards in outside areas. So it's not often a certain level of payment pay, but we'd like to work a little hardcore on getting more Hayward residents to have cards. So that's sort of the same as an area of growth for us. New cards, we've had 15,000 over or close to 16,000 people get new cards this year. So looking at this checkout of materials, it's it just keeps going far.

46:11 – 46:350

We have programs. We've seen a huge, huge, huge increase in programs for our for our system. Last year, we had 481 adult programs for the whole year. This year, we had over 1,500 over 1,500 more program. We one of the things we do notice is our neighborhood residents really love our programs.

46:35 – 47:000

And it is given the type of cognition it is what you would expect. We are largely working class working sort of working community. We have a lot of middle class, you know, residents. So it makes a lot of sense, a lot of new immigrants, people who don't always speak or read English perfectly. So I think we've been very successful in that area, and we're continuing to go.

47:00 – 47:220

So the number of people that attended our programs last year was 18,477. This year, it was 32,281. That's a 75 increase in program attendance. Gurubi, also visitors went up by 25%. It's just really, know, just totally amazing.

47:22 – 47:530

The one area where we actually saw a drop is in the checkout of physical books and and DVDs. So it was at 371,613 last year. This year, it was 339,000, so it was a drop of about 8.5%. However, digital, check out audio, clean, and things like that went from 84,300 to 117,000. That's a huge.

47:53 – 48:230

That's that's. So overall, you've had had an increase, but it's not so much. So, yeah, I think that's sort of, you know, what I wanted to just really bring your attention to. We also put down our social media following because that is something you have been very interested in how we reach out, how we communicate with the public. And so I just wanted to put that information down here showing you how many followers we have.

48:23 – 49:030

Many of you have seen the success we've been having with our social media, but that's something that you'll get we're trying very hard to make sure that's no doubt. So stuff. So we get, you know, getting close to a thousand people daily. And this is, I hope, But it's most of it has been downtown in. No. Okay.

49:045

So, Janti, do we have the substats on how many of the guards are actually active, like, actively used?

49:130

Because, actually, all cards are pretty much active because we do remove cards on a regular basis.

49:215

Okay. I'm having to ask, you know, cards against which some checkout or some action is taken by the patient. Do you have stats for that?

49:28 – 49:510

Yeah. That's what it says. So we annually do regularly every six months, we bleed out. Yeah. So if there's something is, like, competitors, if if they have to abuse it at least once during the year, yeah, so that's how we do it. If they kick you out, I found out the. Think we have to make my car. Yes. So it depends. Yeah. At least it depends. I And mean then

49:515

the other limit question, the $15.30 at other programs, that's, like, in greater than, you know, one day. Right? Hopefully. Yeah. So so what's another program?

49:593

I didn't join. It's so new.

50:01 – 50:430

So if you look at our events calendar, we have one of the highest rate of daily programming. So you will see in in, like, each of rooms are really hard to go. So it might have, say, an citizenship program. Then we have yoga. Then we have something. So the rooms are just booked nonstop, and it's and then we also do some outreach programs. But, yeah, we have a lot of programs that we go on. And so there'll be something like there'll be a digital class going on. And then so if we just count all of them, it's fairly high. Yes. Tell us about the Yes. Where do

50:434

we now like, you know, you get talking about the collection, you had given that statistic about how we were one of the lowest. You know, where are we still like, where are we now in that statistic?

50:520

We are still low. And what is it?

50:544

You just just might be.

50:57 – 51:130

So I don't have the exact numbers with me now, but we are we're moving up a little bit, but we we are not anywhere near even near the median. Okay. We're just slowly we would need to have almost double up with budget in order to get to Can

51:134

you tell what tells what what that statistic what is it gauge?

51:17 – 51:370

So that gauge is the per capita spending. That's what we looked at. Right. And, obviously, I would like, for example, San Francisco Public Library has a has a good collection development policy of over over 4 and a half million dollars. Mhmm.

51:37 – 52:210

We are at half $1,000,000. Mhmm. So I'm not gonna compare directly. They have a much larger population, is compared for catheter spending on all the. Is that updated annually? Yes. And you will have those I will. Yes. Probably at the end of the year. Or Yes.

52:21 – 52:340

So just before when we're getting ready, like, towards the end of the year, I go through. Because right now, we just sent all our statistics, and it usually takes them two to three months to get it all assembled. So by about April, I should have this. Absolutely.

52:384

Yeah. I mean, I just think it's a really good service reminder every time we're talking about budget.

52:412

Like, you look at, you know,

52:44 – 53:065

The one with customer question, you know, Jenny, if we had some stats around what is the impact of the because we don't have as big a physical correction, it may turn out that, you know, people come in to check a book and say it's already checked out. Right? So what if you can convert that to some stats that become actionable for, say, the council, because it's showing back on the community. Right? That might be a useful thing that's too, perhaps.

53:06 – 53:400

It it yes. It is a really it's a very difficult statistic for us to gather. We can do things like what's the average weighted period and things like that. But be because we sort of some of our some of our collections we share with neighboring libraries, so that sort of benefits us. Like, for example, they be overdrive. We are sharing. So sometimes it impacts us negatively. Sometimes it impacts us positively. It's a I think this is a number we really try to work on. It's a very difficult number.

53:40 – 54:210

In fact, San Francisco just came out with something based on that because they have sent you a collection without a budget. A lot of people try to lose their library. A lot of people, we try to borrow their books, and they overdrive. They try to make sure that they are people who beat the hard person in queue. It's a hard thing to do. What happens is if we buy an overdrive book, then our staff get, like, I mean, our patrons get popped up in the queue. But we might add one copy. San Francisco will add 10 copies. So it's it's a really difficult number for us to really retry very hard, but I will

54:225

It will be brainstorming on what that you know, what those metrics might be, then, you know, I think it'll make it make it as much my a much stronger.

54:29 – 54:400

I I completely agree with you, and I will try to put some good numbers together this time. Do the Zipit numbers help? The Zipbooks? Zipit. Zipit?

54:402

Those were so I'm just turning the book.

54:420

Remember you told us the Yeah. Yeah. That's Zipbooks. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. They do. Definitely. So I keep an an understanding.

54:50 – 55:082

So for those of you who weren't at that meeting, ZipBooks are when the library doesn't have a book that you want, you can request it through ZipBooks, and they will buy it and send it to your house. And so I did this. I learned this at the commission meeting, and I did this, and I got it into my house, and I just returned it a little late, maybe two months.

55:080

But I have to sleep very long. Know?

55:124

I did return it to

55:13 – 55:550

a live prayer today. And, yeah, it was pretty cool. Yeah. And and, you know, so similar to that, you know, we have, for example, where we borrow. It's the one people in. Yeah. We see whether we're a net borrower or a net lender. Things like that really help us move up. It's that's it. Commissioner? Yeah. I am trying to use that borrowing, the interlibrary borrowing. Mhmm. And I think as a justification for why we should have more books in house, There is currently no way when I can go to book on your website. If I ask for a book, I never get noticed that the book is in.

55:55 – 56:170

I know it's not physically. I never got a saying that the book was in. I didn't got the name of the book. You have a book waiting for me. No. We don't. Well, can you tell me if it's hanging in a past? They sent me an email. It went to my trash. No. I can't. Can you track my request? No. I can't. So I think a lot of books, and I've had this experience a number of times, a lot of

56:172

folks have are requesting. And he says, well,

56:19 – 56:440

if they don't send it to us or when we make the request and they don't pull it, it's not there, then it just gets lost in the shuffle. So I think that another justification for people may use attempt to use this lending, interlibrary lending system. But for me, probably that one book that I requested through, and I probably request to have a dozen. So either you know, when you send an email, generally goes to trash.

56:452

So people aren't thinking about looking

56:46 – 57:200

in their trash. They don't find out. And I was gonna suggest a better way to notify them maybe by text. Your book is in. That doesn't go to trash. That goes to Robert. But I I don't know if there's no way to track what happened to my request. Same here. There could be lots of reasons why it's not there or they never got it. They don't know. So to me, that's just But that doesn't change. I'm not I'm not sure. Like, you're saying if you don't get a book, you're not getting notified. But when you get a book, you do get notified. Correct.

57:204

Like I said, five out

57:21 – 57:350

of six times, I never got a book for a notification, so I don't know. But I did get a notification on one book. So the staff apparently had no way to track what happened to that request. We put in the request. This is the way

57:354

it was explained to me

57:36 – 58:050

for the booking pass for that is in one of our lending in our lending community. We don't know if they're okay. I will check on this one. We don't know if somebody called you or somebody sent you an email. We can't tell you what happened with that request. So, yeah, we did it. It I don't know if it came in or not. So and I don't know either because I never got the dose. So I think that that's something that I've worked on because that makes sense. It doesn't make sense.

58:05 – 58:400

It's extremely unusual for a migraine to do something like Okay. Okay. Anything else about animal important status? Well, just just one

58:40 – 58:524

quick thing. This is really good. On the collections, think I mean, it's not just physical books. Right? Because we know from the statistic that physical items are going down. So this collection of the per capita has to do with all the items that are digital and everything. Yes.

58:54 – 59:100

Thank you, everyone. Director, I'm gonna move the volunteer. Okay. So just very quickly, you know, you'll have asked me. So every I try to do this annually, bring you a list of current volunteer opportunities in the library.

59:10 – 59:450

If they are there, just if you have any questions. But, otherwise, really to be aware that we do have our website. And on the website, if you click on the get involved button, it always has our opportunities. We have opportunities for for young people, for the teams, and we definitely know that friends of the library really do need volunteers. We would love it if you would invite your friends, family, children, parents, everyone.

59:51 – 1:00:290

Okay. If you don't have any questions? K. Well, thank you. That was good. Thank you, director. I want you to take a breather. Is there any old business from the letter writing committee? No. Alright. Is there any old business from the local committee? Nothing bad. So we're just waiting our we're just waiting the finalization of welcome packet in physical form. And then there's a form that you all have ready for. The welcome packet.

1:00:29 – 1:00:520

Yes. I should get yeah. I will. And that is still subject to Yes. Right. Right. So there is a section in it. We still have the best best practices that was but that would be replaced once the committee Yeah. I'll give a quick update on that one. Been. CSU, East

1:00:522

Bay Shipville Partnership Committee, that really is now in the director's hands with the some work on MO potential MOUs, excuse

1:01:00 – 1:01:130

me, those two campuses. So we will meet the director whenever there's an update there. Budget support committee.

1:01:152

And I met just

1:01:170

to talk about that. We just had a budget update, so there's really not much there.

1:01:222

Community outreach.

1:01:342

you, Commissioner Porter. Any recommendations from commissioners?

1:01:420

With the recommendation section. Think

1:01:540

that would come in probably

1:01:56 – 1:02:162

the directive report. The recommendation section is where we make directions recommendations to the commission. So, for example, I've been seeing many people on social media posting that one of the most disruptive government agencies is the library. So I've

1:02:16 – 1:02:280

been seeing people posting what? I'm gonna finish my sentence. Disruptive in that it serves the public,

1:02:28 – 1:02:562

meaning it provides banned books. It provides all these services we've been talking about. So people have been posting. Please encourage your neighbor to get their library. So recommendation I'm making is to support the library and recommending your neighbors to get their library card and to think about hosting. April is, what, the youth celebration of library staff week?

1:02:560

In April? Oh, the bad books week.

1:02:592

And bad books week is coming up, so I wanna think about what can we

1:03:020

do to support our library during bad books week. Yeah. That's the one that's Yeah. I'll send out pretty much. Yes. So let's think about that so we

1:03:10 – 1:03:512

can maybe put something together in our next commission meeting so we don't get, like, caught flat footed. And I've heard more the since the library wants to make sure neighborhood residents have library parks,

1:03:510

this is a chance that we can ask commissioners. I know I'm supposed

1:03:54 – 1:04:052

to go look. I'm always posting goofy stuff on my social media, like, from your neighbor. Friend, the neighbor of the library commissioner, sign up for your library card. This is this week's banned book. I'm always posting goofy stuff, so that's something we

1:04:056

could do together. You could have banned book group. Like, you just posted the you know, where the the then the group talk about books.

1:04:262

Really? I have it. There's some

1:04:274

It's on real love. Okay. It's like some real good, like, classics.

1:04:310

Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. No. So you're like, why is that band? And you're like, no.

1:04:362

National Library Workers Day is in April. Yeah. And so I do wanna think about how do we

1:04:410

celebrate our library staff. That's the one all

1:04:43 – 1:04:592

of this stuff. It's January, so we have some time to plan. So that is I wanna put that on the table. It can be just something simple as coming together on a after our next meeting and writing some cards to them.

1:04:59 – 1:05:340

Right? I love that idea. So so go on the agenda agenda building item? Or It's a recommendation. A recommendation for discussion. Right? Yes. For discussion. So so we'll discuss. You know? You can say yes. I think That's okay. We should discuss it. I think we should put it on our next. Yes.

1:05:470

So we move that we would like to

1:05:492

do something for our for our National Library's Workers Day, which is in April. So

1:05:57 – 1:06:170

Oh, yeah. No. I I was just gonna ask. So we're going to put this on the agenda? Yes. Okay. That's all we're doing for next day. You need to vote. You need to vote? Yes. Discussion? If all those in favor, please say aye. Aye. Any opposed? Right. So I'll put this

1:06:172

on the agenda for next meeting to have a discussion on what we're

1:06:19 – 1:06:380

gonna actually do. Thank you. Any other recommendations? Ban I was looking at when banned books week is. It's October. October is I think we should have

1:06:386

a monthly banned book thing for the next four years,

1:06:410

I think. It's probably more because I could

1:06:446

It's gonna be worth it. I've read most of them. It'll get weird on top of

1:06:482

me right now. Fair. But what's then what we can actually achieve? K.

1:06:530

I think I'm doing a book a month. Sounds great. To do okay.

1:06:572

Just What is your recommendation, Commissioner Purcell?

1:07:00 – 1:07:110

I don't know. Let's all do a book for you to listen to. Where? And it's well, everybody read their own book, and I don't know. Read

1:07:136

together in the library. Like,

1:07:16 – 1:07:502

is your recommendation to No. Okay. Thank you. You have a motion to put ban on the agenda to discuss her. Thank you. Is there any discussion? No? All those in favor, please say aye.

1:07:500

No. And your toes? No. Thank you. Are there any other rest of the Okay.

1:07:572

During your hour, did you get a break? I do. Okay. Ready to record? Yes.

1:08:02 – 1:08:370

Okay. So I I do want to say it's been somewhat a short period because we were closed for two two weeks and then with the holidays and all of that. But the big news is that we have our new city manager. So, you know, be back, though. We're really busy.

1:08:37 – 1:09:050

Again, we had our New York celebration last Saturday. It was amazing as always. You know, I think that's such a big crowd. It's just really fun. Thank you for you know, with commissioner Dozier, mister Navarro. You were both here, so thank you very much for that. We had a really good turnout. Yeah. And it's just lovely. And then apart from that, Leach's branch is is on track.

1:09:05 – 1:09:500

All of the repairs are on track. It is it is closed, of course, and the temporary fencing is going to go up. We were hoping we have the permanent fencing up first, but we need to sort of, what's it called, notice it so the public can have the thirty days to comment on the what is gonna look like. So that is gonna open on Friday for that. But meanwhile, we just have a change in fence to keep people out while we're doing repairs. And we're still still on track to be closed through the March. Might be a little more than that, but definitely till the March, we will be closed. Sac center, nothing new to report. We were just, you know, as I had said last time. And beyond that, I just want to say I'm going to be gone.

1:09:50 – 1:10:060

It will take three weeks in February. And Yeah. I it's a long time. Yeah. Yeah. But it actually it's yeah. I'm I'm going to my family for the reasons. So I'll be gone for three weeks. So next week next month, Vinci will be here in my place.

1:11:06 – 1:11:264

Really great event. Okay. Yes. So we have the swearing in of our our new STD manager, which is very exciting. So we're very hopeful for the new STD manager. Have you all, like, read a little bit about her? Yeah. She's a pretty amazing woman and has all these great bona fides, and I think really reflects our community. And so we're very excited about with Doctor. Anna.

1:11:29 – 1:11:524

Let's see. So things are coming up. You know, we also obviously had slow time. We didn't have our first meeting until I think it was last week from from the holiday breaks. So next week, we're gonna be we have a work session on the Capitol Corridor change. I don't if everyone's aware, but, you know, we're potentially gonna lose our training station and have it, like, normal. Right here. Here. Yeah. And I and I hope I really we really want people to come out

1:11:520

because I I did go to a meeting. Work. Interesting. Yeah.

1:11:56 – 1:12:114

Yeah. No. It's terrible. And and they just have this grand plan that they're gonna move the, you know, commuter train out to, like, you know, the Bay Edge, basically, and then built some new huge station in Ardenwood, but they're skip Hayward and Fremont now. It's gonna come yeah.

1:12:110

It's Beautiful news. And we're very excited about it.

1:12:14 – 1:12:414

You know? Because all of cities like New York, we've answered this call to build affordable housing along our transit corridors, and now they're gonna take away part of the transit there. So please come or send in your emails or whatever it is for that meeting next Tuesday because the director from that have a quarter committee, I don't know if they are will be here for this work session. Because, apparently, the mayor has been asking the current mayor and former mayor has asking them to come to Hayward and hear from from citizens here. So that's next too.

1:12:410

That's a big one. But said they were going to build a special new partner with worse than the next one down the line going to the East? So I think I think it's gonna be Oakland.

1:12:514

It'll just go Oakland down to Fremont.

1:12:530

That's absolutely cool. Right? So Yeah. I mean, it's

1:12:566

a part of the management. I just tried to mention

1:12:585

that this one drive.

1:12:596

It was literally on the NPR on when I was driving here, and they're saying No. As I was driving here,

1:13:054

they were saying that they are gonna

1:13:07 – 1:13:216

meet with Hayward about this and that they wanna do it because it's, like, some really expensive project, like, $600,000,000. Yes. To shorten the commute fifteen minutes.

1:13:210

Yeah. I mean, that's why people

1:13:224

are so so expensive. And it's

1:13:240

a real equity issue.

1:13:254

Like, they are not addressing the equity issue, like, taking the trade away from the very people that were trying to build close to the, know, you the Chex Farm and Stigler, I think, or you know?

1:13:330

So, yes, please come out for that. They're Well, it

1:13:366

was all in here, so that's a

1:13:370

good thing. They just been Yeah. Getting on and then Getting notice. Yeah.

1:13:414

Yeah. They they do the to save, like

1:13:440

you said, fifteen minutes.

1:13:450

it'll send the great parts of me to come down the line. So, again, equity issues me.

1:13:504

Oh, and then Great parts

1:13:510

of our team. Right. Yes. Yeah. Sorry. I know. Don't remember. Okay. Anyway, that excited all about it because it's a really big deal. I have to pull one of those.

1:14:014

Okay. Right. Let's see. Thank you, sir. And then with also in February, I

1:14:060

think maybe February 8 of some of you

1:14:09 – 1:14:344

have probably seen the sewer rates are going up, and they will go up over the next few years. That's been a really big source of contention. There are very valid reasons for it. Think it's not in the city of China, but in my mind, we are simply causing the cost of a a really exorbitant huge project that everyone every jurisdiction that's on the bay has to sort of offer this new filtration system to not put nutrients into the bay. So it's for a very good cause, but we're talking it's like

1:14:340

a 400,000,000 project.

1:14:35 – 1:15:094

Like, that's our city budget. And so in order to to make this happen, we're you know, we have to pass the the rates on. So if you're interested in that one, I believe that's February 8, and so please pass the word next. There's a lot of very upset people. You'd be understandably you know, we didn't want this. Our staff has fought against it, but this is now the the new rule. And so, know, you stay aware of that, but if you're interested. And then, again, it looks in in February, we're also gonna be having our annual budget discussion. We start looking at our budget. You know, and and we have some work to

1:15:090

do to sort of, you know, bend down the ashes.

1:15:13 – 1:15:364

So that'll be interesting. Oh, and then, you know, one final thing just sort of public service announcement. You know, just based on the fires in Southern California, our fire department is, you know, asking everyone to please sign up for AC alert. You can find that, I believe, on the fire page or on the city page. And pass you know, and please pass the word on that to all of your neighbors because should there be a similar, you know, incident in New York, AC alert is

1:15:36 – 1:15:500

the number one place where you try to disseminate the information. That's all I have. Any other questions? There's people who have a question about the potential to address the status of the. Oh, sorry. Thank you.

1:15:504

I put that on my paper and

1:15:510

not on my notes. Thank you. Yes. So we did

1:15:554

the work for the Ad Hoc Committee. We gave our recommendations to try to, you know, normalize the you know, over overall the commissions what bylaws should

1:16:020

be and all of these things.

1:16:04 – 1:16:174

But we took a pause in order for Keypair with Planet Green to meet, and I believe they met last week because they're debating whether they wanna become a commission or stay a task force. And so we're not gonna meet now until I I

1:16:170

guess it should be the February if it's gone.

1:16:204

So that's the only pause there. So after

1:16:220

that, the recommendations will all go to

1:16:234

the full council for when we vote on it, Then we'll have a standard set of

1:16:290

Thank you. There was one recommendation that a chair can't serve more than one one year. Am I correct on that? Yeah. Yeah.

1:16:39 – 1:17:042

And, I am concerned with the library commission just in the sense that sometimes there are folks who it can be challenging to get folks who want to serve the chair. And I understand that there's a particular commission where there's some challenges, and there's a desire for more rotation of leadership. But I do have concern that to address an issue of one commission, every commission may be impacted. I just wanted to share that with you.

1:17:04 – 1:17:194

Yeah. And thank you for that. I mean, the idea is to generally sort of, you know, to, you know, come up with a general set of recommendations. But there was an out for that sort of like a if nobody else wants to serve with the current chair, you know like, during the pandemic on the planning commission, you know, we just found that

1:17:190

it there was there was a reason to

1:17:22 – 1:18:064

keep the continuity of the chair that was there. So there's it wasn't there there is an out sentence, basically, that says, you know, barring any other, you know, circumstances where nobody wants to serve, nobody steps up. So it isn't a hard and fast rule, and I I I'll look at that one again, but we did have discussions about it for I mean, partly, it was the sort of genuine reason that sometimes you have a chair that has a little bit more, you know, dominance over the commission, so nobody wants to challenge them. And so we were trying to find an opportunity. Like, the whole point is for all of us to join these commissions and find leadership opportunities. And so if, you know, that's taken away because you have a role dominant chair, then then that was sort of the balance of trying to find, you know, that. So, yeah, I I I hear you on that. My

1:18:072

other question was about not about AC alert, which my family's talked to me

1:18:130

that even an earthquake, they're gonna die.

1:18:15 – 1:18:342

But about where we get a half in, and there's there's discussion of getting rid of FEMA. Yeah. We have the Hayward Fault. There's a FEMA report called Haywire. Are we prepared, or what are we doing to think about protecting Hayward if there's no morphine?

1:18:35 – 1:18:584

That's a great question. You know, we had a minor discussion about this at the public safety committee meeting last week, but, I mean, Hayward Fire is pretty amazing and what they are doing you know, especially they're learning all these great things from the Palisades Fire and, like, how to distribute resources and have them ready. But as far as and because this is such an unknown about FEMA, they don't really have any answers to that yet. So I I

1:18:582

don't know. A council reread the Hayward report recently? Have they looked at it?

1:19:034

As counsel, we haven't. No. Yeah. Can they suggest that Yeah.

1:19:06 – 1:19:170

They pull that out? I will bring that. Yes. Thank you. Hayward is a our fault has not rolled in quite some time because Not in 1900.

1:19:202

So I you know, the a wire people who were created wasn't our fault. There is a there

1:19:240

is a national report on

1:19:262

the paper fault called a wire.

1:19:310

The question for.

1:19:37 – 1:20:122

Hearing none. Thank you so much. Friends of the public library, as our director mentioned, we really do like volunteers. Our book sales are doing really well, and it's how we fund so many things that support the library. So the bricks and all the things come from the friends. But we only are able to do book sales two weekends a month. We would really love to be able to do the other two weekends, but we need more volunteers to be able to do that. We have a lot of young people from the high schools that come. So if you don't know other young people who need community service hours or not even

1:20:120

young people, seasoned people people,

1:20:172

people, that would be great. We are getting ready to commence our big fundraising drive. So if you're

1:20:240

interested in supporting, I will

1:20:26 – 1:20:592

be the fundraising chair in my spare time. Be working on that. Book sales are doing really well online on the computer machine, so that is great. Thanks to our our seasoned volunteers, We're getting ready to review our library staff scholarship. We haven't been awarded in two years, so we're reviewing to see if we have funds, and hopefully, we do to go back to avoiding the library staff scholarship so that there is professional.

1:21:050

They're almost taking volunteers and no deletions, so we need to use for the the library of supplements.

1:21:134

I'm sure I was just council member council member for the.

1:21:210

Yeah. What? She's not in the ER too. Oh, she's not in but we she brought in the I think it's

1:21:284

ER the Chabot Fire Academy to help out that day, and they're looking for volunteer hours. And there's a team of them.

1:21:340

So Oh. So that might be a

1:21:354

good one to try.

1:21:350

They were they were asking us. So they might be helpful.

1:21:39 – 1:22:066

And if you could slow writing the library to make sure, which is what I wanna say, which is flowing into what y'all are talking about. I've been well, it is kinda it's all kinda working. I've been working on a few years of what I wanna do, and I've been trying to figure out a way to collate all the amazing things that are going on in this area. And I've been talking to a whole bunch of people about it. And I don't know John Hardisty.

1:22:06 – 1:22:516

Does Forrester. Forrester does Forrester does cleanups and anyway, it doesn't matter. It's a computer. And if this ties into what's going on with the world and I wanted to basically, what I'm trying to do is put together a website to have all everything for this area in one spot. All the food pantries, all the resources, all the things that you can do, all the places you can help and volunteer. Because I'm constantly I can't tell you how many people on Reddit have said, go. They wanna volunteer. The whole bunch of them, I just signed up at the library or whatever or Forrester, and I'm tired of typing it all up. So I'm just just one place, and it's never gonna go away.

1:22:510

They didn't have one lane, everything

1:22:53 – 1:23:086

in the area. And Dawn was like, well, we could do a a fee too. I'm like, no way. And then in the last week, I'm like, you know, because Nextdoor is off the rails. The crazy all all the social media is getting I don't know about you. If you go

1:23:080

on the Internet, whole bunch of

1:23:106

stuff is insecure. And I'm getting Trump gear email every day. 100%. What would

1:23:164

you like to report?

1:23:17 – 1:23:476

So what I'm trying to say is that we're basically starting we we we talked about it yesterday. I literally started putting together the website today. There's gonna be a feed and a community connections with all the resources. I just put friends on there Thank you. Last night. You know? And I'm still trying to figure out how to do the website, but it's gonna be a website where everything's there. Like, everything. And it's not just Hayward. It's not just Castro Valley.

1:23:47 – 1:24:186

It's just, you know, it's inclusive. And so, right now, if you all have, like, any ideas of anything, what should I put on there? Please send it to me. Okay. And then in about two weeks, we'll probably once we get it $5.00 6, we'll get it up. We'll start sending out the vehicle, and then y'all can give us feedback of more to put on, and I think it's gonna spread because it's a safe space, which is not tech billionaire people, but where we can put all the resources.

1:24:182

Thank you. Commissioner.

1:24:21 – 1:24:360

Are there any other library commission report? Yeah. Oh, yeah. I attended the Lunar New Year celebration. But I want to highlight about where I met here, Hector. He was working at

1:24:364

the table, and I just wanna share that

1:24:38 – 1:24:520

he was so awesome. I do outreach. Outreach is difficult, but he was engaging with every single person that was walking through the door. I mean, he and he was doing this by himself. Usually, I have, like,

1:24:522

a student worker with me or something.

1:24:54 – 1:25:360

You know? But he was just really engaging, sharing, like, just different programs and resources, and you couldn't tell that he's, like, happy to be here. And people were walking away, like, taking things, and they were smiling. And I just I told him, like, someone walking in today. Because a lot of people suffer from impostor syndrome in library. It's a lot of research on people scared to walk into to the libraries because they don't feel maybe smart enough or, like, they belong here. And the way that he was just engaging with people is beautiful. I just thought I would share that. I just want to say thank you for that. This was the first year we actually thought it would be good.

1:25:360

Think we have a we have a table, information table, because it had such a big event. I'm so thankful for that.

1:25:454

Yeah. I also certain things often. Good. And I also had

1:25:500

a little bit of a

1:25:52 – 1:26:034

I know you from social media because you're very active in all of your video and everything. So it felt like him I was like, that's him.

1:26:030

I didn't go up to him

1:26:044

or anything, but I want to double down on what you said. In the chat and everything. Yeah.

1:26:090

I said that was just it was so many community members. Okay. Wasn't there an employee coming there? You just Oh, yeah. And there's so many community members that were happy

1:26:196

to talk to him, and I just

1:26:202

thought about it.

1:26:20 – 1:26:324

And to that point, like, that's what you want to do with your social media where you foster this idea that you feel like you know somebody Mhmm. Especially with the younger generation. So when they come in, they're like,

1:26:320

oh, that was look. Die from TikTok or from the social media, and I

1:26:374

could go and talk to them. Right? Because if me as an adult had that feeling, I could imagine that with the younger students.

1:26:48 – 1:27:010

Poor guy who's on social media. Yeah. No. He Yes. I saw that one. Yeah. That's cool. I'm sure there's a lot of fun flickers

1:27:016

in in the make.

1:27:02 – 1:27:170

I wouldn't see the ones with Judy and and Tony. I don't see the ones with everybody. Any other commissioner or counselor? I will just add that I am using the free Rosetta Stone for

1:27:172

the library. I'm in the e resources session on the Slice Island account. I'm in there practicing my elementary French.

1:27:260

Well, I can't make it to the French group because it's in the middle of the day, and I have to go over.

1:27:292

Lastly, we have agenda building, o four.

1:27:460

January. No. Fix it.

1:27:492

I don't know. Don't need my

1:27:500

own first name. February,

1:27:52 – 1:28:122

we've got abundant enhanced oh, we got enhanced request. We got money request, report on weeks, improvement project, technology programs, and makerspace update, and then we've added a discussion on National Library Workers Day. March programming for adults and seniors.

1:28:140

Community bulletin board policy. Mhmm.

1:28:212

April Patron Court of Conduct Enforcement Guidelines if updated if necessary. Yeah.

1:28:260

There was one in the library earlier, and I was trying to quote this doc.

1:28:32 – 1:28:442

Report on bookmobile services. May homework support center report, summer slide, and literacy pre K presentation. You all can read. Is there anything that we're missing?

1:28:453

But you're

1:28:46 – 1:29:050

on it. I thought that commissioner Wait. The what? Banned book? Banned book. We did.

1:29:052

We added the Banned book to me.

1:29:060

Which month? Banned book every month.

1:29:092

Well, we we added the discussion for next month so we can talk about

1:29:123

what we're gonna do. So

1:29:140

next month. Library We're just

1:29:162

gonna figure out where we're gonna Yeah.

1:29:220

We're gonna

1:29:23 – 1:29:362

put it in March. Yeah. We're talk about national library work is what we're gonna do in February and then books in March. Okay. Is there anything else?

1:29:370

Yes. Commissioner. I don't remember if in the welcome packet is there.

1:29:434

If I can get to a meeting.

1:29:46 – 1:29:590

Goodbye. Yeah. Just come back to me. Okay. That should then become to me. Yeah. Thank you. My wife's

1:29:592

not You are aware of the absence policy? Yes.

1:30:04 – 1:30:160

Are there any anything else you can give her? Hearing none of that hereby. It don't want her. Don't want

1:30:162

him. Baby, no. That's not

This transcript was automatically generated from the official public meeting video and is presented unedited. It reflects remarks made on the public record by elected officials, staff, and public commenters. Transcript accuracy may vary; view the original recording for reference.