Village Board - Regular Meeting

Monday, November 2, 2026

The Village Board of Cottage Grove approved minutes, discussed ordinances regarding committee attendance and teleconferences, reviewed annual assessments with Associated Appraisal, and advanced proposals related to land use, zoning overlays, and a paramedic memorandum of understanding.

About this meeting

Government Body
Village Board
Meeting Type
Village Board
Location
Village of Cottage Grove, WI
Meeting Date
November 2, 2026

Published excerpts

Only published remarks appear here. The full transcript is not published.

79 sections

All right. And now it lets me do video. Cool. Thank you.

It looks better when it makes you the focus speaker, but when you're up on the top, yeah, it's really, it's unfortunate.

I think that's, it's unfortunate. Your lighting situation to be clear.

Sorry, I meant to raise my hand. I have a question on the minutes. It doesn't appear on the YouTube video recording our meeting that our vote for salary was included in the YouTube video. So therefore, I don't think I can approve the minutes.

Fair enough. But yes, I move approval of the meeting minutes as presented.

So if I read this correctly, the 48 hour notice, for example, I don't know ahead of time 48 hours if I'm gonna have a suicidal patient that night, or if I run into some type of emergency or crisis at work that same day. So I'm not gonna have 48 hours notice.

and provide more leeway on the back end if there's a reason for the absence so it's I guess up to the board's discretion on timelines no I was just gonna comment what Rick mentioned because that's the next that's the way I interpret the next section or the next sentence there's that on the back end we can We just need to provide justification if you're unable to provide notice ahead of time.

Yeah, I just, I think of someone who served on public works for a long period of time, and Christo, you're going to know who I'm talking about, who served this village for decades and over the last few years wasn't able to participate and would have fallen under this too unexcused absence rule. And I think it's a shame to boot somebody like that because of health conditions and so forth. So I guess to me, this is a slippery slope in terms of what's excused, what's unexcused, what's the timeframe. It just feels really icky at a local level when our neighbors and friends are you know serving on

Written as a may remove. So the village board may remove the committee member from the committee. So it's not saying that it's an absolute absolute thing that will happen if they missed two absences. And so it does provide some flexibility, which I definitely appreciated. And again, if an individual has health challenges down the line, that's where again, like the Rick's comment to Trustee Brunzo is like, that's where the back end notice comes into play and we can kind of work around that a little bit. So, in many ways, the way I'm viewing this is unexcused is another common term that can be u

I understand your point of view, JP, and what you're trying to say. I think perhaps then I'm trying to think of a way to remove subjectivity out of this. So that, for instance, with the word may, right? So how do we... I'm trying to find a really nice PC way to say this. How do we make sure that it's not being used against people that the majority disagrees with versus other people, right? Like that subjectivity of that. So are there parameters in terms of saying, You know, what is considered an excused absence? What is considered unexcused? You know what I mean? Like, maybe there needs to be

So I think, again, as Rick and JP mentioned, the fact that there is 48 hours in advance and following the meeting, both of those allow for providing the communication. And so either of those would fall under an excuse. So if someone has a last minute health complication or some other sort of issue, and can't notify ahead of the committee meeting, but then, you know, within, within two days can make communication. I was unable to attend for, you know, X, X reason, then that covers it. And additionally, as JP said, the, the may is there the, the same the same may as, as Rick mentioned at the sta

Renee, you are on mute, so if you are speaking, we can't hear you.

Oops, thank you. Thank you, Rick, for clarifying that. And I agree with what Paula said, too. We are a local government, and it seems like we're chasing problems that are not there. So I think this is really a waste of time, and I'm not in favor of this.

Yeah, sorry. I think you just put me down after I spoke earlier. So I guess one thing I do want to point out that has not been part of this discussion is another reason for the advance notice. Also, pertains to the alternates. So calling that out as another kind of responsibility, ensuring that especially for those joint committees, that the village does have adequate representation in there, especially since some of them are kind of equal split across the board. So I think that's just one part of this that I think comes into play. And, again, For me, the big thing about all of this is that it

So this might be a Rick question. So as we're having this discussion here, and at times the regular meetings are changed to another day. Like for example, the JFC meeting that I missed was on a day that I work late. I notified the board prior that that's my late working day. So maybe there needs to be some accountability for what happens when meetings are moved.

Casey. Rick, would that fall under the ordinances that require agendas to be properly posted and so on? Is that not covered there?

Okay, thanks for clarifying that it's 24 for the agenda posting. I mean, as you said, yeah, I think the fact that you can still have two days after A meeting, even a moved meeting, still gives plenty of time to make some sort of communication. As you said, no particular excuse is necessary. So I think it's still covered.

Just trying to wrap my head around making sure I know what this is and what this isn't. So basically, we're just laying the framework that you to have an excused absence that wouldn't count for this. You just notify the chairperson within 48 hours before or after your absence, and then it's an excused absence. If you just have at least three unexcused absences, then that prompts the discussion at the board level to remove a committee member. And that is required 2 thirds vote. Is that kind of what I'm, you know, the summary here of. It's basically 48 hours of either end of the meeting to quali

I'll move approval of ordinance one nine dash 2026 regarding village committee meeting attendance.

Sure. I would like to see the consideration for, you know, what would be considered a reasonable attempt to restore a trustee's connection before proceeding with substantive or majority vote. That's one thing I'd like to have considered. And then another thing I'd like to have considered is what objective criteria to term inference and what safeguards are there to prevent authority from this being weaponized to silence somebody, an elected trustee who actually disagrees perhaps with the president or who's ever in charge let me see here I wrote down a couple things so the other the advance know

Sure, thanks. One question I had was about if you have, where is this? Keep your video on throughout the meeting and when you're voting. I have at times had when you have a Not super fast internet connection, having speaking and having your video on at the same time. Is that, I guess, is that something you'd want members to disclose if they're having any connection difficulties or do you think that's just kind of up to the participants? I think unstable connection or something comes up on Zoom if your internet isn't fast enough to do speaking and Video at the same time.

Yeah. Yeah, just if we should communicate those issues just so it's transparent. I'm on a commission with someone who doesn't ever have their camera on because they think AI will then generate them in a virtual world. So I don't know if just communication for transparency purposes.

Thank you. So I first want to say I appreciate you taking a stab at updating this policy. I think it definitely needed some update because it's very much in that era, initial era of COVID and some of the languages that's in there and aiming to add some of that flexibility in here is definitely appreciated. And so going back to Heidi's point, that's where like section 5 paragraph 2 we can kind of expand the other circumstances, prevent them from doing so sentence. That's where I was kind of looking into because of those different circumstances that have already been talked about that. There cou

All it comes down to was the goal with this policy is like how explicit do you want to be because one of the challenges if it's too narrow there's going to be some kind of scenario you might forget or miss in there so in some cases having a broader statement can go could provide that flexibility down the line again it's a reasonable kind of expectation and combination in there, kind of using some of those languages that can come into play. But for me, it's like I would be okay with a broader statement, not going in full detail, but I would be open to narrowing it down a little bit.

And I wouldn't necessarily want to. Create some kind of. you know, if someone has a slower internet connection or doesn't have the technical capabilities from their home, like prevent them from participating or put them on the spot. So, you know, that is kind of a balance there to find because, you know, we still have, you know, technology isn't perfect everywhere. So, yeah, I don't want to make it too narrow that, Everybody has to explain everything to everyone on line all the time. I don't know if that makes sense. We want to be. Equitable also to make sure everyone has the opportunity to pa

Two questions for Rick. So this one is written with the word shall throughout the document, whereas the last one we just talked about was written with may. So what changes in this document using the shall language? For instance, is there some type of repercussions because the word shall is used instead of may? Can you talk to that just a little bit, please?

It did. Second part of that question is, you know, we're obviously using the raise hand feature today and it's working well. But in any meeting environment, right, and we follow Robert's rules, someone can make the point of order or point of information. And so, I mean, do we need to call that out that that's not a raise your hand thing? Because I mean, in essence, I can just say point of information while somebody's speaking because it is germane to what they're speaking to.

Can we get another draft before we take our up and down boat on this?

Yeah, I'm fine. It did sound like there were more than a few ads, so I'm also fine with this coming back as a fresh draft.

Sorry, I hit the wrong button there. I would also be okay with bringing it back with full drafts in there. So just to verbalize, so you have the majorities asking for that. Thank you.

Well does anyone have any advice on how to share my PowerPoint with you guys it's sort of well I was gonna yeah I was gonna say I mean Nick is it the same I I believe it's you know attached in the agenda it is this game yep okay I mean we we could just scroll along with the pdf there if someone if a staff member can share the

This is more just a comment sort of echoing what you said, Cindy. I had a number of residents who were very concerned ahead of time. with this revaluation, but many of them responded very favorably to the communication afterwards saying, you know, they had no idea the open book process was so straightforward that they could just come in. You know, a number had the sort of informal review for things. And so, yeah, lots of compliments for staff and for the appraiser for the communication. I think that helped make this much, much smoother than it would have been otherwise.

Yeah, in the spirit of Halloween, I'm going to do my best to send the impression here. Let me get ready. Sorry. Okay. So this is for Deer Donation Month. It's pretty simple. Just encouraging people to donate any surplus wild game they have through programs like the deer donation program with the DNR or any other independent things.

I move approval of the proclamation for declaring November Deer Donation Month.

Yeah, so we've had board members, I believe myself included, talk about interest in trying to do what we can to help preserve farmland and slow outward sprawl. I think the comp plan survey has shown some appetite that from residents too. So this change would just open up some other types of residential development in different kinds of zoning districts. And there's two options here. One for just updating residential uses in residential districts. There's also an option for Allowing residential uses in non-residential districts to try to help maximize being able to build housing where we can wi

Thank you. We talk about land use a lot on the Capital Area Regional Planning Commission that I sit on. And so we definitely talk about the preservation of farmland and infill development and housing affordability and redevelopment sites. So I get to see a lot of examples across the county of things that people are doing. And I think you know, a couple other things that we could do hand in hand with this is working on boundary agreements with our neighbors, because, you know, some things that could happen in the futures, if we aren't annexing land, not that we should do it just for this reason

Heidi, I would agree about particularly the boundary agreements. You know, obviously, you know, one of Madison creeping in is kind of a big deal. You know, it's the west side of the village. But I guess my concern is I feel like, again, this is the same concern I had with the parking issue. Is that we're getting ahead of the comp plan? I know that Aaron emailed us out the survey results and I've been going through it. There's a lot of information there and a lot of comments from residents, which is fabulous. I'm glad that we got all of that, but I haven't necessarily made heads or tails of all

Yeah, as far as getting getting ahead of ourselves here I don't know that we are and you know I mean we started updating the housing chapter of the cow plan 15 16 months ago and the cow plan is going to be finished in April so that's going to end up being about two years from start to finish and you know that's an entire term for a trustee and I don't think that we can just throw up our hands and do nothing because we're working on it as we're you know part of our responsibility is to look through things and work on stuff like this. We can't just hunt on it for two years because we're also doi

So, Paula, to your point about, you know, about that we can, we don't have to annex things and connive them, I agree. But I think Heidi, you know, kind of brought this up as well, that Just because we deny something doesn't mean that another municipality, Madison, is the typical one, but we have other neighbors as well. So I think I agree with Chris that we should be taking steps. We can't wait on everything for the comp plan, and we can't keep. It can't all be all done at the same time. We need to do some work along the way. That said, the item for it right now is not to make any particular c

And so, I have a couple points here. One, regarding the annexation discussion, one of the other things I just also want to point out too is the climate that we are in with the state government and the way that finance for local municipalities is happening. So it's a challenge for us in that unless something changes at the state government, the way that aid to local government has, in essence, flatlined. Yes, it's kind of increased a little bit recently, but it's to the point where we can't really Count on it at this point in the long term, especially in some of the discussions that's happening

And Matt put his video on. So I was kind of interested to hear how staff, Matt and maybe Erin, also thought that these 2 things like how the zoning ordinance can help inform the comprehensive plan as we update that and like, how those 2 things can work together.

I'd kind of like to hear some more information about what these options would look like. Additional infill should be served by already existing infrastructure, but maybe... I don't know, certain lines need to be upsized to serve something or, you know, you need a stoplight somewhere or improvements to the intersection. So, like, how do we balance some, like, upgrades of infrastructure? Like, I think that's considered, like, an upgrade of existing infrastructure, not that you need new infrastructure, but it's, like, the same stretch of road. I think, yeah, I'd like to hear more information abou

Yeah, so I'll just verbalize kind of what you alluded to that. Yes, I'm definitely open to having conversations about all land uses and definitely agree with what Heidi just kind of mentioned there. Want to learn a little bit more as part of this conversation. I'm not advocating for it right now. I just want to have that information so that we can make an informed choice.

Sorry. I am trying to discern the survey results and the raw data and the conversations, because I think we are in a catch 22 with this one in terms of stopping the sprawl. But if we're doing infill and we were building higher density from what I read of the survey, I feel like those two things kind of fly in the face as to what people want because I'm reading survey questions, I guess, much differently and I haven't had time to analyze the comments for high density versus against high density and really dissect what that looks like. you know, my, my gut reaction to the, some reading through t

Yeah, Paul kind of mentioned the kind of inherent issue with surveys like this is that each question is kind of answered in a vacuum, you know. there might be someone who wants to preserve farmland and also want single family only housing, but you can't really have both because those are kind of competing things. You know, you want development to pay for itself and you can want more density, but those things kind of butt up against each other too. So it's a hard balance, but yeah, you know, it's something that I think we should still keep going forward with to get more information.

Yeah, I move that we direct staff to draft language to implement these zoning changes, both options one and two, to bring back for further discussion and consideration.

This would come back to. Plan commission before it comes to us is that.

So, to clarify that, because I. Since we do want to consider this, can we bring it here first before we finalize what goes to plan commission? Is that an option procedurally? Because I think we don't know what we're sending, because we're not going to send both option one and two to plan commission, right?

Right. Yeah, that's fine that it has to go there at some point, but I don't know if I need to modify my motion, but the spirit of my motion is that it comes to us first to decide what we're going to actually move forward on. And I also, I guess, wanted to clarify whether it's Aaron or Matt or whoever, do you think you have sufficient direction to bring back You know, enough information as Heidi and Paula and others, you know, had other questions that might have not been in the memo. Do you have enough to bring us back something very meaty, I guess? I believe so, yes.

So, sorry, I guess this is part of me misunderstanding your intent there, Casey, because I think part of it is I also want to lean on the experts that are in the room that is the planning commission in there and getting their feedback along the way. I think for our purposes, Getting them in early in the discussion, leaning on their feedback can go a long way for us to kind of draft and move this forward a little bit. So I would be okay sending it to Planning Commission, because that's kind of been our MO with items that go to committees, or for items that could impact committees, we typically

Well, so first, Paula, you had your hand, I think, after someone in here. I did.

I put it down because I thought I was going to be called on next.

That's okay. No, so... I guess, again, my question is, what's the rush? I would love to see conversation happen at the Planning Commission first before we direct staff to draft an ordinance. You know, I mentioned my thoughts about the survey and I dumped it into AI super quick just to see, like, am I way off base with my idea of what I'm kind of reading from those things? And so there's two items of note that I think are interesting. You know, one, we had 468 contributions, but it's only 5% of our village residents. But when, and this is what AI came back with just doing a quick analysis of su

Yeah, so I'm going to keep mine in the spirit. I intended that this comes back to to the board and then if we send an if we have an actual ordinance that's what goes to to plan commission and wherever a public hearing needs to get scheduled I don't really care one way or the other I think that that still provides plenty of time for discussion for further feedback I'll also say I don't think I don't think it's appropriate to be consulting AI for our decisions as trustees or for evaluating resident or constituent feedback. We're elected for our views, for our judgments and opinions. Not to have

I more wanted to give just some extra direction to staff because I think that it's being stretched a little bit that just because it's infill it means that we want like ultra high density in areas which I don't feel like that's That's not what I'm intending on this. I think that utilizing areas for housing doesn't necessarily mean that I want to build a 10-story building somewhere. I think that those are kind of two different things for me, that maybe a four-unit cottage court of senior housing that has no steps to go in might fit into some of these areas. I don't want to limit us to just infi

Chris and then Renee on the debate on the motion yeah I'm just gonna echo kind of what Heidi said that these changes wouldn't permit a like a mid-rise or high-rise apartment the maximum would be a an eight unit apartment on this so this talking about high or very high density this isn't dealing with high or very high density big apartments it's It's small little apartments, duplexes, townhouses, cottage courts, like you already mentioned.

So I read the summary from Grave 2 on pages 6 to 7, and Grave acknowledges that the younger residents were under representative and households with families with kids were definitely over representative. And this kind of tails on to what Heidi was saying. this matters for decisions about housing and senior services and transportation and community facilities. And I agree with Paula, too. I mean, what is the rush? You know, I look at Taylor Prairie and, you know, the expected expansion, and now we've got a school setting that's closed down. So I don't think rushing into these decisions is wise

Excuse me. So this was kind of born from... I've heard from a lot of people, and I'm sure you guys have too, that we don't We want to be our own thing. We don't want to turn into Madison. We don't want to turn into Sun Prairie, things like that. And of course, that means different things to different people. But one of the things it means to me is we got to avoid some of the development patterns that they've fallen into. If you look at places like Stoughton Road in Madison or Grand Avenue in Sun Prairie, it's pretty significant strip development. And it gets away from a walkable type small tow

Great, thank you. I appreciate you all bringing this forward. This is definitely something I heard when I was out talking to folks as part of the campaign. and folks really that's one of the things that they I heard often was that we are missing that true downtown space that feel and when I kind of was asking clarifying questions of what they mean by that is exactly this is like having that building kind of right up against the road not having that parking lot set back in there it creates that walkable safe environment that kind of fits that can fit within our charm that are in there. And I th

Yeah, thank you. You know, when I think about it a little bit, envisioning what we're talking about here, you look at Old Town in 1855 and the Old Town Cafe It's it's on the street, it's inviting for pedestrians, but you have ease of parking behind and along the side of the building. It really brings that business forward into the. You know, into the community part of the community and I think and then you have. You know some you know housing on top I mean it's it's the type of downtown type of building that I think would be great to promote the you know and yes perhaps take these next steps t

Sure, so just 1 point of clarification for JP, you mentioned Stoughton Stoughton does have on street parking in the historic area on main street. So it goes all the way from the fire station city hall down to live. So, in their historic. Downtown, which many consider the center of stone, they do have that on street parking. So I guess, you know, for me, again, we've got a survey and, you know, I asked myself what evidence of people desiring this is in the survey. And it appears there's only one comment specifically to the parking behind a commercial building rather than in front. And it's on p

Again, Paul, I was just expressing what residents had told me. They pointed to Stoughton, among other communities, as an example in there. So I'm sorry if I confused or didn't say that as clear as I should have. That's the feedback that I got. And so part of it is, for me, I've said from the get-go that I'm looking to make data-informed decisions. And so a survey is definitely one part of the piece of the data. But Again, I'm looking at this from all the conversations. I talked to probably close to over 1,000 people, if not more, during the campaign, and many of them brought up, the downtown,

Yeah. So JP, I agree sort of with what you're saying about you know, multiple points of data. And I think that that this is exactly that we have, you know, the respondents of the survey and the, the very start of it you know has two camps and one of those camps is the, is to build a walkable bikeable community. And I think that's well, well, no, they're there was only one particular question about this specific sort of thing. A walkable community is one with this kind of setup as opposed to strip development. Also, the reverse is also true. I don't think anyone here has heard from a resident o

Yeah, I just wanted to point out that limiting strip development, limiting setbacks, and encouraging parking behinds Buildings is in the current COMP plan. So presumably community had feedback to include that in our last COMP plan. And unless we've got an influx of a bunch of people who suddenly want strip development, I would imagine that's going to remain consistent for the next COMP plan. So yeah, I still want to see this move forward.

I get everything everyone's saying. You know, just, I guess a reminder to Casey, I was elected to, and I had a lot of conversations on the campaign trail as well. I've lived here for well over 20 years, so I've had a lot of conversations too, and I'm hearing a different story than you guys are. So I think when you say there's two camps in this community, there very much is. And so I think there has to be a balancing act between the two of them. Because truly, even though it's our supporters who elected us, in essence, we do represent everyone. And so when I'm asking to pump the brakes or slow

I will move that we direct staff to draft language to implement the zoning changes regarding parking as expressed in the memo to be brought back to the village board and ultimately sent to plan commission.

Casey, would you be able to modify that to language for an overlay district? I don't want to limit to just the parking lot portion of it. So the overlay district with relevant requirements for development.

Yes. So, Amanda, I do want to include the zoning overlay district.

I will move approval of the Memorandum of Understanding with Deer Grove Paramedics Local 311.

we can move on to report from the library board JP okay so we met on Wednesday October 21st we we approved our minutes from our 923 meeting we had a discussion regarding the National Friends of library week in there that was happening that week From a programming report, we continue to have strong attendance, kind of on track with the other reports I have given. We're well over 4,500. I think the number was closer to 46, almost 4,700 attendees, again, with two months to go. In there we had a discussion regarding our all community read and the update was that Ann Garvin was selected and she did

Just wanted to shout out, since you mentioned the reading at Drummond Reserve, I know a lot of the library board postings are for But they've also been having some really fantastic talks at Drumlin Reserve where they get speakers. They've talked about Cottage Grove history. There was one just recently about that was from a, a, I believe pediatric psychologist or child development psychologist talking about like AI and sorry, not AI social media usage for young people, just really good stuff going on. So Keep an eye on library posting if you're, you know, not a young person and want to learn so

Yep, thank you. So we met as a fairly brief meeting on Thursday, October 22nd. We postpone the discussion from the residents on whispering way as they were unable to attend that evening. Just a little background, there's no sidewalk there, so the right-of-way of the street can be a little bit fuzzy, but there's trees that are not approved street trees planted within the right-of-way, so we're going to have that discussion with the resident. Hopefully, they're available at our next meeting to talk about that. Then this has been a couple months in discussions talking about female cottonwood tree

Casey, I guess I'll just sort of voice. I don't. I don't feel like the board needs to take any action considering on the public side, staff enforcers are not planting them, not seeking to plant them, and they're not available. And on the private side, I think that is, I agree that that's far too thorny of a thing to step into for something that is not a health and safety issue. So I'm not inclined to take any action on it.

I don't have any. Oh, sorry. I forgot to raise my hand. I have no problem taking action on it and just banning the female cottonwoods. I think it would be helpful maybe just as a proactive measure. And Sean, I'm sure maybe you have this information already about a seed suppressant. that can be sprayed on existing cottonwoods and just providing that information to residents. But I mean, banning the future planting of them, I think is probably a good thing. That's just my two cents.

I just wanted to then wrap up with our Parks and Rec meeting. Since our next meeting would fall on Thanksgiving Day, we reschedule. We usually have to do this since it's for Thursday, always falls Thanksgiving, and then during the Christmas holiday time. So I believe, Sean, did we decide on December 17th was the date of our next meeting? Am I remembering that correctly?

Yeah, the third Thursday instead of the fourth because we didn't want to meet on the holidays.

Move approval. Nope. You said it first. All right. I would move approval of the focus group appointments as presented. I'll second.

Yeah, Matt, just for the Uphoff property, you said two developers are either them just because I know that there's been historically, like a number of developers that have put in and come out and put in are either of these two, have they been here before basically in, in the village or what do you, what do you mean? Yeah. Have they been, have they made inquiries or didn't due diligence for this property before, or are they new to this property?

OK, thanks. It was just a curiosity. Yeah.

These excerpts are remarks by officials whose identity a person confirmed, from a transcript generated automatically from the official public meeting video and presented unedited. Accuracy may vary; view the original recording for reference.