Village Board - Regular Meeting

Wednesday, October 28, 2026

The Village of Cottage Grove Board of Review approved the previous meeting's minutes and held one property tax assessment objection hearing.

About this meeting

Government Body
Village Board
Meeting Type
Village Board
Location
Village of Cottage Grove, WI
Meeting Date
October 28, 2026

Published excerpts

Only published remarks appear here. The full transcript is not published.

9 sections

You said you had an assessment done last year. Ms. Laurie, in 25, is that correct?

I was just clarifying you hadn't had a private assessment done for some reason.

I think, and Nick, correct me if I'm wrong, the only other one listed in South Area 1 is number 12, 405 Roland Court. I was just paging through and I saw the rest were all Northeast or Central Platts. Is that right?

Well, so yours is listed as South Area 1, and the only one in the chart of comparables is this, is number 12, 405 Roland Court, and that's... It's not in Shady Grove, but it's just south of West Cottage Grove. On the map there, it's the number 12. It's okay. I guess, Nick, they say south area number one is how many south areas were there? Because that seems like as far west as the south part of the village goes.

It's not. It's not even near. It's not off Taylor Street at all. I don't know.

Understood. Real quick so in terms of just the land value not improvements like obviously there's you know a number of like the criteria as you went over for the improvements is there anything for the land or is it just raw size square footage that determines that raw size okay and the land table was built based off of vacant land sales okay And you said that the 14 shows here were all chosen primarily based on the time that they were built?

Right. But yeah, I'm talking. So I understand that was your criteria for picking these. But among those, the closest one with the closest land area is number 11, 15,000 square feet for the lot. Hers is 20,000 square feet. So again, I understand what your criteria was. I'm just noting that it doesn't.

I'm inclined to agree. Laurie, you did bring up a number of important points, especially in comparison to the properties listed with your view here. I think there are a number of them that would have potentially swung the other way had your property been sold at the times of these sales in that market. And since that's the methodology required by statute and for the assessor to go by, I appreciate your argument that markets change and fluctuate and things would be different at different times. But that's not what the statute requires. And then that's unfortunately not what we're able to go off

And to clarify, that would be so This would be the assessment after the open book adjustment that was from 445,000 down to this 431. That's the one I'm looking at right now, and that's the one we'd be sustaining. I will make the motion to sustain the assessment in light of all the evidence presented in accordance with state statute.

These excerpts are remarks by officials whose identity a person confirmed, from a transcript generated automatically from the official public meeting video and presented unedited. Accuracy may vary; view the original recording for reference.