Sausalito, on the Record · Part 2 of 3 · The Waterfront

What a Ballot Can’t Decide on Sausalito’s Waterfront

In 2026 Sausalito spent a year arguing over Measure X, a ballot measure to open up its old shipyard. In the same year the city refused to transfer a marina’s lease to its buyer, and a developer filed for 294 apartments on a site the housing plan had counted for 129, and neither of those was on the ballot.

Map: one dot per building in the City of Sausalito, from OpenStreetMap (© OpenStreetMap contributors). Gold marks the place a moment is about; a wide ring means the whole town.

At a Glance
2,324 to 1,681
against Measure X in the county’s count on Nov. 13, not yet certified
$991,980
scheduled yearly rental income for the whole marina property, in the buyer’s estimate from the owner’s 2025 figures
294
apartments at one site where the housing plan counted 129
The finding
In the county’s count so far, voters kept, by a wide margin, the rule that the town’s commercial and industrial zoning cannot change without a vote of the whole town, while the marina rent increases the tenants described and the Harbor Drive application went forward outside it.

In July 2026 a woman who had signed the petition for Measure X came to the City Council to say that she wished she hadn’t, and to describe what signing it had cost her. “I signed the petition under the influence of a kind, well-meaning friend who is very pro,” she said. “I now regret signing it. Fully one half my friends won’t speak with me because I signed the petition. The other half are starting to be mad at me because I regret signing it.”

The petition was for something called the Arts, Industrial and Maritime Preservation and Improvement Initiative, which appeared on the ballot as Measure X, and by the time she reached the microphone it had divided a town of 6,900 people into two camps that could not agree on what the word “preservation” meant. The fight was over the Marinship, the north end of Sausalito’s waterfront, which was a shipyard during World War II and is today about 225 acres in nearly 100 parcels, with roughly 69 owners and 1.3 million square feet of buildings, on ground threatened in places by flooding,1 and for forty years its zoning could not be changed without a vote of the whole town.

The argument

What the ballot box can and cannot do for Sausalito’s waterfront

Part 1 of this series argued that Sausalito’s government answers most readily to residents protecting what they own, and the Marinship rule hands those residents their most powerful instrument, the ballot box. Because any change to the zoning there needs a vote of the whole town, every voter in Sausalito holds a veto over 225 acres that about 69 owners actually own. Fischel’s argument cuts both ways here: a veto protects the town from a council that might trade the waterfront away, and it also makes the waterfront very hard to change on purpose.

Measure X asked voters to hand that power back to the council, and we think both sides had a real case. Its backers argued that the Marinship was decaying under rules nobody could change, while its opponents argued that the measure would let it be built out several times over and that it insulted the people already working there. Latitude 38, which opposed it, wrote after the vote that its apparent defeat “does not resolve the underlying issues”,2 and that seems to us exactly right.

What the year actually showed is how much of the waterfront’s future sits outside that veto, and some of it outside City Hall’s reach altogether. Under state density-bonus law, a developer asked for more than twice the homes the city’s housing plan had counted at Harbor Drive. At Pelican Harbor, where the city refused to transfer a marina’s tidelands lease, boat tenants said they had been sent rent increases of 174% and 250%, though the record does not show who set them. And by the city’s own shoreline plan, the tide will reach $160 million to $570 million worth of assets within two or three decades if nothing is done, and none of it was on the November ballot.

Across California, the state’s housing plan says California must plan for more than 2.5 million homes in the current eight-year cycle,3 density-bonus law is state law that local voters cannot override, and the state’s sea-level guidance, adopted in 2024, asks coastal governments to plan for the same rising water.4 Local control is real in Sausalito, and the town uses it with real skill, but it is a much stronger tool for saying no to a project than for meeting the problems now arriving from Sacramento and from the bay.

March 2026

A boatyard appealed a business-tax reclassification and won unanimously

In September 2025 a consultant auditing business taxes for the city moved a boatyard, KKMI Sausalito, into a higher tax category, a call the city’s finance director adopted, and the boatyard was billed $66,047.80, of which $36,127 was tax and $29,920.80 was penalties.5 When the boatyard appealed to the City Council in March 2026, city staff recommended keeping the higher category and waiving only the penalties, and the council instead overturned the reclassification unanimously and waived the penalties as well. It took the council nearly two hours, but the dispute was specific and the decision sat squarely within the city’s own authority, which is more than could be said for what came next.

May 2026

The council refused to transfer a marina’s tidelands lease to its buyer

The marina case that followed was harder, because part of Pelican Harbor sits over submerged tidelands the city leases to its owner, under a lease that runs to 2040 and pays the city $39,443 a year, as adjusted.6 In spring 2026 the leaseholder asked the city to approve a transfer of that lease to a buyer, and the buyer’s own projections were in the council’s packet: a stated purchase price of $13,356,000,6 and scheduled rental income for the whole property of $991,980 a year, in the buyer’s estimate from the owner’s 2025 figures, against which the yearly lease payment to the city was $39,443.7

The city’s room to act was narrow, and its own staff said so. Under state case law, the staff report explained, consent could not be refused “to extract higher rent than contracted,” and under the lease “rent increases by the tenant are not prohibited”.8 People who keep boats at the marina came to speak anyway. “It’s a very close family group down there,” one said. Mayor Steven Woodside, laying out the choices, noted that the city is steward of part of the land,9 and a council member added that the buyer had written to say he would attend. The council voted to deny consent, and the minutes record the vote as unanimous among the four members present.

By July the boat owners were back, and this time they had received notices. The city’s records do not show who set the new rents, though Latitude 38 reported that the marina learned on July 2 that the buyer from May had completed the purchase, apparently by buying the company that holds the lease,10 and the tenants were clear about what the letters said. “In my hand I have my slip rent increase letter from our new harbormaster,” one told the council. “This letter actually represents a rent increase of 174%.” Another said, “We’ve recently all gotten rent increases of 250%, and we are shocked.”

Two weeks later Woodside came out of a closed session and said the council had told the city attorney to look at “potential causes of action regarding the property transaction involving Pelican Harbor” and at what the city could do about the rent increases the tenants had been sent. In September the interim city manager said the city had sent the property’s owners a demand for an audit and was waiting for an answer, and no lawsuit appears on the tape. John Arndt, writing in the sailing magazine Latitude 38, put the tenants’ case most plainly: “The scale of the increase for Pelican Yacht Harbor is way out of line with what anyone might reasonably expect,” he wrote. The council had used the one lever it held, its consent as landlord of the tidelands, and the tenants say their rents went up all the same.

June 2026

Measure X reached the council, which was required to put it on the ballot

Measure X arrived at the council on June 16. It would have raised the height limit in the industrial zone from 32 feet to 47, let buildings cover 70% of a lot, raised the allowed floor space several times over, repealed the Marinship’s own plan, and let the council change commercial and industrial zoning anywhere outside the downtown historic district without going to the voters.11 The council spent 99 minutes on it, about 54 of them hearing the public.

“Sausalito could become the first Bay Area city to lose its working waterfront, not to development, but to neglect,” a supporter said. One of the measure’s proponents, a former council member, summed up what the town had done after years of studies: “And guess what we did? Nothing. Absolutely nothing.” Two weeks earlier, one of the people who drafted it had argued that converting an empty building in the Marinship to an art studio “should not require a citywide vote.” Opponents answered with the scale of what the measure would allow. “It increases allowable development density in the industrial zone by 650%, not double, 650%. In the water zone by 900%,” one said, and another defended the people who already work in the Marinship. “What an insult to the men and women who work every day in the Marinship, who kept this town afloat during COVID and 9/11 when tourism was dead. I can assure that these people are not encased in amber.”

Public comment, June 2026For Measure X“Sausalito could become the first Bay Area city to lose its working waterfront, not to development, but to neglect”Official recording at 2:58:24 ↗
Public comment, June 2026Against Measure X“It increases allowable development density in the industrial zone by 650%, not double, 650%. In the water zone by 900%”Official recording at 3:07:08 ↗
Public comment, June 2026Against Measure X“What an insult to the men and women who work every day in the Marinship, who kept this town afloat during COVID and 9/11 when tourism was dead. I can assure that these people are not encased in amber”Official recording at 2:49:48 ↗

The council had no real choice about the outcome; it “must place the measure on the ballot,” the staff report said,12 and it did so unanimously. After the vote, arguing for an outside analysis of the measure, a council member warned about how far it reached: “This is different from many ballot initiatives in that it is self-executing. It takes effect 10 days after certification of the election results. The measure as written designates all existing uses throughout town, with the exception of the historic district, as nonconforming.” The city attorney’s summary describes the zoning change as covering commercial and industrial districts outside the historic downtown.

June 2026

A developer filed for 294 apartments where the housing plan counted 129

While the town argued about the Marinship, the housing site voters had already rezoned produced a much larger number. In November 2025 Sausalito’s voters had approved a rezoning for housing, Measure J, that included an office building at 1 Harbor Drive, and the city’s housing plan counted 129 homes across 1 and 3 Harbor Drive.13 In 2026 a developer filed for 294, in six stories, 59 of them for low-income households, and city staff described the path as a permit issued without environmental review.14 A speaker for Save Our Sausalito, a group campaigning against Measure X, put it this way. “It’s 129 units was what we saw in Measure J. And now it is 294 units.”

Measure X asked voters to give up their veto over commercial and industrial zoning outside downtown, the Marinship included, and trust the council to manage what followed, while at the site voters had already rezoned under Measure J, the developer, asking for waivers under state density-bonus law, applied for more than twice the homes the plan had counted, and the application was still incomplete in October.

November 2026

The count so far, and the question neither campaign answered

Through mid-October the committee for Measure X had raised $119,852.83, including $30,000 from the Sausalito Sustainable Waterfront Association and $20,000 from a single company, while the No on Measure X committee, sponsored by Save Our Sausalito, had raised $72,957.30.1516 As of the county’s count on Nov. 13, still not certified, Measure X had 1,681 votes in favor and 2,324 against, or 58 percent against.17

The day after the vote, John Arndt identified what neither campaign had addressed: “Flooding caused by sea-level rise along the Sausalito waterfront remains another issue for which neither side had solutions,” he wrote in Latitude 38. That is the exposure the city’s shoreline plan puts in the hundreds of millions of dollars within two or three decades if nothing is done.18

If the count holds, the town keeps the veto it has held for forty years, and we do not think that is a bad outcome in itself; a community is entitled to decide that it does not want its waterfront built out several times over. But the veto covers a narrower question than the town’s future, which is how its commercial and industrial land, the Marinship included, may be zoned, and much of what will shape the waterfront over the next decade falls outside it, including the extra apartments state density-bonus law allows at Harbor Drive and the water the shoreline plan expects. Sausalito will have to make those decisions with tools other than the ballot, and at Pelican Harbor the boat owners say their rents have gone up, while the city, when it last spoke of it in September, was still waiting on an audit.

Next in the series: Part 3 of 3, The Money. The hill and the water both end up, sooner or later, in the city’s budget, which is why the last part turns to the office that keeps the city’s books, and to whether the city can see what it has spent in time to act on it.

Methodology

How we checked

The meetings: Hamlet’s transcripts are speech-to-text made from the city’s public video. Each quote was matched word for word to the transcript, with “um”, “uh” and repeated false starts removed and nothing else changed, and two AI models from different companies confirmed what was happening around it. Every quote was then checked against the audio by a second company’s speech model and again by the first; no person has listened to them. On one line the models heard a word differently, and that word is left outside the quotation marks. Each video link opens a few seconds before the first words quoted.

The documents: Each figure from a city document, a campaign filing or the county’s results was read off the linked page by the same two models, working separately.

The people: We have not named members of the public or boat tenants, although the city’s own video and documents, which we link, show their names, and the rent increases are reported here as the tenants’ own accounts. The boatyard is named from the city’s staff report, and the marina’s buyer is not named in our text.

Credit: John Arndt of Latitude 38 covered the marina and the measure as they happened, and Ruth Dusseault of Bay City News covered the measure. The Marin Independent Journal’s Steven Rosenfeld covered both throughout, and his reporting pointed us to the meetings.

What is not here: We filed no records requests and interviewed no one, so we do not know how the marina sale closed or what the boat owners now pay.

Sources & Data

Enjoying The District?

Get data-driven local government stories in your inbox every week. Free, no spam.

Search Sausalito's meetings on Hamlet