City Council - Regular Meeting

Wednesday, September 16, 2026

The Cincinnati City Council appointed former council member Reginald Harris to the Planning Commission, approved a rezone for a Westwood housing development, and recognized community advocates and organizations.

About this meeting

Government Body
City Council
Meeting Type
City Council
Location
Cincinnati, OH
Meeting Date
September 16, 2026

Transcript

1086 sections

2:13Speaker 27

Our first speaker is Michelle Rosemond. Welcome.

2:30 – 3:33Speaker 24

Good afternoon. My name is Michelle Roseman. I am the daughter of freedom writer Betty Daniels Roseman. And I'm here to thank you all for considering the honorary street naming in her honor at the corner of Belmont and Hamilton Avenue. My mother believed at an early age that everyone was created equal and everyone should have the same opportunities as everybody in America. She protested, she was arrested. She had a case that went all the way to the Supreme court. So the freedom riders changed the world. And I just want to thank you for everything that you're doing. I know you don't get thanked enough, but the work that you're doing does not go unnoticed. And you all are here trying to make a change as well. My mother passed away January, um, 2026 this year. And even though her journey has ended, her story and her legacy will continue. So I just want to say thank you again.

3:33 – 3:47Speaker 27

That's beautiful. Thank you. Susan Lakes, welcome.

3:49 – 5:51Speaker 9

Hi, everybody. Hope you're having a good day. I'm here to talk about a speedway, Liberty Street. I live in over the Rhine, south of Liberty, but I spend a lot of time north of Liberty going to Findlay Market. Both places are great. First of all, There's a lot of construction. I hope all of you know. I think somebody told me they're repairing a gas line or something at Vine and Liberty. Has everybody seen what's going on there? It's been going on a couple weeks. I'd encourage you to drive there. I'm a pedestrian, okay? Somebody's gonna get killed. They've got it down to, there's an arrow pointing for the people turning north off the Liberty to go to Vine, which is really, really crowded. When they make the turn, they can't see when the walkers have the right of way. I had two friends who came this close to getting clobbered yesterday. It was real personal for me today. And I'm not faulting the drivers. It's impossible for the drivers to see when we have the right of way. Please check that out. Please, please, please. The other thing is, and I've gone on and on about this, there's the Crooked Crosswalk. There where Biscuit Love is, do you know where I mean? You push a button, okay, you push a button, all traffic's supposed to stop, and you can cross Liberty. Then you have to make a little jag, you push another button, and you may, it's good and it's well-intended.

5:51Speaker 27

Thank you very much. Dr. Dhrushala. Welcome.

6:05 – 8:07Speaker 35

I'm just going to do a continuation because I was cut off on my two minutes last week, so I'm going to pick up where I left off. I'm asking again for your help. I don't care if it's big or small. to get this cannabis store open up before the winter kicks in. I'm getting rumors that you've already voted on this. That hurts my feeling because I come here sincerely. I come in the name of I am that I am, the power that I serve today, because I know that power can get things done even . So I'm asking you to please, Assist me. I'm right there on that corner of California and Redding Road. These young people are actually ready for this. And it's cold out there. I've seen them last winter shaking like a leaf. I've given them all the job information I could get from the job fair at the library. I've given them all of the expungement information. And I have to be doing something at the store, want to take care of this. This was a personal thing in the beginning. Now I want to do it for their children. It's not for the grown people now. This is for those little babies I see that these people are having on that corner. And they are not, all of those people are not disrespectful out there. you'll find one or two of them will get on your nerve and then eventually they come back with a calm spirit. When they get a job, the people who they work for, they know they have these bad records, so they, you know, they kind of tick them off. They need to be more lenient with these people with these backgrounds because they need to clear up their record. I'm not saying we should feel sorry for the older people, but it takes a whole village to raise those other babies coming up in the next generation. So if anybody could help me, I'll take any help you can give me. That's all I have to say. Thank you for your time.

8:07Speaker 27

Thanks very much. Jeremy Hudson, welcome.

8:16 – 10:14Speaker 17

Good afternoon, Mayor Perval, members of City Council. My name is Jeremy Hudson. I'm proudly employed by and here today representing O'Rourke Wrecking Company. O'Rourke is a local woman-owned demolition environmental remediation company. We have been located within Cincinnati and performing work for its residents and businesses throughout our 65-year corporate history. I'm here today to speak specifically against Council's adoption of agenda item number 47, which modifies the city's current commercial waste hauler franchise program. The updates to this program were just introduced before the Budget and Finance Committee on Monday of this week. This ordinance represents massive regulatory changes, yet it was never vetted with industry partners. In fact, I received a copy of the updates for the very first time this morning at 11 a.m., less than three hours ago, without any prior knowledge or outreach from the city. As written, these updates place an unmanageable administrative burden on both the city and local franchisees, including requiring an estimate prepared by a registered engineer or registered architect that has to be submitted at the time of permit application for a wide variety of permits, not just demolition. Filing forms out prescribed by the city manager which have not been seen nor vetted. Filing annual reports examined by an independent certified public accountant. Maintaining atypical daily records subject at all times to review by the city. Voting to amend or modify the waste hauler franchise program needs to be paused. It must be held until these changes can be fully vetted by all impacted parties, allowing due process for public, contractor, and end user comment. Please do not pass this ordinance today. Give local businesses a seat at the table first. Thank you.

10:14Speaker 27

Thank you. Lincoln Ware. Is Lincoln Ware here?

10:24 – 10:36Speaker 8

Mr. Ware was called to his veterans meeting, and he came to speak about Betty Oldham Way. She was his second grade teacher, and so he said to please let you know that he apologizes.

10:37Speaker 27

No problem. Thank you. Our next speaker is Howard Vaughn. Welcome.

10:55 – 12:23Speaker 12

Good afternoon, all of you dignitarians. All of y'all know me. I used to work down here for 16 years. And if it wasn't for me working down here, I wouldn't be in the position I'm in right now. And the only one that tried to help me was Aptat. And I can't believe it. All of y'all know me. You know, he was the only one that stood up for me. Okay. The VA owed me money. Social Security owed me money. Over the Ram owed me money. I've been dealing with this in the military ever since I got out of Vietnam, you know, with the war and everything. And they telling me I didn't work down here, and y'all know I work down here, because y'all try to help me. But what I'm telling you is, what's coming, put your arms around me and everything, and I appreciate that. You came down, talked to me here. You seen where your pants was at over your knees. Next time, it's going to be over your head. I'm telling you, y'all don't realize at any time, this is, I want all y'all to see, this is where I was at, on the bridge. And how could I survive from that? Lord, tell me how can I survive from that? But please, please, y'all will see what's getting ready to happen. Y'all see, y'all listen, y'all love, y'all belong, y'all belong. Only one percent. Forgive them. Forgive them, God. Give them Jesus for what they're doing. They don't know what they're doing. Forgive them. Oh, Lord God, let your knees lay down.

12:24Speaker 1

Oh, Lord, let your knees lay down. I want to go right now.

12:28 – 12:53Speaker 12

Please, Jesus, I need you right now. I know they're going to kill you. My car, they're vandalizing everything. They're opening up the front doors. Thank you, sir. Sir, the young woman at the door could potentially support you.

13:06Speaker 27

Could you wave your hand, miss? Do you see her, Mr. Vaughn?

13:13Speaker 28

If you could chat with her.

13:15Speaker 27

I have to get to the next speaker, but I appreciate you coming in, Mr. Vaughn. Thank you. Stefan Pryor, please welcome.

13:41 – 15:44Speaker 33

Good afternoon council, good afternoon everyone in here. I'm looking at your agenda, agenda one, item one. His name is Reggie Harris, y'all got him here as Reginald Harris, as a planning commission. He's been here before, he left once, he don't need to come back, no shape or form. Him and his husband own a development company, I knew that years ago before he got elected, so that's a bad move, Mr. Mary Abtab, letting him be the planning commission. I wouldn't even do that. I'm glad I just think that on this agenda right here. He was here already. He shouldn't have left. His ass would have still been here, but he left early because something happened inside this building. I know about it, but I ain't going to talk about it, but Don't bring him back. Hail to the nah, hail to the nah. Then he's trying to be for CDC so he can endorse candidates that don't go together. But I'm not just here for that. I'm here for Mr. Eugene Brown. He came here last week. He's right behind me. He came here last week to speak about his property. In the blue boundary, he have a property at 1734. His property is in the Blue Boundaries right here, and it's a gate that they came and put in half of his property. I got a paper here for y'all if y'all like to see this. He's coming down here asking for help to find out why do they do that. If I own property in the Blue Boundary, how's another project manager or project company coming along and actually putting a gate in his property boundary. That's not cool, not at all. And I hope you're feeling good, Mr. Johnson, over there. You have been having your head down lately when I've come up. I don't know why. I thought me and you was cool, my brother. Your head always down when I'm speaking. I don't know why. I love you, brother. Nothing you can do about it, but you... I thought we was cool, man. I was advocating for you when you got elected. All of a sudden, your head is down. Thank you, Mr. Pryor.

15:44Speaker 27

Thank you, sir. Mr. Jonathan Norman, welcome.

16:07 – 18:07Speaker 40

The attention and outrage we have seen around Flock camera systems is not only just, it is just the beginning. Flock has taken the brunt of this because it is the most prominent and easily identifiable intrusive surveillance system being propped up in our communities. But they are just one of several brands, some of which, like Axon, used in this city, aims to be worse. These are surveillance systems that can be added to existing street poles, cameras added to cop cars, cameras being attached to school buses. What we're told are just license plate scans is not true. The fusus network Axon builds can bring in security cam footage, can access ring doorbells, uses footage from the drones being deployed. This network that officials and ICE have searched merely with descriptions of people. This is an issue because it's not just about trusting police to be responsible, It's also about trusting the devices themselves and the AI that governs them to be responsibly and accurately deliver the information they leech in an unbiased manner. The truth is you can't trust them to do that. As I have said over and over in here, Axon and our drones made by Skydio is all tech that has been built, used, and tested in an ongoing genocide and apartheid. We already know general AI can be more prone to misidentify and has a negative bias against minorities, especially black individuals. How should we expect AI recognizing faces of thousands of innocent people in Gaza being slaughtered to behave any better? I'm glad this council is looking into its use at a city level, but we are still underestimating what this is and who the true bad guys are. Right now, Border Patrol is running secret predictive policing teams. And they are using these cameras as part of the wide net they are throwing across all of us as they target the most vulnerable of us. AI that is breaking the boundaries that its makers put in place. We can say we want to limit sharing of data, but ICE and this administration aren't the sharing type. They are the skirting the law and the taking type. You can look to Nashville that ended this exact type of contract we're dealing with. They noted that regardless of the guardrails they put in place, they could not guarantee limiting ICE's access to this network. You have a chance to be proactive here before this becomes a crisis and a tragedy in this city. The only way forward is canceling these contracts and removing these instruments of harm.

18:08Speaker 27

Stanford Poole, welcome.

18:19 – 20:20Speaker 37

You know what, if they had a grading system for you guys, you would get an F. You got the ability to do something, but you're not. You are doing stuff for the rich guys or the poor authority or the rich guys that you had 37 people meeting for two years and gave them $2 million to come up with scheme to fill their pocket and put a dirty, muddy boots on the poor people. Make taxes for us that we working. and you continue to steal property from black neighborhoods. Do you understand all the black neighborhoods were redlined for 60 years? But every six months you took taxes out of it and then put a dime in, then take a weed out of that neighborhood, and you took it to High Park, Mount Adam, and downtown. And now you're still stealing. We got brown people on this council and letting it happen. The mayor should be a leader. People voted for him, thought he was going to be a leader, but he's not. Whoever pulled on the screen behind that wall is the leader. You guys don't own anything. You're tenants. That's what you are. Trump is a tenant, and you are a tenant. You're supposed to be here to help the people, but the only thing you're doing is filling up the port-a-sorty now. If a person with a house that stayed here and paid the taxes, you don't want to help them. But you give $4 million to DC3C, you give $4 million on the river, and you do $2 million for the rich people that started 2525, just like Trump got. You guys are no different than Trump. You're hiding behind a thing to say you're a Democrat. You let a Palestinian lady get spit on out there on your property. Mary, you didn't do nothing. You got a wife. Scotty, you got family.

20:22Speaker 27

Our next speaker is Todd Zinsser. Welcome.

20:33 – 21:37Speaker 22

Good afternoon. My name is Todd Zinsser from West Price Hill, and I wanted to follow up on the Westline Flats issue. Yesterday, Mr. Tidd failed to tell the committee that I get the opportunity to respond to his motion to dismiss my lawsuit and, if appropriate, go to the Court of Appeals. That's called due process. Second, if you read paragraph 48 on page 9 of my complaint, it basically says that if I prevail, the planning commission action on the plan development is invalidated. And if the city council goes forward, you could potentially be ratifying an illegal action which could have its own consequences. In fact, if the council went into executive session to discuss pending litigation, that would actually be a legitimate purpose of an executive session. Finally, Ms. Albee, just so you know, My mother's family was poor and came to Cincinnati as far down in Kentucky as you can come from.

21:38Speaker 19

My father's family were poor German immigrant pig farmers from Indiana.

21:44 – 22:35Speaker 22

After she came to Cincinnati, my grandmother, who was a single mother, worked as a domestic, scrubbing the floors of rich people who lived along Harrison Avenue in Westwood. I vividly remember One of my father's uncles lived in a disgusting, impoverished German tenement in Over the Rhine when I was a very young boy. I am proud of my heritage. Ms. Albee, please don't try to tell me about poor people. So you are on notice. The next time you try to put words in my mouth and imply or suggest that I am some kind of bigot against poor people, I'm going to sue you for defamation. and your continued attempts to assassinate Mike. Thank you very much.

22:36Speaker 27

All right, Eugene Brown, welcome.

22:43Speaker 29

Yes, I'm Mr. Eugene Brown.

22:46Speaker 22

This is my third time.

22:47 – 24:23Speaker 29

This is my third time here. And basically I've brung down some paperwork to show you where the boundaries of my property is and where the fence It's going across my property at 1734 Republic Street. This is the fence that's going across. Here's the blue line that shows the boundary of my property. And they put a fence up. Nobody can tell me who fence it is or where it come from or anything. This my third time down here and basically could I get some kind of information on who fence it is or what it may be I'd be satisfied, you know what to do next You know, but anybody would like any question of the paper or anything So Yes, this is my third time down here. I haven't got no information whatsoever about it. They're saying somebody tried to get in touch with me, but I put down my number. They didn't try to get in touch with me, period, if you ask me. And they want me to call them, so basically they need to call me. Anybody tell me anything? Would anybody like any of these papers to see exactly where 37, I mean 1734 Republic is?

24:23 – 24:38Speaker 27

Mr. Brown, I'm sorry. Go ahead. Would you like to add anything else? So I just talked to my colleague about this. Apparently several different folks have tried to reach out to you over the last couple of weeks and you haven't answered your phone. Would it be possible for you to call them?

24:39Speaker 29

I don't think they tried to call me whatsoever. Regardless. I didn't try to call them. I mean, I haven't tried to call them, but I don't think they tried to call me. Fair enough. That's why I'm down here now.

24:48Speaker 27

I'm not in any ways.

24:49Speaker 29

I've asked them to call me.

24:51 – 25:24Speaker 27

Okay. Mr. Brown, I'm not in any way suggesting that that's not true, but I think it would be helpful if you could just call them. Would that be okay? It'd be helpful if they called me. What I'm trying to articulate is that they've tried to call you, according to them, not suggesting that you're lying. But to cut through it, can you just call them? Would that be easier? To me, I think they're lying. So, either or. Noah, in the back, can give you the number for you to call if you'd like to call them, or if you'd like to pick up the phone, we would like to help.

25:25Speaker 27

Okay, thank you. Jerry Coach, or Gerald Coach, potentially? Welcome.

25:40 – 27:40Speaker 11

Got a video here for us, Counsel. It's a video of officers Lisa Johnson and Denise Burns locking me in a police car and turning the heat on. This vehicle is not going to start, but they will assert that the ventilation is pumping. I ain't been coming down here begging y'all this because I'm a cop hater. This is the middle of July. I went to the CCA. They put my home address on a public record that my home address has nothing to do with. John Kennedy is a man. He ain't got nobody overseeing him. I went in here, y'all. We fought for about 50 minutes, maybe. John Kennedy was defending himself because I took him all the evidence that I got out of the public record search. The case been closed for over eight months and he just now presented it last month because I pressed him to do it. With this all being said, I knew he was having it. This here evidence right here though. I'm in the background pressing on my belt. Come on man, you'll hear me if you listen. Sam Burbanks ordered a motion to remit. He wanted them to take the case over with, but then on city cable, that part disappeared. They had a unanimous vote on the motion to remit. This evidence here is clear. No engine turns over. That's why, you know, think about the Owensby, Roger Owensby and stuff.

27:42Speaker 27

Our next speaker is Jamie Bryant. Welcome.

27:54 – 29:55Speaker 13

Good afternoon, members of Cincinnati City Council. My name is Jamie Bryant, and I stand before you today as an eyewitness and personal advocate for Gary Coach. Last July, Mr. Coach was subjected to an egregious police misconduct when officers locked him inside an unventilated police car, handcuffed, and in the sweltering middle of July heat. That is not standard procedure. That is excessive force under the Fourth Amendment, a violation of his civil rights and a life-threatening act of deliberate indifference. Right is right and wrong is wrong. The officer's misconduct was wrong, yet they were found exonerated. When we brought this before the Citizens Complaint Authority, the system broke down further. At the September 9th meeting, CCA Board Chair Samuel Burbanks introduced a motion to remit CCA case 25134 which passed unanimously. Multiple witnesses, including myself, Mr. Coach, Adoria Bryant, and a League of Women Voters rep watched this vote occur live in council chambers. Yet when we were called out on omission, excuse me, yet when we called out this omission via email, John Kennedy emailed me back claiming no footage was altered, CCA cannot alter the city cable, and the case is closed. That is unacceptable and factually inaccurate. The city cable broadcast posted online completely omitted that motion and unanimous vote. Passing the buck between city departments does not excuse wiping official proceedings from the public record. Tempering with public records violates ORC 121.22, 149.351, 29.13.42 in the city's records policy. Section 5.00 of the CPD manual alongside Brady and Giglio demand strict honesty and preservation of evidence from investigators.

29:56Speaker 27

Thank you. Bishop Sonny James, welcome.

30:16 – 32:18Speaker 31

Good afternoon, Bishop Sonny James. I came by today to encourage all of you on October the 17th, my 14 year old daughter, Sonny Renee, who some of you may be aware of through the CCP program. She started college in the eighth grade, her first semester in college, not online, but actually at the university, she received a 4.0 GPA. She's announced that she wants to be the first Congresswoman at age 25. She wants to run for mayor of Norwood at 18. But she asked me a question recently. She said, Daddy, she said, we see all that you're trying to do in this community, but Daddy, as a preacher, Why am I not seeing your peers out on the block with you going to rescue the most vulnerable of my peers? And she challenged me and she said, I expect more out of you, Daddy. And she said on October 17th, it won't be your come together event. It's going to be mine and the youth. And I've made a commitment. to not just stand behind the pulpit, but to actually get into the lives. I thought I was doing the work. I thought I'd been doing pretty good. But my 14-year-old daughter is now saying, we've got to come together, and we've got to bring together the most vulnerable of our youth. Their lives might not be perfect, and yes, they might be making some mistakes, but I'm encouraging all of you on October the 17th to please prioritize that. It's going to be free food, and at the end we're going to have a free concert, a tribute to Motown.

32:19Speaker 27

Thank you. Noah Diagaraga? Please be patient. Welcome, Noah.

32:35Speaker 27

Could we tilt the mic down? There we go.

32:37 – 32:54Speaker 1

My bad. Good afternoon, Mayor, people, and council members. My name is Noah. I'm here with BDSOP's Sonny James to ask all of you to please help with the young and youth adults struggling with crime and gun violence in our city to young adults. I need help in so many of the youth, so come support us on October 17th in Norway. Thank you.

32:55Speaker 27

Thank you. Great job. Jason Winbush, welcome.

33:16Speaker 1

Good afternoon, everybody.

33:17 – 34:37Speaker 36

My name is Jason Wimbush with the Young CEO Program, also a board member for the Mount Airy Town Council. I think about May we had your sanitation department come and we talked about the delay and yard waste that was being picked up maybe two weeks to 30 days later than normal. As we see that there is I guess a continued issue with staffing roughly four or five, six months later. And so I come with possible solution. I was on vacation in Florida, Palm Bay to be exact, and they have a sanitation where they have one person and they have a robotic arm that actually comes out and picks up the trash cans and dump it on its own so nobody has to get out of the vehicle and pick up trash, go to the curb, things of nature. So I'm just here today to offer a possible solution for our staffing shortages and maybe look into getting some different type of vehicles that can help this situation in the future. So it might be a heavy investment up front, but it might be best in the long run. So I'm just here to offer a possible solution if you guys would like to look into that. Thank you.

34:38Speaker 27

Have a great day. Thank you. Connie Brightbiel, welcome.

34:51 – 36:53Speaker 39

I am speaking in opposition to the subsidized housing in Westwood. I live in Westwood, and this housing development, 167 units, is supposed to be on a small street called Glen Hills Way. It's not on Ferguson, as it's announced. All there is is a road driveway to Ferguson. It's on Glen Hills Way. And this is what is on this small street, Glen Hills Way. There's Walgreens. There's the Ford dealership. There's St. Vincent de Paul. There's La Rosa's Call Center. And then there is another building on the east, that street. And it's several people of business, but one of them is a liquor store. So that's the small street. And across the street, immediately across the street, is Walmart and Kroger's. In front of Kroger's is a police department. All that is in one small area. It's just too small for that many housing development. I asked for a plan of the housing development. I got a reply as to how many units there were and how many parking spaces. But there was nothing said about where children play. Where are children supposed to play? In the street? So let's go on to the traffic. I called the traffic division. I asked them if there was a study being done. And yes, just on Glen Hills Way, but not on Boudinot. Boudinot is a block away. Boudinot is the corridor from Price Hill to the north, which ends in Westwood Northern Boulevard that goes to Green Township on one side and Clifton on the other. The traffic is horrendous there. I live near Work Road and Westbrook, and there is accident after accident after accident. And you want to put more traffic on there. And also on that street is a school, a Montessori school. If you ever go there in the morning, or you go there when they're closing, when they're...

36:54Speaker 27

Thank you very much. Kent Evans, welcome.

37:09 – 38:06Speaker 32

Thank you for being allowed to speak. Governance of this city should factor in the rules at the federal level, having been completely turned upside down. Bull rush acts daring Congress to match the exuberant illegal acts were not met with an equal challenge. I'm not even looking to blame anyone. It's unprecedented. We all know this, OK? And yet we have the power to do things at this level. And so I'm going to continue. The malevolent federal administration then plays that the normal process is made right by offering tip line phone numbers. That just recently happened. Can you imagine that? The same behavior is being patterned at the state level. Whoever asked for data centers? Did anyone know about data centers coming through? Anyone?

38:08Speaker 15

I don't think anyone back here did.

38:10 – 39:10Speaker 32

I know I didn't. I urge each of you with our city's administration to utilize the same energy and fix issues that need attention when everything was working normally. Let's start with the regressive flat municipal income tax. I know it's ruled by the state, but look at what the state is doing. They don't consider the citizenry. Also, have a discussion on tax abatement returns. The length of time is excessive. That's something you guys definitely participate in. Finally, start vetting the Futures Committee recommendations. I just read this morning's paper that we have one of the four billionaires supposedly THAT'S OPERATING IN A FAMILY ENTERPRISE. THEY OWN A FOOTBALL COMPANY THAT GETS MASSIVE AMOUNTS OF PUBLIC MONEY.

39:10Speaker 27

NEW SPEAKER THANK YOU. MOVING TO ZOOM, MIKE, WELCOME.

39:14Speaker 19

NEW SPEAKER YES, HELLO. THANK YOU FOR ALLOWING ME TO SPEAK TODAY. CAN YOU HEAR ME?

39:21Speaker 27

NEW SPEAKER YES, GO AHEAD.

39:24 – 41:16Speaker 19

NEW SPEAKER SO I WAS COMING BACK HERE AGAIN TO Follow up on what's being done about the fraud that Greater Cincinnati Water Works commits against people when they charge a monthly base rate when they have the water turned off at the meter, claiming that it is only for them being ready to provide something and for people having access to it, not actually using it or having access because Greater Cincinnati Water Works has it turned off at the meter. I've been coming here dozens and dozens of times. I heard somebody earlier say that this is only their third time. And yet you are following up with him. Nobody's followed up with me. Not once. I've called dozens and dozens of times to all of your offices, but nobody has ever followed up with me about this issue. Now, of course, I pointed out that this is a violation of Ohio Revised Code 2913 fraud statute because the city is receiving money for providing nothing of value. I've also pointed out that this is not ethical. I don't think anybody here would agree that it's ethical for a company to charge people a monthly base rate just because they're ready to provide something and for people having access to it. Because if it was and it is legal, imagine if every company sent you a bill just for being ready to provide something and people having access to it's just not right but nobody's doing anything about it nobody's contacting me about it nothing is being done i've been coming here for over a year and a half by zoom and i don't see any results yet i would love to know what is being done i've even contacted the fraud waste and abuse hotline they don't return my calls either so

41:20 – 43:39Speaker 3

you sir our next speaker is also on zoom amber cassam welcome thanks can you hear me yes go ahead thank you appreciate that um yesterday i listened to the city council talk about westline development and what i heard was fundamentally dishonest and ignores housing equity The $38,000 a cop and teacher jobs are wrong, and they're lying. And now you guys are lying. CPD recruits during the academy make closer to $60,000 to $77,000, and teachers make $55,000 to $60,000 in CPS starting out. If you guys require your argument to have bad numbers, that says something about your integrity when you claim to care about working class people who can't compete with vouchers. You guys are liars. Evan, poverty doesn't disappear because your map was zoomed in on parking lots. Tract 109 and Block 1004 is around $29,000. Your neighborhood has a median income of almost $80,000. That's why poverty doesn't resonate with you at all, you cornball. Nika, your neighborhood includes a track that has $55,000 up to another track of $82,000 with a census block of around $100,000. Housing equity cannot mean putting the lowest income households wherever the land is cheapest and the farthest away from you and the east side. That's not equity. Anna, your neighborhood is essentially fully gentrified. You've supported adding residents while increasing property values. So let's be honest about how you view development in this city. Jeff, you're the only one making sense. Will you enforce 25% voucher maximum? Will you require a CPD officer? Will you require 75 percent of the people to be employed and not take vouchers? Because otherwise, west side just or absorbs another concentration of vouchers and the east side continues to gentrify. LBG is building a no income development, not a 60 percent AMI development.

43:46Speaker 27

Thank you, Amber. Our next speaker is in person, Antoinette Wells. Welcome.

44:04 – 46:05Speaker 2

Hi. Okay. Good afternoon. I was coming in on behalf of my son that's incarcerated here in Hamilton County Justice Center unjustly. He's been in there 10 months. for drug abuse and just a minor resistant arrest with a $262,000 bond with a 24 hour 7 EMU. He was taken to UC Hospital during the time of the arrest, ventilated, clothes cut off. UC does not have a record, neither does the Justice Center. But I got transcripts from 801 Broadway, I mean 801 Lens stating that that was his secondary transport. location. We're thinking that they admitted him and adjusted in the hospital, but the police officers took him anyway. We don't have the record, but I do have that. He was taken there. Justice center said it's illegal for them to have him without a discharge paper. Secondly, he has had three different attorneys on this case. The attorneys overheard some information on a phone call about, I can, well, Something that happened, the person is dead now, so the information is null and void. They held my son in jail trying to make him give information up. He's like, the guy's dead, he's dead, so it's nothing to discuss. Attorney's been lying, getting continuances for the state, but he lied and said that the state been asked, and we busted him, pulled up the records. He withdrew from the case yesterday after he got busted and we confronted him on Thursday. He withdrew yesterday. We gotta go through this all over again. And this is Judge Katie Cash that's giving these outrageous bonds for these minor cases to people. It's insane and something needs to be looked at. And they're also at the Justice Center denying my son his materials to go to court pro se because we were.

46:06Speaker 27

Thank you, thank you. Mark, last name starts with a K. I apologize. It looks like K-U-T-Y Lowski.

46:16Speaker 27

Welcome, Mark.

46:24 – 48:01Speaker 7

First off, I just want to say thank you to everyone. I'm sure you guys get enough people coming with issues. So I wanted to talk about recycling in Cincinnati. I JUST WANT TO SAY YOU GUYS ARE DOING A WONDERFUL JOB. I KNOW THAT I'VE HEARD AT LEAST 300 RECYCLING BINS HAVE BEEN ADDED THROUGHOUT THE CINCINNATI. I LIVE IN LOVELAND AND I'VE TOLD THEM ABOUT THE HAMILTON COUNTY GRANT THERE AND THEY ADDED RECYCLING BINS UP THERE. I'VE GONE TO 36 OF THE 48 HAMILTON COUNTY COMMUNITIES TO ADVOCATE FOR ADDING RECYCLING BINS IN THEIR DOWNTOWN AREA. I WANT TO SAY THANK YOU FOR WHAT YOU GUYS HAVE DONE TO PUSH FOR RECYCLING BINS IN CINCINNATI. I KNOW THERE'S ABOUT 50 NEIGHBORHOODS IN CINCINNATI. I'D JUST LIKE TO ENCOURAGE TO KEEP GOING THERE AS WELL, TOO, WHETHER I KNOW I'VE SEEN THEM IN OAKLEY. I THINK I SAW THEM IN WESTWOOD THE OTHER DAY. Tide Park, downtown, obviously. I just want to encourage you guys to keep going with that. I've helped to recycle about 1.5 million items over the past four years through cleanups. Semi partnered with a nonprofit called the Onion Bag Litter Prevention Project that's helped to clean up more than 4 million items across the state actually, including here in Cincinnati as well too. And if anyone wants to follow up or have any questions, feel free to reach out. But again, I know you guys have enough people probably coming with things. Just wanted to say thank you guys and hope you guys all have a wonderful day.

48:02Speaker 27

Thank you. Gary Hodges, welcome.

48:10Speaker 21

Gary Hodge is the second, and I'm confusing you with my dad. Now, as many years as I've known Mark Blackman, Scotty, why have I not met you?

48:18Speaker 27

Sir, if you could speak into the mic.

48:20 – 50:14Speaker 21

As many years as I've known Mark Blackman, why have I not met you, Scotty? Especially when I'm connected to here. You know, I've got 35 years of my life out here on these streets. I've known Mark Blackman for 20 of them. He's basically married to your niece or related by marriage, okay? After my bus run, which moved every man in black, from Florida to Ohio, I'm out here bouncing my head off the walls, wondering why I can't get any help. with this national problem where the rapists and chumos are supposed to be put on these buses and brought to justice. To come to find out that you exposed my family, the SWAT team here, playing games, all right? So now we've got little girls being raped by adults, okay? And we got Ronisha Stinson sitting in the Justice Center for over four years now because she went through the due process, okay? Due gets two years. Cone's out looking for seconds. Well, Joe Dieter's got on national TV, I'm not stopping, saying that I'll never tell you you couldn't kill to protect. I'll never say that. So she kills a dude. Now she's got to fight a murder charge. Why? I can't get the help I need. They used a foster care system when I was 13 years old to move me from Hamilton County to Claremont County to drop me in enemy territory, right there where my dad, being an Iron Horseman, would be his enemy. You know, I've got all these issues sitting here. And the only way I can get any help is out here on the streets. And then when we commit the murders, like Christian Montgomery had to go over there to commit a double homicide, which was needed for the cause. Then we got to go in prison for the rest of our lives. You know, when are you going to do your due diligence? Because you're my dad's age. It's your mess regardless. To clean it up. Especially with your title sitting here. Get up off your ass and earn your keep, bro. 100. 100. And you will answer to all the women out there to be victimized because of you, because of what I'm doing here, and putting the guys on... Okay, thank you. Thank you very much.

50:14 – 50:32Speaker 27

Sir, there's a woman at the door. Sir? Sir? Hey, sir? Sir? Miss, if you could help him. Thank you. Okay, Paula Gasper, welcome.

50:46 – 52:49Speaker 38

It's Glasper. I have been here 60 years and suffer from a mental illness. Here lately, it's like the whole Cincinnati area knows that I have a mental illness and what I suffer from. I'm having problems with my adult daughter disrespectful. I don't know if he put something on the internet or what. Speaking to doctors and what have you, if they feel like you are a threat to the community, out to do something to someone, I guess they could put a bulletin out about it. I don't know. Like I said, 60 years and all of a sudden, I'm homeless. I'm walking the streets talking to myself looking totally ridiculous. I'm being harassed by police making comments. I'm being harassed by firemen when I'm trying to commit suicide. They can speak of things that I haven't told anybody. You know, HIPAA, I guess it's not alive. I have no privacy. No one to help me with housing, affordable housing. All I get is no, no, no. And just need some respect. And HIPAA should be alive. Because if it would have been alive, I wouldn't have got my check. It was a lawsuit. It took about two years. But I'm going to make this short and simple. I'm crazy, not stupid. So to the doctor, he know what he did when I was in there. Like, hey, I can go on. And he knew my condition. And I blathered it out.

52:49 – 53:10Speaker 27

Thank you, Miss. Thank you very much. We have one more speaker who's on Zoom. Derek Blazingame, welcome, sir. Derek Blazingame, welcome, sir.

53:17 – 54:44Speaker 30

I can tell you I'm not no heterosexual. I never had no girlfriend. I never had no relationship with no woman. So don't try to put me in that category. You don't put me in many categories. I want to clarify something to the people of the city of Cincinnati. For the record, I do not hate the city of Atlanta. The city of Atlanta is where I got my college education. The city of Atlanta is where I got my college degree. The city of Atlanta is where I went from 501 pounds to 214 pounds. The city of Atlanta is where I found a path that would work for me. The city of Atlanta is where I found love and people who treated me like a human being. So I do not hate the city of Atlanta. So stop trying to project those things in my mind and my thoughts. Now, For everybody on this council, you all want to spend $6 million on hiring police officers. Why don't you explore alternatives to hiring more police officers? Police officers are good for society, but $6 million more of taxpayers' money when we already put 60-plus percent investment in our public safety? Find alternatives. Find other avenues to reduce crime and to eliminate violence and to encourage people to find alternative dispute resolutions than to killing and hurting each other. The other thing, finally, I want to encourage the Good Samaritans of Cincinnati, get your trucks. Hire some youth, go clean up the shit and the garbage that's all around the city of Cincinnati because the city failed to get your garbage, collect your garbage. Derek Blassingame, the biggest and baddest to ever do it. Fuck Scotty Johnson, I holla.

54:47 – 55:05Speaker 27

All right. I WOULD REMIND EVERYONE TO PLEASE BE RESPECTFUL DURING PUBLIC COMMENT, TO REFRAIN FROM PROFANITY, BUT THAT IS THE END OF TODAY'S PUBLIC COMMENT. IT IS NOW 2.23, AND WE WILL BEGIN TODAY'S BUSINESS PORTION OF CINCINNATI CITY COUNCIL, AND THE CLERK WILL PLEASE CALL THE ROLL.

55:06Speaker 15

COUNCIL MEMBER ALBIE. HERE. COUNCIL MEMBER CRAMERDING. HERE. COUNCIL MEMBER JAMES.

55:12Speaker 15

COUNCIL MEMBER JEFFRIES.

55:14Speaker 15

COUNCIL MEMBER JOHNSON.

55:16Speaker 15

Vice Mayor Kearney.

55:17Speaker 15

Council Member Nolan. Here. Council Member Owens.

55:20Speaker 15

Council Member Walsh.

55:22 – 56:32Speaker 27

Here. Please stand for a moment of silence. And now the Pledge of Allegiance. I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the Republic for which it stands, one nation under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all. The minutes from the previous meeting will be approved and filed without objection. Hearing none, they'll be approved and filed. Moving to our agenda, we're going to start with item number 11, and we will now recognize Councilmember Jeffries for a resolution from Vice Mayor Kearney, Councilmember Jeffries, Councilmember Albee, Kramerding, James, Owens, recognizing Keep Cincinnati Beautiful's Don't Dump the Natty program and expressing the support of the Mayor and Council for Keep Cincinnati Beautiful's work to combat illegal dumping, promote environmental stewardship, and provide emergency cleanup support following catastrophic flash flooding in Cincinnati. Mr. Jeffries.

56:33 – 58:55Speaker 23

Thank you, Mr. Mayor. Well, I'm joined by folks from Keep Cincinnati Beautiful. We all know KCB. They've been around since 1978, so their work is not new to folks. But given recent events, we thought it would be important to highlight some of their recent work. especially around Dump the Natty. So, as many people know, we have a pretty significant, have had a pretty significant problem with illegal dumping throughout parts of the city. The Don't Dump the Natty program has reduced it by, I think, over 35%, which is substantial, because it also is, illegal dumping costs the city two, three million dollars a year, plus it's obviously blight on the neighborhood. But this past year, they held nine Don't Dump the Natty events, and I want to read off some of the stats from that as well as from the flood relief as well. So the nine events removed, I'm not going to read all the exact numbers, but over a million pounds of litter and debris, over 74,000 pounds of tires, diverting 247,000 pounds of recyclable material, and 1,350 participating vehicles being served. Also, I would say, given the flash flood events that encompassed a lot of neighborhoods in our city, it was very unexpected. On July 31st, they scaled their capacity and allowed a lot more debris to be collected. They engaged 270 local participants, diverting and removing 147,000 pounds of landfill waste, just this one event. 14,000 pounds of landfill debris, 4,250 pounds of scrap metal, 270 pounds of e-waste and 2000 pounds of cargo recycling and 300 tires. So that's a lot. The point being, a lot of work, a lot of diversion that otherwise would often go into our neighborhoods. because people don't want to drive over to Coleraine. And so thank you for that contribution. And this resolution just acknowledges the work that you've done. And thank you for continuing to serve the people of Cincinnati. So with that, I'll turn it over to the mayor and my colleagues for additional comments. Jonathan, do you want to make a comment first?

58:58 – 1:00:20Speaker 28

Naturally. This is true. I just wanted to highlight the people who really have done the work. And also just to mention that this was one of those necessity being the mother of invention. We've always tried to catch bad guys doing illegal dumping. And it's kind of playing whack-a-mole. And during the portion of our strategy, we thought, why don't we incentivize people who want to act lawfully? We had surveyed some of the people that had been caught doing illegal dumping. And they were like, we want to act lawfully, but it's just totally inconvenient. So what else are we going to do? So Alistair and his team created Don't Dump the Natty. And how we started was we went out to all the illegal dump sites and put up signs saying you don't have to do this. Come to this centralized location and it has grown and it is something that I think that the city can be proud of. Diverting up to a million and a half pounds of otherwise dumped material and being a true waste diversion event into e-waste and scrap metal and furniture and tires and all those things is something that we can be really proud of. So I want to congratulate Alistair and Jada for doing this and also to congratulate our board, Courtney Reitman-Deinlein as our board chair, just for allowing us to be entrepreneurial and setting those boundaries, but relying on KCB to be true problem solvers. And we love doing that for the city.

1:00:22Speaker 27

Thank you, Jonathan. Thank you. Comments from Council? Vice Mayor?

1:00:27 – 1:01:09Speaker 8

Councilmember Jeffries, thank you so much for bringing Jonathan Ady here and the Keep Cincinnati Beautiful team. You know, as Councilmember Jeffery said, Keep Cincinnati Beautiful does a lot of work that the city would have to do. So you help us a lot with litter over a million pounds. That's a lot of litter in one year. I mean, that's amazing. But I wanted you to please say again about the end of the month is the last Friday of the month. Where do we come? What time? Because I think that's really important. I know for tires, there's a limit of 10 tires, but that's still a lot. And so it's just good for us to know about that. Tell us one more time.

1:01:10 – 1:01:50Speaker 28

Thank you for reminding me of that. So the next Don't Dump the Natty event is next Friday, which is September the 25th. Last Friday of the month, 9 to noon, at 841 West 6th Street, the old Hutipol place, and there will be many Packer trucks there. We'll have folks there to accept your e-waste, your concrete, landscape debris, plenty of tires. The litter study from Keep America Beautiful just came out. And there's an increase in over 40% in the amount of littered and illegally dumped tires over the last five years. So that's another important element of this. But it's next Friday, 9 to noon.

1:01:51Speaker 8

And that includes furniture, mattresses, all of that, right? Yes, okay.

1:01:58Speaker 25

Yeah, I also want to thank you, Council. Thank you for all the support for this program.

1:02:04Speaker 26

It's just grown year after year. This is our fourth year doing it.

1:02:08 – 1:02:50Speaker 25

So we really appreciate Everybody coming out, I know some folks have come out and just seen the production that it takes to hold these events. But this month we're starting a partnership with Hamilton County Resource and Office of Environment and Sustainability through the City of Cincinnati to start taking hazardous waste, household hazardous waste. So we're really excited to start taking that waste for our residents. Stay tuned for that. Check our website for all information. You do have to preregister for that. And so the event is 9 to 1, and we will be going through November.

1:02:50Speaker 28

I say that because I leave at noon.

1:02:55 – 1:03:17Speaker 8

And may I just, just to close up, because I don't want to steal Councilmember Scotty Johnson's thunder. I see he's out of his seat, but I know he's the one who advocated. for the jobs, for funding for the jobs van that you're doing with the City Gospel Mission where you drive around and you get folks who need employment. And so thank you for that as well.

1:03:19Speaker 27

Thank you. Any comments on this side? Mr. Nolan? Oh, I'm sorry.

1:03:23Speaker 8

I didn't see. Okay. Council Member Johnson was sitting back from his seat. I didn't see him. I'm sorry. I thought you had gone. I'm sorry about that.

1:03:29 – 1:03:42Speaker 34

Mr. Johnson, did you want to make a comment? I just want to thank them, Mayor. Thanks for the amazing work you continue to do. I'm sorry, I couldn't see. A clean city is a good city, and you're making sure that we do that.

1:03:43Speaker 27

So keep up the amazing work, and thank you very much for what you do. Thank you, President Johnson. Okay, we'll go Mr. Nolan, then Ms. Albee, then Ms. Helens.

1:03:51 – 1:04:14Speaker 26

Thank you, Mayor. Thank you, Councilmember Jeffries, for bringing this forward. I also want to offer my congratulations on the recognition of this program. This is one of the many things that you do to help us out here in Cincinnati. Jonathan, you're a regular here in City Hall, so it's always good to see you. And also want to just call out the block party that's happening on Friday to celebrate the new location as a part of the growing work that you're doing. So congratulations.

1:04:17 – 1:04:47Speaker 41

Thank you for the resolution. Team, this is great work. You know, we in Cincinnati all love our city, and we want to see a clean, healthy Cincinnati, and this work's just so critical, so thank you for it. You know, I wish more individuals took it upon themselves to do this proactively, and we didn't have to do so much cleanup, but I am grateful for all your volunteers. I mean, there are hundreds, maybe thousands of people who aren't in the room right now who equally deserve recognition and thanks, so please pass that along from us. to them, so thank you for all that work.

1:04:49 – 1:05:28Speaker 4

So thank you, thank you, thank you. You are doing work that we couldn't do without you, and so we appreciate that. And what I also want to recognize is that you do this work because you care. And so we thank you for bringing yourself into this. I've been to your operation, and it is a well-run, well-oiled machine, even on these hot, hot days. And Jonathan, you bring pizza and make everybody happy, including myself. So thank you. And I also want to thank our DPS workers who are on site as well, helping to add to the efficiency of this operation. Thank you for the collaboration and partnership.

1:05:28Speaker 27

Thank you. Any final comments?

1:05:29 – 1:06:34Speaker 16

Mr. James. Hello, KCB. Thank you so much for coming in today. I'm excited to be a part of a city council that in the last year has been taking our relationship so seriously and hopefully deepening this marriage here, realizing that keeping Cincinnati beautiful is not just your organization name, but a responsibility that we share together and excited to walk arm in arm with you in this work. I will say that coming from the nonprofit sector, a lot of organizations of your influence, of your size, of your recognition in the community, are not fighters like you all, I've realized over the last few months. Alistair, I feel like we're bros now. I've seen you at so many community impact bros at events and I see you constantly, so I feel like we have a kinship there. Jonathan, it's been fantastic to deepen a relationship with you here in the last few weeks. Not many executive directors are on the ground fighting tooth or nail for the survival and success of their organization like you are. You are not behind a monitor in an office somewhere. You are with the people. So it's exciting to work with you and I'm so excited to deepen our relationship. So KCB, you do wonderful work and I'm excited to walk this walk with you. Thank you.

1:06:34Speaker 27

Thank you. I'll add my congratulations as well. Well earned and thank you so much for all your hard work. Roll call on passage of the resolution please.

1:06:43Speaker 15

Council Member Albee? Yes. Council Member Kramerding? Yes. Council Member James?

1:06:48Speaker 15

Council Member Jeffries?

1:06:50Speaker 15

Council Member Johnson? Yes. Vice Mayor Kearney? Yes. Council Member Nolan? Yes. Council Member Owens? Yes. Council Member Walsh?

1:06:56 – 1:07:13Speaker 27

Yes. It passes. Congratulations. Item 12, we will now recognize Council Member Albee for a resolution recognizing Christy Brown and expressing the appreciation of the Mayor and the Council of the City of Cincinnati for Ms. Brown's Diligent work for Greater Cincinnati's nonprofit agencies. Ms. Albee.

1:07:29Speaker 41

All right, all right. Well, come stand next to me and we'll face the crowd here.

1:07:33Speaker 3

Here is the resolution if you'd like to hold it.

1:07:37 – 1:10:24Speaker 41

We got a fancy frame for you. So I'm excited today to recognize Christy Brown for your work with One Source and beyond. Most of the resolution focuses on one source, but we know you've been an amazing partner and member of this community. So without further ado, I will read the resolution. So recognizing Christy Brown, expressing the appreciation of the mayor and the council of the city of Cincinnati for her diligent work for Greater Cincinnati's nonprofit agencies. Whereas for the last 11 years, Christy served as CEO of One Source Center for Nonprofit Excellence, and through this leadership has created more opportunity, strengthened the economy, and elevated lives across Greater Cincinnati. Whereas Christy led One Source Center through several organizational Changes such as a merger between resource and ESCC, moved a warehouse and offices from Sharonville to Queensgate, we love having you in the city, began remote distributions of donated product to better serve outlying areas, the expansion of the leadership programs and fostered a stronger sense of collaboration across the entire nonprofit sector. Whereas Christie most recently worked to merge OneSource and Leadership Council and Social Venture Partners. Whereas throughout her tenure, Christy has led the organization in consulting over 500 projects and individuals, and whereas Christy retired as CEO of one source for non-profit excellence on July 31st, 2026, after serving more than a decade leading the organization's expansion across Greater Cincinnati. Now, therefore, be it resolved by the Council of City Cincinnati, the mayor in this council hereby recognize Christy Brown for her tireless work in the non-profit sector for non-profit organizations, in communities across Cincinnati. Congratulations, Christy. So, Christy, I'm so excited to recognize your work today. So, I first learned about OneSource and their amazing mission a handful years ago. My mom, who's been retired for a bit, came home and was like, I just signed up to be a coach with this great organization, OneSource. They are the nonprofit that serves nonprofits. As many of us know, oftentimes non-profit starts because an amazing person has an idea to give back to the community, and they just jump head in, head first. Sometimes it takes a little extra coaching and support behind the scenes to get the infrastructure up and running. The work you all do is empowering what was it, 500 projects and organizations to really do that boots on the ground work to serve our community. I know each one of my colleagues up here, we really value what our nonprofits do and the support you provide across the community has been extraordinary. Your leadership in this area has been invaluable and you have earned a well-deserved retirement and it is very exciting to honor you and recognize your work today. So congratulations.

1:10:25 – 1:10:58Speaker 42

Would you like to say a few words? Just thank you to the council for your support for all the nonprofits. I always say when I'm at a fundraiser, I remind people, I say, imagine what our city would be like without the nonprofits. So even here today, this was my first time sitting at a council meeting and listening to some of the challenges that you hear from residents. A lot of those are being addressed by the help of nonprofits that are helping in different areas. So I thank you for your support for the nonprofit community because it certainly helps our city thrive. Thank you.

1:11:01 – 1:13:16Speaker 6

So why am I here? I'm Rob Reif-Snyder. I have been serving with great honor as the board chair for One Source Center for Nonprofits and have prior to that was on the board and on the board of the Executive Service Corps, which was a predecessor organization that Christie helped merge with resource to become one source. I I really was honored to be the board chair when Christie was coming to a conclusion about her career and deciding to retire. We had a lot on our plate. The organization is doing great work. The 500 projects that you mentioned, Councilwoman, was just the tip of the iceberg. 750 nonprofit leaders have been trained by OneSource over the years, and I just want to say thank you to the council for recognizing Christy in this way. It's been an honor and a pleasure to work with you, and I know we'll continue to do so. and that's right so christie was very important in in starting uh discussions with two or three other non-profits to see if we could come together and merge one source center the leadership council for non-profits and svp associate venture partner cincinnati all provide great services to nonprofits to help them build their capacity, strengthen their services, strengthen their boards, and so on. In the idea that there may be too many nonprofits sometimes and we can be strengthened by consolidating and merging, Christie provided great leadership to that effort. We worked for close to a year to bring these nonprofits together and We just recently announced the Beam Center for Nonprofits, which is the merger of these three organizations. I'm going to be serving as the inaugural board chair, and we are very excited about that work and hope you'll continue to support that work as we go forward.

1:13:19Speaker 27

Wonderful. Congratulations. Comments from council? I see Mr. Jeffries and then the vice mayor.

1:13:25 – 1:14:36Speaker 23

Yeah, thank you, Councilman Baraboli, for this acknowledgement. So I just wanted to give an anecdotal story of the value of OneSource. So if people remember, it was a little more than two years ago, Red Bike, their board, basically decided to shut it down. And there were a small group of folks, myself included, who said, no, we think this needs to remain, but clearly it's a nonprofit that needs help. And through Interact for Health, they funded a consultant through OneSource, and this gentleman basically went out and benchmarked all other systems in the country, looked at the financials, what's the right board structure, and the result is a really awesome board now. The head of Metro is on the board, Citi has a representative among others, but more importantly, also Red Bike just had a record year record ridership right now beat 2023, and they're on a lot better footing. So all the work, both structural and strategic, that your consultant helped with just was hugely valuable. And so seeing it firsthand, and I think it's really important and valuable, the work that OneSource does. And so thank you for that, and all the best on your next chapter, whatever that is.

1:14:38 – 1:15:17Speaker 8

Thank you. Congratulations, Councilmember Albee. Thank you for bringing Christy Brown here. So excited about you being here in City Hall today and getting honored. You know, your work with helping nonprofits work together really means a lot. You know, often everybody's working in silos and, you know, we are stronger together. So congratulations. I want to say to Rob Reif-Snyder, thank you for your 17 years of being president and CEO of our United Way. I think you finished in like 2018, and you've kept going. So thank you so much for your work in the past and now. Thank you, both of you.

1:15:18 – 1:15:46Speaker 26

Mr. Nolan. Thank you, Mayor. Thank you, Councilmember Albee, for bringing this forward. Christy, I want to say congratulations. I know you've had the opportunity to work very closely with my spouse, Lisa, to bring this merger to reality. It really is a testament to your legacy to see these organizations come together to build on the work that you've done and really accelerate and enhance the work going forward through BEAM. So congratulations. Thank you. Thank you.

1:15:47Speaker 27

And finally, Ms. Owens.

1:15:48 – 1:16:26Speaker 4

Thank you. Lisa is great. No, I just want to say, yes, absolutely, thank you. We live in such a giving city where, yes, we have an ecosystem where there's a lot of nonprofits. And so to be able to pause and ask, how can we work more effectively together? How can we collaborate? Not many people will do that, but it's what we must do when we think about how we serve our residents at the end of the day, how effective that is. And so it's important that we remain innovative and we continue to think about impact and going upstream. So I thank you for what you have represented in this ecosystem.

1:16:27Speaker 27

And I'll add my congratulations as well. Thank you so much for sharing your talent with so many vulnerable and needy communities. Congratulations. Roll call on passage of the resolution, please.

1:16:37Speaker 15

Councilmember Albee? Yes. Councilmember Kramerding?

1:16:42Speaker 15

Councilmember James? Yes. Councilmember Jeffries?

1:16:45Speaker 15

Councilmember Johnson?

1:16:46Speaker 25

Vice Mayor Kearney? Yes. Council Member Nolan? Yes. Council Member Owens?

1:16:50Speaker 15

Yes. Council Member Walsh?

1:16:51Speaker 25

Yes. It passes. Congratulations.

1:16:59 – 1:17:10Speaker 27

Okay, jumping back to our agenda, we will now go back to item one, which is the appointment of former Council Member Reginald Harris to the Cincinnati Planning Commission. Roll call on confirmation of the appointment, please.

1:17:10Speaker 15

Council Member Albee? Yes. Councilmember Kramerding?

1:17:14Speaker 15

Councilmember James? Yes. Councilmember Jeffries? Yes. Councilmember Johnson?

1:17:19Speaker 15

Vice Mayor Kearney? Yes. Councilmember Nolan? Yes. Councilmember Owens? Yes. Councilmember Walsh?

1:17:24Speaker 27

Yes. Item two is the appointment of Dr. Corinne Taylor to the Human Service Advisory Committee. Roll call on confirmation of the appointment, please.

1:17:31Speaker 15

Council Member Albee? Yes. Council Member Kramerding? Yes. Council Member James?

1:17:36Speaker 15

Council Member Jeffries? Yes. Council Member Johnson?

1:17:39Speaker 15

Vice Mayor Kearney? Yes. Council Member Nolan?

1:17:42Speaker 15

Council Member Owens? Yes. Council Member Walsh?

1:17:44Speaker 27

Yes. Item three is the appointment of Haley Bar-King to the Human Service Advisory Committee. Roll call on confirmation of the appointment.

1:17:50Speaker 15

Council Member Albee? Council Member Kramerding?

1:17:54Speaker 15

Council Member James?

1:17:56Speaker 15

Council Member Jeffries? Yes. Council Member Johnson?

1:17:59Speaker 15

Vice Mayor Kearney? Yes. Council Member Nolan?

1:18:02Speaker 15

Council Member Owens? Yes. Council Member Walsh?

1:18:05Speaker 27

Yes. Item 4 is the appointment of Sandra Perry to the Human Service Advisory Committee. Roll call on confirmation of the appointment, please.

1:18:12Speaker 15

Council Member Albee? Yes. Council Member Kramerding? Yes. Council Member James? Yes. Council Member Jeffries? Yes. Council Member Johnson?

1:18:21Speaker 15

Vice Mayor Kearney?

1:18:22Speaker 15

Council Member Nolan?

1:18:24Speaker 15

Council Member Owens? Yes. Council Member Walsh?

1:18:27 – 1:18:50Speaker 27

Yes. Items five through 10 are all appointments to the FC Cincinnati Community Coalition. They are the appointments of Mark Alexander, George Lee, Matthew Lysak, Gregory D. Johnson, John Walter, and Mika Owens. Without objection, we will take these appointments as a single vote. Hearing none, roll call on confirmation of the appointments, please.

1:18:51 – 1:19:05Speaker 15

Council Member Albee. Council Member Kramer, yes. Council Member James, yes. Council Member Jeffries, yes. Council Member Johnson, yes. Vice Mayor Kearney, yes. Council Member Nolan, yes. Council Member Owens, yes. Council Member Walsh, yes.

1:19:07Speaker 27

Items 13 through 25 are as indicated. Item 26, first reading please.

1:19:13 – 1:19:25Speaker 15

An emergency ordinance authorizing the reallocation of $300,000 in existing fiscal year 2024 Human Services Impact Award funding for the priority of eviction prevention and housing stabilization in the City Manager's Office General Fund non-personnel operating budget.

1:19:26Speaker 27

Roll call on suspension.

1:19:28Speaker 15

Councilmember Albee? Yes. Councilmember Kramerding?

1:19:32Speaker 15

Councilmember James?

1:19:34Speaker 15

Councilmember Jeffries? Yes. Councilmember Johnson? Yes. Vice Mayor Kearney?

1:19:41Speaker 15

Councilmember Nolan? Yes. Councilmember Owens?

1:19:46Speaker 15

Councilmember Walsh?

1:19:47 – 1:20:08Speaker 27

No. Ms. Albee, would you like to be recorded as a yes vote for items 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, through 10, 13, through 25? Yes. Thank you. We are in Budget, Finance, and Governance. Mr. Kramerding.

1:20:09Speaker 20

Mayor, I was excused from the Budget and Finance Committee, so I'm going to have the Vice Chair introduce all the budget and finance items today.

1:20:15 – 1:20:37Speaker 26

Mr. Nolan. Thank you. This is the ordinance that follows the motion to allocate the remaining leveraged support funds along with $300,000 that was reallocated from the impact award. We had much discussion about this in committee last week and at council last week, and this is the ordinance that brings that motion forward.

1:20:38Speaker 27

Thank you. Further comments?

1:20:40 – 1:21:03Speaker 4

Yes. I disagree, as you all have heard, with the source of funding in terms of the impact award and its intended use. So, I will be voting no. I am unable to abstain, which is what my vote has been up until this point. But according to our charter, I cannot abstain in full council meeting. So, for items 26 and 27, I will be voting no.

1:21:04Speaker 27

Thank you. Further comments? Seeing none. Classic Billy Webber. Roll call on passage, please.

1:21:13Speaker 15

Councilmember Albee? Yes. Councilmember Kermiting?

1:21:18Speaker 15

Councilmember James? Yes. Councilmember Jeffries? Yes. Councilmember Johnson? Yes. Vice Mayor Kearney? Yes. Councilmember Nolan?

1:21:26Speaker 15

Councilmember Owens? No. Councilmember Walsh?

1:21:29Speaker 27

No. Roll call on emergency.

1:21:31Speaker 15

Councilmember Albee? Yes. Councilmember Kermiting?

1:21:35Speaker 15

COUNCILMEMBER JAMES? YES. COUNCILMEMBER JEFFRIES? YES. COUNCILMEMBER JOHNSON?

1:21:39Speaker 15

VICE MAYOR KEARNEY?

1:21:41Speaker 15

COUNCILMEMBER NOLAN?

1:21:43Speaker 15

COUNCILMEMBER OWENS? YES. COUNCILMEMBER WALSH?

1:21:46Speaker 27

NO. ITEM 27, FIRST READING, PLEASE.

1:21:50 – 1:22:05Speaker 15

AN EMERGENCY ORDINANCE AUTHORIZING THE REALLOCATION OF $790,000 IN EXISTING FISCAL YEAR 2024 HUMAN SERVICES IMPACT AWARD FUNDING FOR THE PRIORITY OF EVICTION PREVENTION AND HOUSING STABILIZATION IN THE CITY MANAGER'S OFFICE GENERAL FUND NONPERSONAL OPERATING BUDGET ACCOUNT. Councilmember Albee?

1:22:05Speaker 15

Councilmember Kramerding?

1:22:07Speaker 15

Councilmember James? Yes. Councilmember Jeffries? Yes. Councilmember Johnson? Yes. Councilmember Kearney? Yes. Councilmember Nolan?

1:22:14Speaker 15

Councilmember Owens? Yes. Councilmember Walsh?

1:22:17 – 1:22:39Speaker 26

No. Mr. Nolan. Similarly to item number 26, this is an ordinance that follows the motion that was passed last week that takes, I'm sorry, that reallocates the funding from the impact award AND DISTRIBUTES IT TO SOME OF OUR NONPROFIT PARTNERS. FURTHER COMMENTS? ROLL CALL IN PASSAGE.

1:22:41Speaker 15

COUNCILMEMBER ALBIE. COUNCILMEMBER CRAMERDY.

1:22:45Speaker 15

COUNCILMEMBER JAMES.

1:22:46Speaker 15

COUNCILMEMBER JEFFRIES.

1:22:48Speaker 15

COUNCILMEMBER JOHNSON. YES. COUNCILMEMBER KERNEY. YES. COUNCILMEMBER NOLAN.

1:22:52Speaker 15

COUNCILMEMBER OWENS. NO. COUNCILMEMBER WALSH.

1:22:55Speaker 27

NO. ROLL CALL IN EMERGENCY.

1:22:57Speaker 15

COUNCILMEMBER ALBIE.

1:22:59Speaker 15

COUNCILMEMBER CRAMERDY.

1:23:01Speaker 15

Councilmember James?

1:23:03Speaker 15

Councilmember Jeffries?

1:23:04Speaker 15

Councilmember Johnson? Yes. Vice Mayor Kearney?

1:23:07Speaker 15

Councilmember Nolan? Yes. Councilmember Owens?

1:23:11Speaker 15

Councilmember Walsh?

1:23:13Speaker 27

No. For item 28, the Vice Mayor is recusing herself. Thank you. Item 28, first reading, please.

1:23:24 – 1:23:38Speaker 15

An emergency ordinance authorizing the reallocation of $50,000 in the existing fiscal year 2024 Human Services Impact Award funding for the priority of eviction prevention and housing stabilization in the City Manager's Office general fund to provide leveraged support resources for the Free Store Food Bank.

1:23:38Speaker 27

Roll call on suspension.

1:23:39Speaker 15

Councilmember Albee? Yes. Councilmember Kermiting?

1:23:43Speaker 15

Councilmember James?

1:23:44Speaker 15

Councilmember Jeffries? Yes. Councilmember Johnson?

1:23:47Speaker 15

Councilmember Nolan? Yes. Councilmember Owens? Yes. Councilmember Walsh? No.

1:23:52 – 1:24:04Speaker 26

Mr. Nolan? This ordinance brings forward the motion from last week that is reallocating $50,000 from the Human Services Impact Award to the Free Store Food Bank.

1:24:05Speaker 27

Further comments? Roll call on passage.

1:24:08Speaker 15

Councilmember Albee? Yes. Councilmember Kermiting?

1:24:12Speaker 15

Councilmember James?

1:24:13Speaker 15

Councilmember Jeffries? Yes. Councilmember Johnson?

1:24:16Speaker 15

Councilmember Nolan?

1:24:18Speaker 15

Councilmember Owens? Yes. Councilmember Walsh?

1:24:21Speaker 27

No. Roll call on emergency.

1:24:24Speaker 15

Councilmember Albee?

1:24:26Speaker 15

Councilmember Kramerding?

1:24:27Speaker 15

Councilmember James? Yes. Councilmember Jeffries? Yes. Councilmember Johnson? Yes. Councilmember Nolan?

1:24:36Speaker 15

Councilmember Owens? Yes. Councilmember Walsh?

1:24:39 – 1:25:14Speaker 27

No. Could someone please bring in the Vice Mayor? WELCOME BACK, VICE MAYOR. ITEM 29, FIRST READING, PLEASE.

1:25:15 – 1:25:26Speaker 15

AN ORDINANCE AUTHORIZING THE CITY MANAGER TO EXECUTE ANY AND ALL AGREEMENTS AND DOCUMENTS AND TAKE SUCH OTHER STEPS AS MAY BE NECESSARY TO SELL APPROXIMATELY 1.5345 ACRES OF LAND AND CONVEY TWO PERMANENT EASEMENTS AND TWO TEMPORARY EASEMENTS.

1:25:26Speaker 27

ROLL CALL AND SUSPENSION.

1:25:28Speaker 15

COUNCIL MEMBER ALBIE.

1:25:29Speaker 15

COUNCIL MEMBER KRAMERING.

1:25:31Speaker 15

COUNCIL MEMBER JAMES.

1:25:32Speaker 15

COUNCIL MEMBER JEFFRIES.

1:25:33Speaker 15

COUNCIL MEMBER JOHNSON. YES. VICE MAYOR KEARNEY. YES. COUNCIL MEMBER NOLAN.

1:25:37Speaker 15

COUNCIL MEMBER OWENS. YES. COUNCIL MEM

1:25:43Speaker 26

THIS IS THE SALE OF PROPERTY FROM THE CINCINNATI RECREATION COMMISSION TO GREAT PARKS TO HELP CREATE A SHARED USE TRAIL CONNECTING GLENWOOD GARDENS AND THE WINTON WOODS TRAIL.

1:25:53Speaker 27

FURTHER COMMENTS? ROLL CALL AND PASSAGE.

1:25:57Speaker 15

COUNCIL MEMBER ALBIE. YES. COUNCIL MEMBER KRAMERDING. YES. COUNCIL MEMBER JAMES.

1:26:01Speaker 15

COUNCIL MEMBER JEFFRIES.

1:26:03Speaker 15

COUNCIL MEMBER JOHNSON.

1:26:05Speaker 15

VICE MAYOR KEARNEY. YES. COUNCIL MEMBER NOLAN.

1:26:08Speaker 15

COUNCIL MEMBER OWENS. YES. COUNCIL MEMBER WALSH.

1:26:10Speaker 27

YES. ITEM 30, FIRST READING, PLEASE.

1:26:13 – 1:26:24Speaker 15

An emergency ordinance authorizing the city manager to apply for, accept, and appropriate a grant of up to $250,000 from the U.S. Department of Justice Office of Community Oriented Policing Services Fiscal Year 26 Law Enforcement Mental Health and Wellness Act Grant Program.

1:26:25Speaker 27

Roll call on suspension.

1:26:26Speaker 15

Councilmember Albee? Yes. Councilmember Kermiting?

1:26:29Speaker 15

Councilmember James? Yes. Councilmember Jeffries?

1:26:32Speaker 15

Councilmember Johnson? Yes. Vice Mayor Kearney? Yes. Councilmember Nolan?

1:26:36Speaker 15

Councilmember Owens? Yes. Councilmember Walsh?

1:26:41Speaker 26

This is a grant application to support the police department's mental health and wellness efforts.

1:26:46Speaker 27

Further comments? Roll call on passage.

1:26:49 – 1:27:02Speaker 15

Councilmember Albee? Yes. Councilmember Krimmerding? Yes. Councilmember James? Yes. Councilmember Jeffries? Yes. Councilmember Johnson? Yes. Vice Mayor Kearney? Yes. Councilmember Nolan? Yes. Councilmember Owens? Yes. Councilmember Walsh?

1:27:02Speaker 27

Yes. Roll call on emergency.

1:27:04 – 1:27:16Speaker 15

Council Member Albee. Yes. Council Member Kermiting. Yes. Council Member James. Yes. Council Member Jeffries. Yes. Council Member Johnson. Yes. Vice Mayor Kearney. Yes. Council Member Nolan. Yes. Council Member Owens. Yes. Council Member Walsh.

1:27:16Speaker 27

Yes. Item 31, first reading, please.

1:27:19 – 1:27:30Speaker 15

An emergency ordinance authorizing the city manager to apply for, accept, and appropriate a grant of up to $6,250,000 from the U.S. Department of Justice Office of Community Oriented Policing Services fiscal year 2026 COPS hiring program.

1:27:30Speaker 27

Roll call on suspension.

1:27:31Speaker 15

Councilmember Albee? Yes. Councilmember Kramerding?

1:27:34Speaker 15

Councilmember James?

1:27:36Speaker 15

Councilmember Jeffries? Yes. Councilmember Johnson? Yes. Vice Mayor Kearney? Yes. Councilmember Nolan? Yes. Councilmember Owens? Yes. Councilmember Walsh?

1:27:44Speaker 26

Yes. Mr. Nolan, this is a grant application to help support our police department's hiring efforts.

1:27:51Speaker 27

Further comments? Roll call on passage.

1:27:54Speaker 15

Council Member Albee. Yes. Council Member Kermiting.

1:27:57Speaker 15

Council Member James.

1:27:59Speaker 15

Council Member Jeffries.

1:28:01Speaker 15

Council Member Johnson.

1:28:02Speaker 15

Vice Mayor Kearney. Yes. Council Member Nolan.

1:28:05Speaker 15

Council Member Owens. Yes. Council Member Walsh.

1:28:08Speaker 27

Yes. Roll call on emergency.

1:28:10Speaker 15

Council Member Albee. Yes. Council Member Kermiting.

1:28:13Speaker 15

Council Member James.

1:28:14Speaker 15

Council Member Jeffries. Yes. Council Member Johnson.

1:28:17Speaker 15

Vice Mayor Kearney. Yes. Council Member Nolan.

1:28:21Speaker 15

Council Member Owens. Yes. Council Member Walsh.

1:28:24Speaker 27

Yes. Item 32, first reading.

1:28:27Speaker 15

An ordinance authorizing the city manager to apply for a grant of up to $2,500,000 from the Ohio Department of Transportation's Municipal Bridge Program.

1:28:34Speaker 27

Roll call on suspension.

1:28:35Speaker 15

Council Member Albee. Yes. Council Member Kermiting.

1:28:38Speaker 15

Council Member James.

1:28:40Speaker 15

Council Member Jeffries. Yes. Council Member Johnson.

1:28:43Speaker 15

Vice Mayor Kearney. Yes. Council Member Nolan.

1:28:46Speaker 15

Council Member Owens. Yes. Council Member Walsh.

1:28:49Speaker 26

Yes. Mr. Nolan. THIS IS A GRANT APPLICATION TO HELP WITH THE DESIGN AND REHABILITATION OF THE MONASTERY STREET BRIDGE.

1:28:56Speaker 27

OTHER COMMENTS? ROLL CALL AND PASSAGE.

1:28:59Speaker 15

COUNCIL MEMBER ALBIE. YES. COUNCIL MEMBER KERMEDEEN.

1:29:03Speaker 15

COUNCIL MEMBER JAMES.

1:29:04Speaker 15

COUNCIL MEMBER JEFFRIES.

1:29:06Speaker 15

COUNCIL MEMBER JOHNSON.

1:29:07Speaker 15

VICE MEMBER KEARNEY. YES. COUNCIL MEMBER NOLAN.

1:29:10Speaker 15

COUNCIL MEMBER OWENS. YES. COUNCIL MEMBER WALSH.

1:29:12Speaker 27

YES. ITEM 33, FIRST READING.

1:29:16Speaker 15

An ordinance authorizing the city manager to apply for a grant of up to $1,825,000 from the Federal Transit Administration Transit-Oriented Development Planning Pilot Program.

1:29:24Speaker 27

Roll call on suspension.

1:29:26Speaker 15

Councilmember Albee. Yes. Councilmember Kermiting. Yes. Councilmember James.

1:29:31Speaker 15

Councilmember Jeffries. Yes. Councilmember Johnson. Yes. Vice Mayor Kearney.

1:29:36Speaker 15

Councilmember Nolan.

1:29:38Speaker 15

Councilmember Owens. Yes. Councilmember Walsh.

1:29:41Speaker 27

Yes. Mr. Nolan.

1:29:43Speaker 26

This is an exciting one. This is a grant application to help provide resources for study and recommendations for transit-oriented development around the Reading Road Bus Rapid Transit Corridor.

1:29:54Speaker 27

Further comments?

1:29:56 – 1:30:47Speaker 41

Thank you, Mayor. I said this during committee, but it bears repeating. I got to catch Metro in action presenting about bus rapid transit at the North Avondale Community Council this month, including discussion around the Redding Road. So I'm excited about this work. I think really extra excited just to have BRT come to life and see that work progress. We are a city where roughly a third of our residents don't have a car, and so being able to improve our public transit is really vital to how our city continues to grow and be accessible and connect people to where they work, play, and work, live, and play. So I just wanted to give a shout out to all the hard work. I know that it's still a long literal road to get there, but I'm excited to have this forward momentum around BRT and connecting our communities.

1:30:48Speaker 27

Thank you. Further comments? Roll call and passage, please.

1:30:52Speaker 15

Councilmember Albee? Yes. Councilmember Kermiting?

1:30:56Speaker 15

Councilmember James?

1:30:57Speaker 15

Councilmember Jeffries? Yes. Councilmember Johnson? Yes. Vice Mayor Kearney? Yes. Councilmember Nolan?

1:31:03Speaker 15

Councilmember Owens? Yes. Councilmember Walsh?

1:31:05Speaker 27

Yes. Item 34, first reading, please.

1:31:09Speaker 15

An ordinance authorizing the city manager to accept proceeds of $1,463,385.98 from the fiscal year 2027 sale of renewable energy certificates.

1:31:20Speaker 27

Roll call on suspension.

1:31:21Speaker 15

Council Member Albee. Yes. Council Member Kermiting.

1:31:25Speaker 15

Council Member James.

1:31:26Speaker 15

Council Member Jeffries. Yes. Council Member Johnson.

1:31:29Speaker 15

Vice Mayor Kearney. Yes. Council Member Nolan.

1:31:33Speaker 15

Council Member Owens. Yes. Council Member Walsh.

1:31:39Speaker 26

This is an ordinance to accept the proceeds of the sale of renewable energy credits and put those dollars back into the revolving energy loan fund.

1:31:48Speaker 27

Further comments? Seeing none, roll call on passage. I'll be right back. Excuse me.

1:31:54Speaker 15

Councilmember Albee? Yes. Councilmember Kermit?

1:31:58Speaker 15

Councilmember James? Yes. Councilmember Jeffries? Yes. Councilmember Johnson? Yes. Vice Mayor Kearney? Yes. Councilmember Nolan?

1:32:07Speaker 15

Councilmember Owens? Yes. Councilmember Walsh?

1:32:16Speaker 8

Okay, item number 35, first reading please.

1:32:19 – 1:32:38Speaker 15

An emergency ordinance authorizing the payment of $26,552.81 from the General Fund Enterprise Software and Licenses Non-Departmental Non-Personnel Operating Budget Account as a Moral Obligation Payment to Central Square Technologies LLC. Okay, and roll call on suspension. Councilmember Albee? Yes. Councilmember Kramer-Ding?

1:32:39Speaker 8

Yes. Oh, I'm sorry, Kramer-Ding, okay. Sounds like Kearney when I'm sitting next to you, I'm sorry.

1:32:44Speaker 15

Councilmember James?

1:32:46Speaker 15

Councilmember Jeffries? Yes. Councilmember Johnson? Yes. Vice Mayor Kearney?

1:32:50Speaker 15

Councilmember Nolan? Yes. Councilmember Owens?

1:32:53Speaker 8

Yes. Excuse me.

1:32:54Speaker 15

Councilmember Walsh? Yes.

1:32:56Speaker 8

Okay. Any comments? Okay.

1:33:03Speaker 8

Roll call on passage.

1:33:06Speaker 15

Councilmember Albee?

1:33:08Speaker 15

Councilmember Kermiting?

1:33:11Speaker 15

Councilmember James?

1:33:13Speaker 15

Councilmember Jeffries? Yes. Councilmember Johnson? Yes. Councilmember Kearney? Yes. Councilmember Nolan?

1:33:19Speaker 15

Councilmember Owens? Yes. Councilmember Walsh?

1:33:22Speaker 15

And emergency? Councilmember Albee?

1:33:26Speaker 15

Councilmember Kermiting?

1:33:28Speaker 15

Councilmember James?

1:33:29Speaker 15

Councilmember Jeffries?

1:33:31Speaker 15

Councilmember Johnson?

1:33:32Speaker 15

Vice Mayor Kearney?

1:33:33Speaker 15

Councilmember Nolan?

1:33:35Speaker 15

Councilmember Owens? Yes. Councilmember Walsh?

1:33:37Speaker 8

Yes. Item number 36, first reading please.

1:33:41 – 1:33:57Speaker 15

An emergency ordinance authorizing the payment of $8,996.54 from the General Fund Enterprise Technology Solutions non-personnel operating budget account to Buckeye Power Sales Co. Inc. as a moral obligation. Roll call on suspension. Councilmember Albee? Yes. Councilmember Kramerding?

1:33:58Speaker 15

Councilmember James?

1:34:00Speaker 15

Councilmember Jeffries?

1:34:01Speaker 15

Councilmember Johnson?

1:34:03Speaker 15

Vice Mayor Kearney? Yes. Councilmember Nolan?

1:34:06Speaker 15

Councilmember Owens? Yes. Councilmember Walsh?

1:34:10Speaker 8

Any comments on item 36? No? Okay.

1:34:17Speaker 26

I'm sorry, Vice Mayor, did you want me to add any additional introduction or?

1:34:21Speaker 8

That would be wonderful.

1:34:22Speaker 26

Okay. This is a more obligation payment for emergency generator repair services.

1:34:28Speaker 8

Cool. Any further comments? Okay, roll call on passage.

1:34:34Speaker 15

Council Member Albee.

1:34:35Speaker 15

Council Member Kermiting. Yes. Council Member James. Yes. Council Member Jeffries. Yes. Council Member Johnson. Yes. Vice Mayor Kearney. Yes. Council Member Nolan.

1:34:44Speaker 15

Council Member Owens. Yes. Council Member Walsh. Yes.

1:34:46Speaker 8

And emergency.

1:34:47Speaker 15

Council Member Albee. Yes. Council Member Kermiting. Yes. Council Member James.

1:34:52Speaker 15

Council Member Jeffries. Yes. Council Member Johnson.

1:34:56Speaker 15

Vice Mayor Kearney. Yes. Council Member Nolan.

1:34:59Speaker 15

Council Member Owens.

1:35:00Speaker 15

Council Member Walsh.

1:35:01Speaker 8

Yes. Item number 37, first reading, please.

1:35:05 – 1:35:16Speaker 15

An emergency ordinance authorizing the payment of $7,151.51 from the General Fund Enterprise Software and Licenses Non-Departmental Non-Personnel Operating Budget Account to Kronos for maintenance and support services.

1:35:17Speaker 8

Roll call on suspension.

1:35:19Speaker 15

Councilmember Albee?

1:35:20Speaker 15

Councilmember Kermiting?

1:35:22Speaker 15

Councilmember James?

1:35:24Speaker 15

Councilmember Jeffries?

1:35:26Speaker 15

Councilmember Johnson? Yes. Vice Mayor Kearney?

1:35:29Speaker 15

Councilmember Nolan?

1:35:31Speaker 15

Councilmember Owens? Yes. Councilmember Walsh?

1:35:33Speaker 8

Yes. Councilmember Nolan, would you like to comment?

1:35:37Speaker 26

This is a then and now payment for ready workshop management software.

1:35:40Speaker 8

Okay, any other comments?

1:35:44Speaker 15

Roll call on passage. Councilmember Albee? Yes. Councilmember Kern-Reeding? Yes. Councilmember James?

1:35:50Speaker 15

Councilmember Jeffries?

1:35:52Speaker 15

Councilmember Johnson?

1:35:53Speaker 15

Vice Mayor Kearney? Yes. Councilmember Nolan?

1:35:56Speaker 15

Council Member Owens? Yes. Council Member Walsh?

1:35:59Speaker 15

Emergency? Council Member Albee? Yes. Council Member Kermiting?

1:36:03Speaker 15

Council Member James?

1:36:05Speaker 15

Council Member Jeffries? Yes. Council Member Johnson?

1:36:07Speaker 15

Vice Mayor Kearney? Yes. Council Member Nolan?

1:36:10Speaker 15

Council Member Owens? Yes. Council Member Walsh?

1:36:13Speaker 8

Yes. Item number 38, first reading please.

1:36:17Speaker 15

AN ORDINANCE AUTHORIZING THE TRANSFER AND APPROPRIATION OF $96,448.80 FROM THE UNAPPROPRIATED SURPLUS OF MISCELLANEOUS PERMANENT IMPROVEMENT FUND TO EXISTING CAPITAL IMPROVEMENT PROGRAM PROJECT ACCOUNT.

1:36:28Speaker 8

OKAY. AND SUSPENSION?

1:36:30Speaker 15

COUNCIL MEMBER ALBE? YES. COUNCIL MEMBER KERMITING?

1:36:33Speaker 15

COUNCIL MEMBER JAMES?

1:36:35Speaker 15

COUNCIL MEMBER JEFFRIES?

1:36:36Speaker 15

COUNCIL MEMBER JOHNSON?

1:36:38Speaker 15

VICE MAYOR KEARNEY? YES. COUNCIL MEMBER NOLAN?

1:36:40Speaker 15

COUNCIL MEMBER OWENS? YES. COUNCIL MEMBER WALSH?

1:36:43Speaker 8

COUNCIL MEMBER NOLAN?

1:36:45Speaker 26

This is the appropriation of proceeds from the sale of obsolete vehicles and equipment to be utilized for the purchase of new fleet equipment and vehicles.

1:36:54Speaker 8

All right. Any comments? Any other comments?

1:36:57Speaker 15

Okay. Roll call on passage. Councilmember Albee?

1:37:00Speaker 15

Councilmember Kermadean?

1:37:02Speaker 15

Councilmember James? Yes. Councilmember Jeffries? Yes. Councilmember Johnson? Yes. Vice Mayor Kearney? Yes. Councilmember Nolan? Yes. Councilmember Owens? Yes. Councilmember Walsh?

1:37:11Speaker 8

Yes. Item number 39. First reading, please.

1:37:15Speaker 15

An ordinance establishing new permanent improvement program project account tri-state trails development to provide resources to tri-state trails.

1:37:21Speaker 8

Okay, roll call on suspension.

1:37:23Speaker 15

Councilmember Albee? Yes. Councilmember Kermiting?

1:37:27Speaker 15

Councilmember James?

1:37:28Speaker 15

Councilmember Jeffries? Yes. Councilmember Johnson? Yes. Vice Mayor Kearney? Yes. Councilmember Nolan?

1:37:34Speaker 15

Councilmember Owens? Yes. Councilmember Walsh?

1:37:38Speaker 8

Councilmember Nolan?

1:37:40Speaker 26

In collaboration with Tri-State Trails, we are working to improve accessibility to our great and expanding trail network.

1:37:47Speaker 8

Okay, any comments? A roll call on passage.

1:37:52Speaker 15

Councilmember Albee?

1:37:54Speaker 15

Councilmember Kramerding?

1:37:56Speaker 15

Councilmember James?

1:37:57Speaker 15

Councilmember Jeffries? Yes. Councilmember Johnson? Yes. Vice Mayor Kearney?

1:38:03Speaker 15

Councilmember Nolan?

1:38:04Speaker 15

Councilmember Owens?

1:38:06Speaker 15

Councilmember Walsh?

1:38:10 – 1:38:21Speaker 15

Item number 40, first reading, please. An ordinance accepting and confirming the grant of permanent easement in favor of the City of Cincinnati for a sidewalk on behalf of the public through and across certain real property in the City of Cincinnati, Hamilton County, Ohio.

1:38:22Speaker 27

Roll call on suspension.

1:38:23Speaker 15

Councilmember Albee? Yes. Councilmember Kramerding?

1:38:26Speaker 15

Councilmember James?

1:38:28Speaker 15

Councilmember Jeffries? Yes. Councilmember Johnson?

1:38:31Speaker 15

Vice Mayor Kearney? Yes. Councilmember Nolan?

1:38:34Speaker 15

Councilmember Owens? Yes. Councilmember Walsh?

1:38:38Speaker 26

Yes. Mr. Nolan? This is the acceptance and confirmation of an easement in favor of the city for a public sidewalk along Butterfield Place in Madisonville.

1:38:48Speaker 27

Further comments? Ms. Albee.

1:38:50 – 1:39:22Speaker 41

Thanks, Mayor. So this is part of, there's going to be some additional condos built in the neighborhood, so excited to obviously have sidewalks connecting those new residents, but want to highlight Madisonville and other communities across our neighborhoods don't have sidewalks on certain streets, so I think this is an area, you all know I love my sidewalks, so this is an area where continuing to just shine a light on how do we make our city as accessible and connected as possible, so hoping in the future we can continue to to build out the sidewalk infrastructure for even existing residents in places where they don't exist today.

1:39:23Speaker 27

Thank you. Further comments? Roll call on passage of item 40.

1:39:28Speaker 15

Councilmember Albee? Yes. Councilmember Kermadean?

1:39:31Speaker 15

Councilmember James?

1:39:33Speaker 15

Councilmember Jeffries?

1:39:34Speaker 15

Councilmember Johnson?

1:39:36Speaker 15

Vice Mayor Kearney? Yes. Councilmember Nolan? Yes. Councilmember Owens? Yes. Councilmember Walsh?

1:39:41Speaker 27

Yes. Item 41, first reading please.

1:39:44Speaker 15

An ordinance accepting and confirming the grant of public utility easement in favor of the City of Cincinnati for water mains and related fixtures, equipment, and appurtenances through certain real property in the City of Forest Park, Hamilton County, Ohio.

1:39:55Speaker 27

Roll call on suspension.

1:39:56Speaker 15

Councilmember Albee?

1:39:58Speaker 15

Councilmember Kermiting?

1:40:01Speaker 15

Councilmember James?

1:40:02Speaker 15

Councilmember Jeffries?

1:40:04Speaker 15

Councilmember Johnson?

1:40:05Speaker 15

Vice Mayor Kearney? Yes. Councilmember Nolan?

1:40:08Speaker 15

Councilmember Owens? Yes. Councilmember Walsh?

1:40:11 – 1:40:28Speaker 26

Yes. Mr. Nolan? If it's okay, I'll go ahead and introduce the next four items. These are all for the acceptance and confirmation of easements for Water Works to expand its footprint and network into Forest Park, Fairfax, and Green Township.

1:40:29Speaker 27

To be clear, we are talking about items 42 through 44?

1:40:34Speaker 26

41 through 44.

1:40:35Speaker 27

41 through 44. Understood, thank you. Any comments for items 41, 42, 43, 44? SEEING NONE, ROLL CALL ON PASSAGE OF ITEM 41.

1:40:46Speaker 15

COUNCILMEMBER ALBIE. YES. COUNCILMEMBER CREMETING.

1:40:49Speaker 15

COUNCILMEMBER JAMES.

1:40:51Speaker 15

COUNCILMEMBER JEFFRIES.

1:40:52Speaker 15

COUNCILMEMBER JOHNSON.

1:40:54Speaker 15

VICE MAYOR KEARNEY. YES. COUNCILMEMBER NOLAN. YES. COUNCILMEMBER OWENS. YES. COUNCILMEMBER WALSH.

1:40:59Speaker 27

YES. ITEM 42, FIRST READING, PLEASE.

1:41:02 – 1:41:17Speaker 15

AN ORDINANCE ACCEPTING AND CONFIRMING THE GRANT OF PUBLIC UTILITY EASEMENT IN FAVOR OF THE CITY OF CINCINNATI FOR WATER MAINS, RELATED FIXTURES, EQUIPMENT, AND PERTINENCES THROUGH CERTA Council Member Albee. Council Member Kramerding. Yes. Council Member James.

1:41:18Speaker 15

Council Member Jeffries.

1:41:19Speaker 15

Council Member Johnson.

1:41:21Speaker 15

Vice Mayor Kearney. Yes. Council Member Nolan.

1:41:24Speaker 15

Council Member Owens. Yes. Council Member Walsh.

1:41:26Speaker 27

Yes. Roll call on passage of item 42, please.

1:41:29Speaker 15

Council Member Albee. Yes. Council Member Kramerding. Yes. Council Member James.

1:41:33Speaker 15

Council Member Jeffries.

1:41:35Speaker 15

Council Member Johnson. Yes. Vice Mayor Kearney. Yes. Council Member Nolan.

1:41:40Speaker 15

Council Member Owens. Yes. Council Member Walsh.

1:41:42Speaker 27

Yes. Item 43, first reading.

1:41:44Speaker 15

An ordinance accepting and confirming the grant of public utility easement in favor of the City of Cincinnati for water mains and related fixtures, equipment, and appurtenances through certain real property in the Village of Fairfax, Hamilton County, Ohio.

1:41:53Speaker 14

Roll call on suspension.

1:41:55 – 1:42:07Speaker 15

Councilmember Albee? Yes. Councilmember Kermerding? Yes. Councilmember James? Yes. Councilmember Jeffries? Yes. Councilmember Johnson? Yes. Vice Mayor Kearney? Yes. Councilmember Nolan? Yes. Councilmember Owens? Yes. Councilmember Walsh?

1:42:07Speaker 27

Yes. Roll call on passage of item 43, please.

1:42:11Speaker 15

Council Member Albee?

1:42:13Speaker 15

Council Member Kermiting?

1:42:15Speaker 15

Council Member James?

1:42:16Speaker 15

Council Member Jeffries?

1:42:18Speaker 15

Council Member Johnson? Yes. Vice Mayor Kearney? Yes. Council Member Nolan?

1:42:23Speaker 15

Council Member Owens? Yes. Council Member Walsh?

1:42:25Speaker 27

Yes. Item 44, first reading, please.

1:42:28Speaker 15

An ordinance accepting and confirming the grant of a public utility easement in favor of the City of Cincinnati for water mains, related fixtures, equipment, and pertinences to a certain real property in Green Township, Hamilton County, Ohio.

1:42:37Speaker 27

Roll call on suspension.

1:42:38Speaker 15

Councilmember Albee? Yes. Councilmember Kerr-Mitting?

1:42:42Speaker 15

Councilmember James?

1:42:43Speaker 15

Councilmember Jeffries? Yes. Councilmember Johnson?

1:42:46Speaker 15

Vice Mayor Kearney? Yes. Councilmember Nolan?

1:42:49Speaker 15

Councilmember Owens? Yes. Councilmember Walsh?

1:42:52Speaker 27

Yes. And roll call in passage of item 44, please.

1:42:57Speaker 15

Councilmember Albee? Yes. Councilmember Kerr-Mitting?

1:43:01Speaker 15

Councilmember James?

1:43:03Speaker 15

Councilmember Jeffries?

1:43:05Speaker 15

Councilmember Johnson?

1:43:06Speaker 15

Vice Mayor Kearney? Yes. Councilmember Nolan? Yes. Councilmember Owens? Yes. Councilmember Walsh?

1:43:12Speaker 27

Yes. Item 45, first reading, please.

1:43:15Speaker 15

An ordinance accepting and confirming the grant of public utility easement in favor of the City of Cincinnati for water mains and related fixtures, equipment, and appurtenances through certain real property in the City of Blue Ash, Sycamore Township, Hamilton County, Ohio.

1:43:25Speaker 27

Roll call on suspension.

1:43:26Speaker 15

Councilmember Albee?

1:43:27Speaker 15

Councilmember Kermadean?

1:43:30Speaker 15

Councilmember James.

1:43:31Speaker 15

Councilmember Jeffries.

1:43:33Speaker 15

Councilmember Johnson.

1:43:35Speaker 15

Vice Mayor Kearney. Yes. Councilmember Nolan.

1:43:38Speaker 15

Councilmember Owens. Yes. Councilmember Walsh.

1:43:40 – 1:43:51Speaker 26

Yes. Mr. Nolan. I should have included this in the list along with the last few. This is an easement for Water Works to expand their network into Blue Ash.

1:43:52Speaker 27

Thank you. Any comments? ROLL CALL AND PASSAGE OF ITEM 45, PLEASE.

1:43:56Speaker 15

COUNCIL MEMBER ALBIE. YES. COUNCIL MEMBER KERMITING.

1:43:59Speaker 15

COUNCIL MEMBER JAMES.

1:44:00Speaker 15

COUNCIL MEMBER JEFFRIES.

1:44:02Speaker 15

COUNCIL MEMBER JOHNSON.

1:44:03Speaker 15

VICE MAYOR KEARNEY.

1:44:05Speaker 15

COUNCIL MEMBER NOLAN.

1:44:06Speaker 15

COUNCIL MEMBER OWENS. YES. COUNCIL MEMBER WELSH.

1:44:10Speaker 27

YES. ITEM 46, FIRST READING, PLEASE.

1:44:15Speaker 15

AN ORDINANCE MODIFYING THE PROVISIONS OF THE ADMINISTRATIVE CODE OF THE CITY OF CINCINNATI BY AMENDING ARTICLE 26, FINANCIAL DISCLOSURE REQUIREMENTS.

1:44:22Speaker 27

ROLL CALL AND SUSPENSION.

1:44:24Speaker 15

Councilmember Albee?

1:44:25Speaker 15

Councilmember Kermiting?

1:44:27Speaker 15

Councilmember James?

1:44:29Speaker 15

Councilmember Jeffries? Yes. Councilmember Johnson?

1:44:31Speaker 15

Councilmember Kearney?

1:44:34Speaker 15

Councilmember Nolan?

1:44:35Speaker 15

Councilmember Owens? Yes. Councilmember Walsh?

1:44:38 – 1:45:05Speaker 26

Yes. Mr. Nolan. This ordinance amends the deadline for filing financial reports to align the city deadlines with the state deadlines. Thanks to the administration for bringing this forward. This is a continuation of the work that we as council and the public voted to approve last year with campaign finance deadlines to enhance transparency and make the overall system more efficient.

1:45:06Speaker 27

Thank you. Further comments? Roll call on passage.

1:45:10Speaker 15

Councilmember Albee. Yes. Councilmember Kermiting.

1:45:13Speaker 15

Councilmember James.

1:45:15Speaker 15

Councilmember Jeffries.

1:45:17Speaker 15

Councilmember Johnson.

1:45:18Speaker 15

Vice Mayor Kearney. Yes. Councilmember Nolan. Yes. Councilmember Owens. Yes. Councilmember Walsh.

1:45:24Speaker 27

Yes. Item 47, first reading.

1:45:27Speaker 15

An ordinance modifying chapter 729, waste disposal on 730 commercial waste franchises.

1:45:38Speaker 27

Roll call on suspension.

1:45:40Speaker 15

Council Member Albee? Yes. Council Member Kermiting?

1:45:43Speaker 15

Council Member James?

1:45:45Speaker 15

Council Member Jeffries? Yes. Council Member Johnson?

1:45:48Speaker 15

Vice Mayor Kearney? Yes. Council Member Nolan?

1:45:51Speaker 15

Council Member Owens? Yes. Council Member Walsh? No.

1:45:58 – 1:46:12Speaker 26

This ordinance amends the code to refine the commercial waste franchise regulations to enhance transparency and compliance with the regulations that are currently in the code now.

1:46:13Speaker 27

Thank you. Further comments?

1:46:16 – 1:47:12Speaker 4

Yes, thank you. As the chair of Climate City Services Infrastructure, of course, how we deal with waste removal in this city is extremely important. So this is specifically focused on the regulatory environment in which we allow that to happen. So for me, I'd like to learn more about the impact on stakeholders and unintended consequences, which is always important, specifically as it relates to our women-owned businesses, minority-owned businesses. So specific to permits and fees, and because we are a listening body, I do believe stakeholders reaching out and having some concerns. I do think that having a moment to understand what those concerns are in this context is important. We see it in what our work currently is around energy benchmarking around parking lots. So listening is important. And so with that, I would motion to move this back to committee. Second.

1:47:13Speaker 27

Who was the second? Mr. Walsh? Okay, any discussion on moving it back to committee? Mr. Nolan.

1:47:20 – 1:47:47Speaker 26

Yeah, I think the question I have is, I know this has been in the works for a while. I know I had the opportunity to participate in some discussions four years ago as a member of the law department. And I'm curious if anyone in the administration has any experience or can speak to any of the attempts to get compliance with those private companies. I know the gentleman that spoke mentioned that there hasn't been any communication

1:47:52 – 1:48:18Speaker 5

to the chair and to the council i know that this specific legislation has been out there for a while now i would prefer to support your efforts of putting it back to committee and then we can have some additional conversation with director kroner as far as his engagement and some of the things conversations that he's had okay thank you thank you any further comments on the motion to send it back to committee

1:48:19 – 1:48:32Speaker 27

Seeing none, it's been seconded and is appropriately in front of us. Again, this is not on the substance of item 47, but rather a question whether or not to send it back to the Budget and Finance Governance Committee. Roll call on passage of the motion.

1:48:33Speaker 15

Councilmember Albee?

1:48:35Speaker 15

Councilmember Kramerding?

1:48:38Speaker 15

Councilmember James?

1:48:40Speaker 15

Councilmember Jeffries?

1:48:41Speaker 15

Councilmember Johnson?

1:48:43Speaker 15

Vice Mayor Kearney? Yes. Councilmember Nolan?

1:48:47Speaker 15

Council Member Owens? Yes. Council Member Walsh?

1:48:50Speaker 27

Yes. Okay. Mr. Clerk, do we have to take any other further action on item 47?

1:48:58Speaker 15

No, Mr. Chair.

1:48:59Speaker 27

Thank you, sir. Item 48, first reading, please.

1:49:02Speaker 15

An ordinance authorizing the city manager to take all necessary and proper actions to cooperate with the director of the Ohio Department of Transportation to facilitate the performance of bridge maintenance activities.

1:49:09Speaker 27

Roll call on suspension.

1:49:11Speaker 15

Council Member Albee?

1:49:13Speaker 15

Councilmember Kermiting?

1:49:15Speaker 15

Councilmember James?

1:49:17Speaker 15

Councilmember Jeffries?

1:49:19Speaker 15

Councilmember Johnson?

1:49:20Speaker 15

Vice Mayor Kearney? Yes. Councilmember Nolan?

1:49:24Speaker 15

Councilmember Owens? Yes. Councilmember Walsh?

1:49:26Speaker 27

Yes. We are now in climate, city service, and infrastructure. Ms. Owens?

1:49:31Speaker 4

Thank you. This is really standard operating procedure ordinance. It allows us to complete bridge maintenance work with our partners like ODOT.

1:49:40Speaker 27

Further comments? Roll call on passage.

1:49:44Speaker 15

Council Member Albee? Yes. Council Member Kermiting?

1:49:47Speaker 15

Council Member James?

1:49:48Speaker 15

Council Member Jeffries? Yes. Council Member Johnson?

1:49:52Speaker 15

Vice Mayor Kearney?

1:49:53Speaker 15

Council Member Nolan?

1:49:55Speaker 15

Council Member Owens? Yes. Council Member Walsh?

1:49:57 – 1:50:24Speaker 27

Yes. Item 49 is a motion from Council Members Jeffries and Albee that the administration within 30 days report the following share a comprehensive 2026 after action analysis either as a report or in presentation to city council from the 2026 flash floods that evaluates what worked slash did not work and what the city needs to start, stop, and continue doing going forward. Ms. Owens, may I have Mr. Jeffries introduce this item?

1:50:25 – 1:51:30Speaker 23

Mr. Jeffries. Thank you, Mr. Mayor. As we all remember, we had the flash floods in July. We had a great meeting in August when we were coming back from recess in Ms. Owens' committee. where MSD came out, I believe they're going to come back in October. And this lays out some requests to look at what worked, what didn't work in terms of our response, looking at things like detention basins, other green infrastructure, et cetera. I think after the flash floods in July, what residents clearly want is a plan, even if it's going to be years in the making, of what we plan to do as a city, and so this lays out a lot of questions for the administration to evaluate, and then it sounds like in October they'll be coming back, MSD, with more of a presentation on what's next, and I think it'll be important to share that with residents, get input, and make sure everyone is on the same page, because we will be seeing these flash floods again. It happened this summer, it will happen again, and we just want to make sure that we have a clear plan going forward

1:51:33Speaker 27

Thank you. Ms. Alvey?

1:51:34 – 1:52:13Speaker 41

Thank you. Councilmember Jeffery summarized it well. I'll just add climate change is real, and it's here in Cincinnati. And I know this body is doing what we can to be proactive and reactive to what we're seeing. And so I'm grateful to everyone on this council who went out, met with community members, who toured sites, who participated in panels. I think that just really reflects the dedication we all have collectively to doing what we can to hopefully improve this for next time, knowing that, to Councilmember Joffrey's point, we expect this type of extreme weather patterns to continue because climate change is real. So thank you. Thank you. Ms. Long?

1:52:15 – 1:52:39Speaker 5

To the chair, to the council, I just want to level set 30 days as maybe a little bit of aggressive a timeline to the councilmember. We are currently working on creating a site for that work and having some long-term and short-term wins, but my team may be reaching out to ask for a little bit more time because there is a lot of work that potentially needs to be talked about, and we may not be able to get that done within that time frame.

1:52:41Speaker 27

Thank you. Further comments? SEEING NONE, ROLL CALL ON ADOPTION OF THE MOTION, PLEASE.

1:52:47Speaker 15

COUNCIL MEMBER ALBIE. YES. COUNCIL MEMBER CREMITING.

1:52:51Speaker 15

COUNCIL MEMBER JAMES.

1:52:52Speaker 15

COUNCIL MEMBER JEFFRIES.

1:52:54Speaker 15

COUNCIL MEMBER JOHNSON.

1:52:56Speaker 15

VICE MAYOR KEARNEY. YES. COUNCIL MEMBER NOLAN.

1:52:59Speaker 15

COUNCIL MEMBER OWENS. YES. COUNCIL MEMBER WALSH.

1:53:02Speaker 27

YES. ITEM 50, FIRST READING.

1:53:05Speaker 15

AN EMERGENCY ORDINANCE AMENDING THE OFFICIAL ZONING MAP OF THE CITY OF CINCINNATI TO REZONE THE REAL PROPERTY LOCATED AT 2323 FERGUSON ROAD IN THE WESTWOOD NEIGHBORHOOD.

1:53:12Speaker 27

ROLL CALL ON SUSPENSION.

1:53:14Speaker 15

Council Member Albee?

1:53:16Speaker 15

Council Member Kermiting?

1:53:18Speaker 15

Council Member James?

1:53:20Speaker 15

Council Member Jeffries? Yes. Council Member Johnson? Yes. Vice Mayor Kearney?

1:53:26Speaker 15

Council Member Nolan?

1:53:28Speaker 15

Council Member Owens? Yes. Council Member Walsh?

1:53:32Speaker 27

No. We are in housing and growth. Mr. Jeffries?

1:53:38 – 1:55:11Speaker 23

Yeah, so we had a pretty robust discussion on this in committee yesterday. It is a development in Westwood on the border of West Price Hill for income-restricted housing units between 50 and 70 percent average-medium income. This is currently a vacant site. It would turn it into about 157 units of housing. And the developer, LDG, has been engaging with the community and the community council. They have an agreement on a community benefits agreement with both West Price Hill and Westwood that has been approved through their community council. They're just finalizing the details on that. So that's what this is. I'm strongly in favor of this. We currently know that we have over 4,000 homeless Cincinnati public school children. We need more housing, especially income-restricted, and this is between 50 and 70%, which they laid out what professions that includes, and I think understand a lot of the concerns around concentrating poverty and others. We have a motion that will follow which will consider that and other next steps that will follow. But overall, I think on balance, you know, we had a good discussion and I think this is a strong project. Thank you.

1:55:11Speaker 27

Further comments? Mr. Chair. Mr. Walsh.

1:55:18 – 2:00:17Speaker 10

I recently read or had a conversation with some people about the book, The Power Broker, about Robert Moses and the transformation of New York City from 1920 to the 1960s. And if you haven't read this book, I would highly recommend you take like a month because it's a thousand plus pages of incredibly tiny font to get through it. And in the first like 300 pages, there's some really fascinating lessons to learn. And then the last 600, I think everybody on this day, I should say, How did that happen? How did we get to the spot that these things were allowed to happen in such a great city? And I've really wrestled with that question and this project now for months as it's popped up, because I've said many a times, publicly, privately, I'm probably the most pro-housing, pro-development person on this dais. My career has been spent in community development. I've built low-income housing tax credit projects. I've built affordable housing. And when I was appointed to city council, the question I kept getting asked is, how do you replicate College Hill? And what a lot of people were asking when they said that was, you know, how do you bring to life the corners of Hamilton and North Bend and the 170 units we brought online there? But I think what I started responding with, and I think what a lot of people were actually asking, is every community has a vision for what they want to achieve and make happen. And it's not always 170 units of market rate housing and it's not always 170 units of affordable housing. And it's complicated and it's messy and figuring out what that is is really, really difficult. And for this council, I think it's also really difficult because we've talked about for four or five years now the need for more housing and specifically affordable housing. And so we get into these situations where to challenge an affordable housing project can feel intimidating. I feel terrified right now, candidly, coming out with this opinion. But so we can lose some of the nuance and we can be scared of the conversation. And so I'm just going to put my opinions on the table here. I'm ultimately going to vote against this. I don't expect my council colleagues to follow me on this. But last week, the Public Safety Committee had a long conversation with the residents of Price Hill about slumlords. We have heard now, for as long as I've been on council, for the decade before I was on council working in the city of Cincinnati, the problems that the Price Hills and Westwood have dealt with in terms of crime and feeling overlooked and feeling like their services, their basic services aren't being met. And perpetually, the answer, I feel like we keep hearing, it's like we as a city aren't doing enough to solve them. And the reality is the Price Hills and the Westwood area, it's gonna take a lot of money in subsidy to be able to jumpstart a market. Like of any kind, it's gonna take just a substantial amount that is gonna be an insanely scary number for us to invest. And I don't think anybody's naive to that. But as I look at this project, what I'm most worried about right now is that the message we're sending to the Price Hills is that we can't deliver or we haven't adequately delivered on their concerns that they've come down here repeatedly to. And, yeah, we're going to come forward with this affordable housing conversation and not be able to address the basic services for those who are living there right now. And I worry that in a decade or two decades, this is going to be a vote that we look back on and say, ah, we probably could have asked more questions or done more for Price Hill. I really appreciate item 51 on here by council members Jeffries and Kramerdine. I think it's a really good start for what comes next. I just, I'm going to vote no because I think even if it's just symbolic, the Price Hills and Westwoods deserve to feel like the significant investment and time and energy that we need to put into them needs to happen and that we can't just paper over it. And I don't think that's easy. I think this is nuanced. I think this is complicated. We absolutely need more housing. We absolutely need more housing for those who are experiencing homelessness. But also, you know, some of the best things we found in College Hill was renovating the existing housing to get it out of slum conditions into just quality and keeping the rents down was a powerful tool we had. And so this by no means is an indictment on the planning department. There's no means of indictment on the developer. I just think we need to really make a stand for the west side right now that I think everybody on this council would agree we need to do more for and we need to do better by. And if this is our opportunity to challenge ourselves and this administration for how we can do that, I WOULD LIKE TO SEE US TRY. I ALSO, AGAIN, RECOGNIZE THAT I DON'T EXPECT YOU ALL TO FOLLOW ME ON THIS, BUT I'VE REALLY, REALLY WRESTLED WITH THIS ONE FOR SEVERAL MONTHS NOW. SO I WILL BE BREAKING FROM WHAT I NEVER THOUGHT I WOULD DO AND ACTUALLY VOTE AGAINST A DEVELOPMENT TODAY.

2:00:19Speaker 27

THANK YOU. FURTHER COMMENTS? MR. CHAIR. MR. NOLAN, THEN VICE MAYOR, PLEASE.

2:00:24 – 2:01:35Speaker 26

THANK YOU, CHAIR. COUNCILMEMBER WALSH, I WOULD JUST NOTE THAT THIS PROJECT IS IN WESTWOOD. Westkirk, Westwood Works, and the Westwood Civic Association have all excitedly supported this project. So the suggestion that we're not somehow giving the west side what they've asked for. Westwood just passed their own neighborhood plan where they called for this type of development in their neighborhood. The concerns that you seem to be teeing up come from some portion of West Price Hill or maybe even East Price Hill, which in many cases, maybe not all, aren't located very close to where this project is. And I have some concerns about the precedent that could set that if some small group of people don't like the look of a development for whatever reason, that is miles from their own home that we should somehow hold it up. We are never going to get to our ambitious goal of 40,000 new housing units if we hold up projects like this one, particularly one that provides additional affordable housing in a neighborhood that is asking for it. Thank you. Vice Mayor.

2:01:36 – 2:03:39Speaker 8

Thank you. I really appreciate Councilmember Walsh's information on this and consideration of it. I'm voting against this as well. I feel that the West Price Hill community was just rolled over by this developer. I think it's really important to work with the communities. Yes, it's on the border of Westwood and West Price Hill. My understanding is that the Planning Commission had to make the developer go and talk to the Westwood, to the West Price Hill Community Council. They were completely left out of any consideration. I was told at that meeting a lot of things came out that weren't true. The developer said that there were plans for a playground and really there aren't. They told them that a traffic audit had been done and it has not. We've had a lot of complaints about how bad the traffic is right now. And with 167 units coming, that needs to be addressed. Whether there's a pedestrian study coming later, I mean, that's too late. These things need to be worked out in advance. At the Planning Commission meeting back in June, it seemed that there was a big rush to vote on this. because the developer said that they had to apply for the state LIHTC credits, the 4%. Turns out they did not even apply for that. It's just messy. And if there's a community benefits agreement, I don't know anything about that, but if it's going on, it needs to be completed. before this is actually approved, because once projects are approved, it's really difficult to get approval for a community benefits agreement after the fact. So for that reason, I'm going to vote with the West Price Hill Community Council, who gave a letter of no, and so I'm going to vote no.

2:03:40Speaker 27

Thank you. We've got quite a few folks who want to make comments, so I'll go to President Johnson next. Back to Mr. Nolan and then Ms. Albee.

2:03:49 – 2:04:44Speaker 34

Thank you, Mr. Chair. Yeah, there appears to be some confusion here based on the information that I also received from West Price Hill. Of course, Mr. Nolan, I'm sorry, Mr. Nolan makes a good point and so does Mr. Walsh, but we got to make sure that we are engaging the community at every level where these developments are going up. I've also been told that they're not against the development. They just want mixed-use development also. So there's a lot of conflict here. Can I ask a question? I'm not in the Housing and Growth Committee. Is it necessary that we expedite this development at this point in time, if I may ask that question, Mr. Chair?

2:04:45 – 2:04:58Speaker 27

Would the administration like to take Mr. or excuse me, President Johnson's question about the timing and the urgency of this item 50? Mr. Weber.

2:05:00 – 2:05:43Speaker 18

Thank you. I want to double check with the Office of Strategic Growth and the developer to confirm. I do know that a bit of the timing pressure was relieved from when this was in Planning Commission because there was an application cycle for LIHTC that they were up against. My understanding since then is that They have determined to go a different path for their financing. So my current understanding is there is more time than was previously indicated. But I would like to confirm, I can try to confirm right now with Brandon Rudd.

2:05:44 – 2:06:00Speaker 27

Yeah, I think there's time to confirm if you wouldn't mind indulging us. So while Mr. Weber confirms President Johnson, We'll continue to discuss. I saw Mr. Jeffries. Please, Mr. Chair.

2:06:00 – 2:06:38Speaker 34

I greatly appreciate that, Mr. Weber and the administration. It's just a matter of if we can make sure that we are addressing all the issues that appear to be on the table when it comes to this development. Like I said, there appears to be that they're not against the development. They would just like to see it more mixed use. Of course, we need housing in Cincinnati. We need housing. But we want to make sure that the community is completely respected and not overlooked, and they don't feel as though, you know, perceptions, reality depend on who's doing the perceiving. They don't feel as though they've been run over. So thank you very much, Mr. Chair.

2:06:39Speaker 27

I know I had called on Mr. Nolan, but Mr. Jeffries, do you have a comment on the timing?

2:06:43 – 2:07:29Speaker 23

Yeah, no, just on the timing, just to be clear. So we actually delayed this item for six weeks. It came up over the summer. We were going to vote on it, but the West Price Hill Community Council specifically asked for more time to engage on the Community Benefits Agreement. So there was a delay of six weeks. During that six weeks, the CBA, Community Benefits Agreement, was agreed to. And so West Price Hill has signed on to that. Westwood has signed on to it. And so, in response to the question, there has been further engagement, and it was delayed, and I'll let the administration respond. My understanding is the developer is going for LIHTC now, and so they need this in order to proceed with the project. Thank you.

2:07:29Speaker 27

I'll go back to Mr. Nolan, please.

2:07:31 – 2:09:36Speaker 26

Thank you. Yeah, I'll just add on the timeline. The developer has been engaged with Westwood for more than a year on this, as Councilmember Jeffries noted. We here on council delayed it six weeks, so there could be even more engagement with West Price Hill, which has happened and the Community Benefits Agreement has been moving along. You know, to the extent that we feel like we need to listen to the people and ask and do what the residents are asking us to do, it is very clear what the residents of Westwood are asking us to do here. Again, I have concerns about the precedent of what other neighborhoods may have to say about things that are not happening in their neighborhood, particularly when they have been meaningfully engaged. If we want to talk about the substance of the concerns, I know not every council member had the opportunity to attend Housing and Growth Committee, The idea of the traffic study, it did come up. The developer on their own commissioned a traffic study which came back to show that this development and the current zoning would cut the amount of traffic by half. So to the extent that traffic is a concern, there will be significantly less traffic with this development than there would be with a commercial development for which the property is currently zoned. And to the concerns about it being mixed use or including retail, that directly contradicts the concern about traffic. Any commercial use will invite patrons by the tens or hundreds per hour way more than would be coming in and out of this property as a residential use. So we also talked about the overcrowding, the density of housing. I think if you look at a map, you have to go almost half a mile or more before you see any other multifamily housing. There are a few single-family residences nearby, but generally I'm not seeing any concerns that really continue to need to be addressed. So I'm not sure why we would continue to hold this up any longer than we already have.

2:09:36Speaker 27

Thank you. Before I go to Ms. Albee, Mr. Weber has returned.

2:09:39 – 2:10:29Speaker 18

Thank you. My understanding, based on the information I received, is that it is not an imminent, as in the next few weeks, deadline for the next round of LIHTC that this project is going to be applying for and seeking. So to the extent that's helpful for Council, It is not the same situation as we had in Planning Commission, which it was down to several days. There could be more time to consider. But I did hear Councilmember Jeffrey's point. Yes, this was delayed out of Planning Commission. We did ask at Planning Commission for more engagement, which was done by the developer following Planning Commission. So just to affirm that as well. Thank you. Ms. Alvey.

2:10:29 – 2:13:05Speaker 41

Thank you. And I want to thank all the comments from my colleagues before. So I want to lift up. So in planning, yes, there was the ask that the developer go back and engage in West Price Hill. In fact, the developer engaged West Price Hill in a CBA before Westwood. The neighborhood this development is not even in. got a CBA before the neighborhood where it actually is and wants it. So I don't know what else we could be asking of this development team. In fact, West Price Hill agreed to the CBA, per my understanding, and asked that West would be included in it. So as we, I hear the concerns, I genuinely do, Again, Planning Commission asked for that increased community engagement. We've delayed this project already. I genuinely don't know what else we would legitimately ask to change in this project in the engagement between now and next week or the week after or whatever. We have an agreement to a community benefit agreement on both sides and both neighborhoods now. And Westwood has been highlighted once this, the neighborhood where this project is, once this development. And I'll speak for my own neighborhood. I can only imagine the outrage of my neighbors if Madisonville voted in favor of a development, and people from Oakley or Hyde Park or somewhere else complained about the development in our neighborhood, even though we're next-door neighbors. So, you know, I appreciate the time that has been taken and the engagement done on all sides. We have a responsibility to hear from all of our residents, and so I do genuinely appreciate that, but The neighborhood where this development is is asking for it. There's a CBA in both neighborhoods, which includes things like increased security measures, cameras and gates, to my knowledge, which I know was part of the concerns. So, you know, I continue to be in favor, and I personally see no reason to hold on this today. And I will also add, This council, I think every one of us have campaigned on more affordable housing. This is an opportunity to add more affordable housing in a currently vacant building. And you know what's bad for public safety and quality of life are vacant buildings. We've talked about that. Council Member Walsh, you've offered many comments about vacant buildings. So, you know, to me, this is a step in the right direction as we continue to provide what our residents are asking for, which is more housing. more affordable housing. And I appreciate the engagement that's been done to this point to address concerns. And I hope we move this forward today.

2:13:06Speaker 27

Thank you. Several of the council members would like to weigh in. Ms. Owens and then Mr. Kramerding and then Mr. James.

2:13:12 – 2:14:26Speaker 4

Thank you, Mayor. I really can't believe the conversation that we're actually having on this day is right now. Building housing is always urgent. The cost of everything is going up. And just to remind ourselves, we just took a million dollars from housing stabilization of people who find themselves in a position of not being able to pay rent. Because why? It has to go to supply and demand, ultimately. So this council cannot be ambiguous when it comes to growth. I would also add that, yes, to the conversation of affordability, we're talking about 50 to 70 percent AMI. Let's attach those to actual jobs, teachers, public servants, right? So, this conversation that we're having is actually counterintuitive. And I would also offer to this conversation that this is exactly why developers might look at Cincinnati and think, wow, let me go take my investment to another city and build housing. So, Housing is absolutely urgent all the time, and there's no reason for us to delay or send this back to committee, in my opinion.

2:14:27Speaker 27

Thank you. Mr. Kramerding.

2:14:29 – 2:17:06Speaker 20

Thank you, Mayor, and a sincere thank you to my colleagues. I do appreciate the attention of the West Side, because it's the only West Sider elected to council I do hear a lot. A couple comments. There are a few strident voices from Price Hill. And they're unpleasant. And they're unfortunate. And I think they're counterproductive. But having said that, I do think those voices reflect how Price Hill feels. The market dynamics in Price Hill are not working. We are constantly chasing quality of life issues. We're hearing from it. People are loud and they're angry. because the market dynamics are not working. We as a council, I believe, are tasked to change that. I certainly have never campaigned and said that Price Hill needs more affordable housing. All the housing in Price Hill is inherently affordable. Price Hill needs catalytic development that will support the business district and bring in people with higher incomes to support that business district. So there can't be a catch-all solution. And I think Westwood is a very different example. I think the market dynamics are working in Westwood. The business district is growing, which is why these two neighborhoods feel very differently about this project. Westwood is confident. They're optimistic. They want more housing. Price Hill is very pessimistic and very insecure and very fearful. So we need to be mindful of that. We've talked about the next motion on the agenda. As I said in committee, I think it's a challenge because I'm not sure where we sit as a council. We've got a lot of well-intentioned community partners, but I often believe maybe that we collectively are more concerned about cranking out units and not changing markets. And it's Price Hill, and it's Mount Airy, and it's Avondale. They don't need more units. They need to change the market, and we need to be very cognizant of that. SO HAVING SAID THAT, THAT'S THE REASON I SUPPORTED NUMBER 51, THE MOTION. I DON'T SEE A REASON NOT TO GIVE THIS MORE TIME. I WOULD BE IN SUPPORTIVE OF SENDING THIS MEC TO COMMITTEE. I THINK THERE IS TIME TO SEE WHAT HAPPENS AS FAR AS SOME OF THESE NEGOTIATIONS. THIS DEVELOPER DOES NOT HAVE A GOOD TRACK RECORD, BUT IF WE VOTE TODAY, I WILL VOTE IN SUPPORT.

2:17:07Speaker 27

THANK YOU. MR. JAMES.

2:17:13 – 2:20:28Speaker 16

You know, there's been a lot of comments on the day off today, and no one is saying that the West Side doesn't continually deserve better. I know that when we do community engagement in the West Side, it is almost hard to get home at night because you have so many questions about what we're going to do next and how we're going to uplift our residents. quite frankly public service outages and failures that have happened in the neighborhood i know my inbox is full right now of folks talking about blight and trash that wasn't picked up properly um so you know the the west side deserves better but i will say as we you have found me at times critical of this goal of creating x tens of thousand units of housing because I think it's a goal that is worth chasing, and it's a goal that's tied to outcomes, but it's absent of the lived experience of our residents as it applies granularly. The new development in a neighborhood, and the neighborhood isn't put in a position where they have to react and create a stance. And I commend Councilmember Owen, not Councilmember Owens, Councilmember Nolan for rolling up their sleeves and doing the work here and making sure that there was process for our residents to be heard. I hear you, Councilmember Walsh, in your comments about how we can better uplift the west side. Councilmember Cranberry, I think your sentiments echoed. But I will say, as it pertains to this particular situation, I do believe that community engagement was done. We had a robust conversation in housing and growth. Not every developer is willing to spend years with the community. Not every developer is willing to make accommodations. Not every developer is willing to lead a successful community benefits agreement, which should be common practice, which should be best practice in the city of Cincinnati. So for those reasons, I do believe that this is a development that can be good for the community. I think that as you apply humanity to this, I understand that there's conceptions, true and false, about concentrations of poverty in neighborhoods. But when you look at the nature of this project, It is teachers, it is service industry workers, it is late shift nurses. These are folks who have been crying for more housing options in our community for quite frankly a decade in Cincinnati. So yes, we have an obligation to create affordable housing. Yes, we have a responsibility to create a place for these folks who quite frankly cannot make it at 2 p.m. for a council meeting and be heard and create a physical presence to influence our decisions. So I'm in support of this development at this time. I will say, Councilmember Nolan, it was your comments that really resonated with me in this conversation. As you said, focused on this high level goal with the city of creating units, but making sure that that's granular and human. I do think you have a right to win here because you have rolled up your sleeves and you have done the work. You're not just talking right now. And this is a 24-7 issue for you. So I will say that, you know, I'm in support of this development. If we think we can make reasonable accommodations in a short timeframe, I'm open to hearing those and understanding what another week or two weeks could do. But it sounds like we don't have a plan for what that timeframe is going to do. We have an appetite to accommodate a few loud voices. So for that reason, I'm in support of this development. Thank you. Thank you. Final comment from Mr. Jeffries.

2:20:29 – 2:21:59Speaker 23

Thank you, Mr. Mayor. Yeah, I think item 51, we'll talk here in a second, that is a motion to address the need for market demand and private demand. I make a second point for people who are at the committee. The developer pointed out the Bond Hill development, what has happened around there. What has happened, and this happens often with new developments, the development across the street, which is a little old and tired, they've upped their game. They have updated their windows, they have done landscaping, they have upped their game because they see they have competition. And that's what happens. In this case, it is an empty lot, a vacant lot. But can that spark other market demand around there? Yes. The other thing I would point out, back to, I think, your point, Councilmember James, on making it human is right. Because, yes, there were 3,500, now there are 4,000 CPS kids who are homeless. We had the Bond Hill development, 160 units. This is 157. We had the one in Walnut Hills where we reduced it by 100. That's 400 units. So we can't say that we're in favor of affordable housing and then vote against it when we have affordable housing that is there for our kids. And so that would be the thing that I would encourage us. When it comes forward and the community is in favor of it, in this case, Westwood especially, then I think it deserves our support. Thank you.

2:22:00 – 2:22:19Speaker 27

Okay. Everyone's been heard who wants to be. I know I said final comment, but I'm going to open it up for anyone who wants. I see President Johnson would like to say something. Last call for any comments on this item. I see the Vice Mayor. Anybody else? Okay, I'm cutting it off. President Johnson, then the Vice Mayor for the actual final comment.

2:22:19 – 2:23:32Speaker 34

Thank you, Mr. Chair. Just very quickly, I just asked a question about the delay. I didn't ask for it to be delayed. That's number one. Number two is, when you talk about Bond Hill and what's happening up there, I don't know how many of you have talked to the people that live in the village at daybreak, so that's not a real good comparison to make about what's happening in Bond Hill. That should have never happened in Bond Hill. I've never... This is completely contrary. What I'm hearing on this dais is in complete, complete contrary to what residents that live up there have said to me personally. And that's fair. I mean, you're in the housing committee, I'm not in the housing committee. But I do have a right to ask those questions as to what's going on in contrast to what I'm hearing and what they're saying to me. But the Bond Hill analogy, that's not a good analogy. That's a piss-pork analogy to be quite honest. of what is happening to the people that live in the village at daybreak. Thank you very much, Mr. Mayor. Thank you. Vice Mayor?

2:23:33 – 2:25:23Speaker 8

I'm just really, really tired of seeing our residents rolled over. And that's what's happening with the West Price Hill Community Council. I mean, they have considered this. They've spoken to the developer. They met with that developer. But they have a letter opposing this project, and they have good reasons for it. things that should have happened, for example, the traffic impact study wasn't done. They have concerns about safety of the students. You know, West High is right there, Data Montessori is right there. They have concerns about pedestrian safety. They have concerns about the market rate in their neighborhood, where their businesses are really struggling. And then if you look at what this developer has done, for example, you keep talking about Bond Hill, the villages of Daybreak that this council voted for, I mean, it's pretty horrible. That development is right in the backyards of the homeowners of the villages of Daybreak. I mean, physically in their backyard. And they're very upset about that. And so we've heard a lot of people from West Price Hill complain. They don't want this. There's no community benefits agreement that's been agreed upon, as far as I know. And to pass this before that even happens means that you take all of the wind out of their sails. I mean, there's no power of having a CBA agreed upon after the development has been passed by council. So I think this is a very unfortunate situation, and I'm totally opposed to it. Thank you.

2:25:23Speaker 23

Mr. Mayor, can I just correct one thing?

2:25:26 – 2:26:03Speaker 27

Mr. James, I'm cutting us off. I apologize. Except for me, I will say that this is an affordable housing development that we have consistently said that we need across the board. The residents that live in this actual neighborhood where this is going to happen want it. The traffic study was done and it showed that housing is certainly better for traffic than commercial. which is the other comment that we're hearing. So I don't have a vote, but I would strongly support this and encourage my colleagues to do so. Roll call on passage of item 50.

2:26:04Speaker 15

Councilmember Albee? Yes. Councilmember Kramerding?

2:26:08Speaker 15

Councilmember James?

2:26:10Speaker 15

Councilmember Jeffries?

2:26:12Speaker 15

Councilmember Johnson?

2:26:14Speaker 15

Vice Mayor Kearney? No. Councilmember Nolan?

2:26:18Speaker 15

Councilmember Owens?

2:26:20Speaker 15

Councilmember Walsh?

2:26:21Speaker 27

No. Roll call on emergency.

2:26:24Speaker 15

Councilmember Albee?

2:26:25Speaker 15

Councilmember Kerrmaning?

2:26:28Speaker 15

Councilmember James?

2:26:30Speaker 15

Councilmember Jeffries? Yes. Councilmember Johnson?

2:26:34Speaker 15

Vice Mayor Kearney?

2:26:36Speaker 15

Councilmember Nolan?

2:26:38Speaker 15

Councilmember Owens?

2:26:40Speaker 15

Councilmember Walsh? No.

2:26:44 – 2:27:12Speaker 27

Thank you. Item 51 is a motion from Councilmembers Jeffries and Kramerding that the administration in partnership with Home Base, Price Hill Will, Westwood Civic and other stakeholders report back to City Council within 30 days with a proposed framework for developing a medium to long-term neighborhood investment strategy centered around the proposed LDG development in Westwood and on in Westwood on the border of West Price Hill. Mr. Jeffries, this is your committee. Would you like to introduce the item?

2:27:13 – 2:27:52Speaker 23

Thank you, Mr. Mayor. We've already teed this up, but given the comments earlier, which I think are right, where we need more market demand there, we need more private development in and around this development in Westwood, the intent of this is how can we pull together, since this does cross two neighborhoods, Westwood and West Price Hill, both Price Hill Will, Westwood Civic, other organizations, and Homebase. We've already met with Homebase to assess how can we have a more deliberate strategic investment strategy in this area. So that's the intent of this. Again, the work has already started, and look forward to pushing it forward.

2:27:52Speaker 27

Mr. Kramerdijk.

2:27:54 – 2:28:25Speaker 20

Yeah, again, go back to cautiously optimistic. I think if this motion is successful, and, you know, there are some projects that are in the works in this area. And I think if the city, working with our partners, working with the Neighbor Development Fund, working with the Office of Strategic Growth, is successful and pushes these forward, I think it would be a tremendous win for both neighborhoods and be a victory. And if it's not, I think that's going to be a tremendous negative for our collective housing efforts.

2:28:27Speaker 27

Further comments? Mr. Nolan.

2:28:29 – 2:29:31Speaker 26

Thank you, Mayor. Just to reiterate some of my points from yesterday on this particular motion, I appreciate the efforts put in by the respective community councils and the developer to come together and have the discussion around a community benefits agreement. And I appreciate council members Jeffries and Cranberding bringing this forward. But in the larger context, this is something that I just don't think that the city has the capacity to do on every housing development. I support it here, and we'll vote in favor. But as we move forward, as we consider the neighborhood planning cycle and the attention that we give to neighborhoods, we have to think more about what happens after that neighborhood plan is approved. How do we get to activation and implementation? How do we get to the development that the community wants? And doing it on a one-off basis like this is not efficient. We don't have the resources for it. IT IS WORK THAT NEEDS TO BE DONE, BUT WE NEED TO FIND A WAY TO COLLABORATE WITH COMMUNITY PARTNERS, LIKE HOME BASE AND OTHERS, TO MAKE THIS HAPPEN IN A MORE EFFICIENT WAY. THANK YOU. FURTHER COMMENTS?

2:29:33Speaker 27

ROLL CALL ON ADOPTION OF THE MOTION, PLEASE.

2:29:35Speaker 15

COUNCILMEMBER ALBE? YES. COUNCILMEMBER KRAMERDING?

2:29:38Speaker 15

COUNCILMEMBER JAMES? YES. COUNCILMEMBER JEFFRIES?

2:29:41Speaker 15

COUNCILMEMBER JOHNSON?

2:29:42Speaker 15

VICE MAYOR KEARNEY? YES. COUNCILMEMBER NOLAN?

2:29:46Speaker 15

COUNCILMEMBER OWENS? YES. COUNCILMEMBER WALSH?

2:29:48Speaker 27

YES. Item 52, first reading, please.

2:29:52Speaker 15

Be version of an emergency ordinance declaring that East Mitchell Avenue at Clifton Springs Avenue in the North Avondale neighborhood shall hereby receive the honorary secondary name of Betty T. Oldenway.

2:30:01Speaker 27

Roll call on suspension.

2:30:02Speaker 15

Councilmember Albee.

2:30:05Speaker 15

Councilmember Cramerding.

2:30:07Speaker 15

Councilmember James.

2:30:08Speaker 15

Councilmember Jeffries.

2:30:10Speaker 15

Councilmember Johnson.

2:30:11Speaker 15

Vice Mayor Kearney.

2:30:12Speaker 15

Councilmember Nolan.

2:30:14Speaker 15

Councilmember Owens. Yes. Councilmember Walsh.

2:30:19 – 2:30:30Speaker 23

Yeah. Items 52, 3, 54, and 55 are all street namings that the Vice Mayor is offering. So I will turn it over to her to introduce each one.

2:30:30 – 2:31:33Speaker 8

Vice Mayor. Okay. So I'll just quickly tell you a little bit about each person. So the first one is Betty T. Oldham. This is a street in North Avondale. She is a graduate of Woodward High School. She devoted her professional life to education and community advocacy. She served as a CPS teacher. I mentioned earlier that she was Lincoln Ware's second grade teacher, which that's what he was coming to talk about. She also broke racial barriers in Cincinnati by becoming the first black homeowner on Mitchell Avenue. And I'll skip a lot of this. There's so much about her. But she co-authored Kid Safari to inspire children to travel. And she was among the first black Cincinnatians, excuse me, to serve on the symphony and the ballet boards. She was also a founding member of the Taft Museum's Duncanson Society and the Cincinnati Art Museum's Donald P. Soul Committee. And yes, this was approved by the North Avondale Neighborhood Association.

2:31:33Speaker 27

Wonderful. Further comments on item 52? Seeing none, roll call on passage.

2:31:38Speaker 15

Councilmember Albee?

2:31:40Speaker 15

Councilmember Kramerding?

2:31:41Speaker 15

Councilmember James?

2:31:43Speaker 15

Councilmember Jeffries?

2:31:44Speaker 15

Councilmember Johnson? Vice Mayor Kearney?

2:31:47Speaker 15

Councilmember Nolan? Yes. Councilmember Owens? Yes. Councilmember Walsh?

2:31:50Speaker 27

Yes. Roll call on emergency.

2:31:52 – 2:32:04Speaker 15

Councilmember Albee? Yes. Councilmember Kermiting? Yes. Councilmember James? Yes. Councilmember Jeffries? Yes. Councilmember Johnson? Vice Mayor Kearney? Yes. Councilmember Nolan? Yes. Councilmember Owens? Yes. Councilmember Walsh?

2:32:04Speaker 10

Yes. Item 53, first reading, please.

2:32:07Speaker 15

An emergency ordinance declaring that Redding Road at Berry Lane in the North Avondale neighborhood shall hereby receive the honorary secondary name of Arzel Papazel Nelson Way.

2:32:16Speaker 27

Roll call on suspension.

2:32:17Speaker 15

Councilmember Albee?

2:32:18Speaker 15

Councilmember Kermiting?

2:32:21Speaker 15

Councilmember James?

2:32:22Speaker 15

Councilmember Jeffries?

2:32:23Speaker 15

Councilmember Johnson? Yes. Vice Mayor Kearney? Yes. Councilmember Nolan?

2:32:28Speaker 15

Councilmember Owens? Yes. Councilmember Walsh?

2:32:30Speaker 27

Yes. Vice Mayor.

2:32:34 – 2:34:02Speaker 8

Okay, thank you. Again, this is another street. These are honorary second year street namings. This one is in North Avondale as well. It's Redding Road at Berry Lane. And this was requested by Attorney Daniel Hofheimer. to name a secondary street, to name, to give an honorary secondary name to that street, and the name would be Arzell Papa Zell Nelson Way. Arzell Nelson is a native Cincinnatian. He devoted his professional life to social justice and civic engagement. He served on the Cincinnati Human Relations Commission and retired in 1998 as its executive director. He was awarded the key to the city of Cincinnati by three different mayors, and he received official recognition from Ohio Governor George Voinovich for his contributions to cultural diversity and civic leadership. He was nationally recognized for his human relations work and his community service work, including letters of appreciation from President Bill Clinton and other honors. I won't name them all. There's a lot. He also received recognition from Ukraine's Department of State for his work in global human relations. He is also an accomplished musician and promoter. So we'll stop there because there's so much more to say about him. Thank you. But again, this was approved by the North Avondale Neighborhood Association.

2:34:04Speaker 27

Thank you. Further comments? Roll call on passage, please.

2:34:07Speaker 15

Council Member Albee. Yes. Council Member Kramerding.

2:34:11Speaker 15

Council Member James.

2:34:12Speaker 15

Council Member Jeffries. Yes. Council Member Johnson. Vice Mayor Kearney.

2:34:16Speaker 15

Council Member Nolan.

2:34:18Speaker 15

Council Member Owens. Yes. Council Member Walsh.

2:34:20Speaker 27

Yes. And emergency.

2:34:21Speaker 15

Council Member Albee. Yes. Council Member Kramerding. Yes. Council Member James.

2:34:26Speaker 15

Council Member Jeffries.

2:34:27Speaker 15

Council Member Johnson. Vice Mayor Kearney.

2:34:31Speaker 15

Council Member Nolan.

2:34:33Speaker 15

Council Member Owens. Yes. Council Member Walsh.

2:34:36Speaker 27

Yes. Item 54, first reading, please.

2:34:40Speaker 15

An emergency ordinance declaring that Hamilton Avenue at Belmont Avenue in the College Hill neighborhood shall hereby receive the honorary secondary name of Betty Jean Daniels Rosemond Way.

2:34:48Speaker 27

Roll call on suspension.

2:34:50Speaker 15

Councilmember Albee. Councilmember Kermiting.

2:34:53Speaker 15

Councilmember James.

2:34:55Speaker 15

Councilmember Jeffries. Yes. Councilmember Johnson. Yes. Vice Mayor Kearney.

2:35:01Speaker 15

Councilmember Nolan.

2:35:03Speaker 15

Councilmember Owens. Yes. Councilmember Walsh.

2:35:07Speaker 27

Mr. Johnson, would you like to be recorded as a yes for items 52 and 53? Yes, thank you, sir. Absolutely. Vice Mayor.

2:35:14 – 2:36:14Speaker 8

Thank you. I think everyone knows Betty Jean Daniels Roseman. She was born in Magnolia, Mississippi, grew up in New Orleans, Louisiana, and she became one of the first black students to attend Louisiana State University in New Orleans. She became a Freedom Rider where she traveled throughout the Deep South to continue breaking racial barriers. I think most people know her story. She went down with the Freedom Riders. Her bus was attacked by the KKK. She had to hide in a phone booth. A bus driver came along and saved her life, and she continued her fight for social justice after she moved to Cincinnati. She spent decades of service to St. Vincent de Paul until the age of 80. She was honored by Oprah Winfrey on the Oprah Winfrey Show. She's been inducted into the Ohio Civil Rights Hall of Fame, and the College Hill Community Council has approved the street naming.

2:36:16Speaker 27

Further comments? Roll call and passage, please.

2:36:19Speaker 15

Council Member Albee. Council Member Kramerding.

2:36:22Speaker 15

Council Member James.

2:36:24Speaker 15

Council Member Jeffries.

2:36:25Speaker 15

Council Member Johnson.

2:36:27Speaker 15

Vice Mayor Kearney.

2:36:29Speaker 15

Council Member Nolan. Yes. Council Member Owens.

2:36:32Speaker 15

Council Member Walsh.

2:36:32Speaker 27

Yes. Roll call on emergency.

2:36:35Speaker 15

Council Member Albee. Council Member Kramerding.

2:36:38Speaker 15

Council Member James.

2:36:39Speaker 15

Council Member Jeffries.

2:36:41Speaker 15

Council Member Johnson.

2:36:43Speaker 15

Vice Mayor Kearney. Yes. Council Member Nolan. Yes. Council Member Owens. Yes. Council Member Walsh.

2:36:48Speaker 27

Yes. Item 55, first reading, please.

2:36:53Speaker 15

An emergency ordinance declaring that Clifton Avenue at Spring Grove Avenue and the Spring Grove Village neighborhood shall hereby receive the honorary secondary name of Kathy B. Bailey Way.

2:37:02Speaker 27

Roll call on suspension. Excuse me, roll call on suspension.

2:37:06Speaker 15

Councilmember Albee? Councilmember Kermiting?

2:37:09Speaker 15

Councilmember James?

2:37:11Speaker 15

Councilmember Jeffries? Yes. Councilmember Johnson?

2:37:14Speaker 15

Vice Mayor Kearney?

2:37:16Speaker 15

Councilmember Nolan?

2:37:18Speaker 15

Councilmember Owens? Yes.

2:37:19Speaker 8

Councilmember Walsh?

2:37:21Speaker 27

Yes. Vice Mayor.

2:37:23 – 2:40:37Speaker 8

Thank you. I am really excited to read about this, and I know that Assistant City Manager Kathy Bailey is probably about ready to kill us all at this point, but we are going to go through with this. So this honorary street naming was requested by our Greater Cincinnati Water Works director, Andrea Yang. It's a street in Spring Grove Village, because that's where the Water Works headquarters sits. and the name will be Kathy B. Bailey Way in honor of Kathy Bernardino Bailey. As you know, she currently serves as interim assistant city manager for the city of Cincinnati, and she is the immediate past executive director of Greater Cincinnati Water Works. Ms. Bailey earned a bachelor of science degree in chemistry from the University of Cincinnati, and after conducting water research for the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, She began her career with the Greater Cincinnati Water Works in 1992 as a chemist. She advanced through numerous leadership roles before being appointed executive director in September 2015. As executive director, Ms. Bailey became the first woman and the first African American to lead the independent water utility in its more than 209-year history. and she led approximately 600 employees responsible for providing drinking water and storm water services to more than 1.2 million customers throughout the greater Cincinnati region. And she was widely known throughout the water industry as the First Lady of Water, FLOW, F-L-O-W. She earned national recognition for her leadership of Cincinnati's award-winning lead service replacement program, helping build support for a cost-sharing approach that evolved into a no-cost replacement program for customers and contributing to the replacement of more than 10,000 lead service lines from an initial inventory exceeding 40,000. And the city's lead service line replacement program became a national model. And as you know, in 2022, the US EPA selected Ms. Bailey for a temporary assignment as Senior Advisor to help create the Lead Service Line Accelerator Program, which was an initiative that initially supported 40 communities in developing lead replacement strategies and later expanded nationwide. And throughout her leadership at GCWW, Ms. Bailey championed customer-focused initiatives, including assistance programs for residents facing financial hardship following the COVID-19 pandemic, while also advancing strategic planning, workforce diversity, employee and community engagement, continuous improvement and utility leadership. Now, let me say there are two, there are three pages left. And so at the actual street naming, we will read all of it. How about that?

2:40:39Speaker 27

Okay, Bernardino. I don't know about that middle name. Further comments on this? Seeing none, roll call on passage.

2:40:48Speaker 15

Councilmember Albee. Councilmember Kramerding. Yes. Councilmember James.

2:40:52Speaker 15

Councilmember Jeffries.

2:40:54Speaker 15

Councilmember Johnson. Yes. Vice Mayor Kearney. Yes. Councilmember Nolan.

2:40:59Speaker 15

Councilmember Owens. Yes. Councilmember Walsh.

2:41:02Speaker 27

Yes. Roll call on emergency.

2:41:03Speaker 15

Councilmember Albee. Councilmember Kramerding.

2:41:06Speaker 15

Councilmember James. Yes. Councilmember Jeffries.

2:41:10Speaker 15

Councilmember Johnson.

2:41:11Speaker 15

Vice Mayor Kearney. Yes. Councilmember Nolan.

2:41:14Speaker 15

Councilmember Owens. Yes. Councilmember Walsh.

2:41:16Speaker 27

Yes. And finally, item 56, first reading.

2:41:21Speaker 15

An emergency ordinance approving and authorizing the city manager to execute a job creation tax credit agreement with VGP Holdings LLC doing business as Valvoline Global Operations.

2:41:29Speaker 27

Roll call on suspension.

2:41:30Speaker 15

Councilmember Albee. Yes. Councilmember Kramerding.

2:41:34Speaker 15

Councilmember James. Yes. Councilmember Jeffries. Yes. Councilmember Johnson. Yes. Vice Mayor Kearney. Yes. Councilmember Nolan? Yes. Councilmember Owens? Yes. Councilmember Walsh?

2:41:43Speaker 27

Yes. This is a big deal. Mr. Jeffries, tell us about it.

2:41:46 – 2:42:33Speaker 23

Yeah, Mr. Mayor, I'm sure you'll have stuff to add, but I want to first of all congratulate the administration and the mayor on working on this. This is a jobs tax credit for Valvoline Global to move to their headquarters to downtown Cincinnati. It's a big deal. Big employer, I mean, there are 54 jobs, but they already have significant footprint in the Cincinnati area, especially in and around just west of downtown. But it's a vote of confidence, vote of confidence in the city of Cincinnati, vote of confidence in our downtown to have a global Fortune 500 company say they want to locate here in downtown Cincinnati. So congratulations to all those involved, the Office of Strategic Growth, the administration, the mayor, I know, heavily involved. uh, in this, uh, and, uh, it's exciting.

2:42:34 – 2:43:19Speaker 16

Thank you. Further comments? Mr. James. Yes, just congratulations to the administration on, on courting this type of economic growth and love to our communities here. Um, this, uh, to pile on top of what Councilmember Jeffery said, um, this is 54 jobs and, and millions in income tax revenue. So these are good jobs. Um, so thank you to the Department of Strategic Growth. Thank you to Brandon Rudd. Um, thank you to, to the administration. But I also wanted to call out, um, one of our public employees that doesn't often get the limelight here. The project manager of the project was Justin Halter, who is the Senior Development Officer of Job Creation and Retention. This is one of the folks directly responsible for working the deal here, so fantastic work. Our city is better for this change, so thank you to everyone involved.

2:43:20Speaker 27

Thank you. Further comments? Roll call and passage, please.

2:43:24Speaker 15

Councilmember Albee. Councilmember Kramerding.

2:43:27Speaker 15

Councilmember James.

2:43:29Speaker 15

Councilmember Jeffries. Yes. Councilmember Johnson. Yes. Vice Mayor Kearney. Yes. Councilmember Nolan. Yes. Councilmember Owens. Yes. Councilmember Walsh.

2:43:37Speaker 27

Yes. An emergency.

2:43:39 – 2:43:50Speaker 15

Councilmember Albee. Councilmember Kramerding. Yes. Councilmember James. Yes. Councilmember Jeffries. Yes. Councilmember Johnson. Vice Mayor Kearney. Yes. Councilmember Nolan. Yes. Councilmember Owens. Yes. Councilmember Walsh.

2:43:50 – 2:45:23Speaker 27

Yes. That concludes the business portion of our agenda. First things first, Oktoberfest is this weekend celebrating 50 years. So I'm sure it's going to be a special one. It runs from Thursday evening through Sunday at Sawyer Point in Yeatmans Cove. I hope you all have a chance to visit over the weekend. Additionally, just a quick shout out to all the city employees that helped organize this week's Build Ready Awards and really the entire project. Several of the council members were there. with us that night, but it was so joyous. It was so wonderful to see so many young folks participating in the program and really optimistic about our housing future and wanting to be a part of it. It's really a big deal. Creating pre-approved designs for middle housing is our attempt to go further than just reforming the rules. We're making the process to build these types of houses Simpler, less risky, and importantly, we're doing so based on the input of the communities that will see them. We do not know of another city doing this right now, so to our Planning and Engagement Department, the City Manager's Office, OSG, BNI, the Department of Economic Inclusion and Procurement, the Law Department, the innovation team thank you and congratulations with these winning designs we are now able to move forward on the next phase which is creating our formal pre-approved plans and very excitingly getting two example projects built on city land congratulations to everyone city manager long any announcements yes mayor i have two um i just want to give an update um this was something that was sent on our sensei alert regarding the trash

2:45:24 – 2:46:21Speaker 5

Um, if you have not, uh, registered for since the alert, these are, uh, that is a great opportunity for you to stay engaged on what is going on with the city. Um, but to do to staff staffing challenges last week, some trash collection routes were missed. City administration is aware and has been working with the unions to address this. But if your household was missed, please place your card at the curb on your next scheduled collection date. All trash will be collected, including bag trash that does not fit within the cart. We apologize for the inconvenience, and thank you for your patience. Also, last weekend, we had a great conference, more to do. It was some amazing discussions. There was many city employees that actually participated, in addition to external people that came in to educate our great community. Thank you, CBUF. Thank you, Iris Rowley. Thank you, all of the sponsors that assisted. It was a great time. That's it.

2:46:22Speaker 27

Thank you. Council members? Vice Mayor?

2:46:24 – 2:47:20Speaker 8

I just want to chime in on Build Ready. That was amazing. It was so much fun. What, 92 entries I think we had from not just across the country, but all across the world. I mean, really fantastic. So now we have these two-family, three-family, and four to five-family plans that are ready, and we're going to get to see two of them done. So I just think that's wonderful. Okay, I really wanted to introduce our office's new Portman Fellow, Jimmy Voiland. Jimmy, stand up, take a bow. He's a Portman Fellow. He's a junior at the University of Cincinnati. So thank you so much for coming. We welcome him, and so hopefully you'll all get to know him. He'll be here until about mid-December, so every Monday and Wednesday. So please stop in the office. He'll be coming by to meet all of you. So, all right, thank you.

2:47:21Speaker 27

Announcements on this side? President Johnson and then Mr. James.

2:47:25 – 2:48:45Speaker 34

Thank you, Mr. Mayor. Let me echo what the city manager's already talked about. Amazing, great. 25 years of the collaborative agreement last week. I salute Mrs. Rowley for her hard work and her dedication. A lot of great information. Cincinnati, I do not think we understand what we did here in Cincinnati 25 years ago in separating ourselves from the rest of the nation, to be quite honest, when it comes to police community relations. and the collaboration of making sure that the community has say so on how they're policed. So to all those that were there 25 years ago, myself included, I'm telling my age and the Black United Front, Kenny Lawson, to be quite honest, Charlie Lucan, Chief Stryker, Keith Fangman, Don Hart, there was a lot of difficult, there was a very difficult time, but it was well worth it. And Cincinnati, we need to take a bow because we have maintained and kept up with what was the right way to do policing in this city. Thank you, Mr. Mayor.

2:48:45Speaker 16

Absolutely. Thank you.

2:48:48 – 2:49:25Speaker 16

Absolutely. A few exciting events this weekend. One, My Bengals are playing Sunday at 1 in Houston, Texas, so please make a point to watch here. We're looking for a very, very, very strong season this year, so I'm very excited. I will also say that a couple of community events this weekend. There's a Pike Park Pitch Inn, which is an event serving food that's hosted by the RNA. They are looking for volunteers this weekend, so please, if you're interested, stop by. We also have the Roselawn Arts and Wellness Festival happening this Saturday. from 12 to 4. I know we'll be stopping by. So if you have time on Saturday, please make a point to stop by.

2:49:26Speaker 27

Thank you. Other announcements? Seeing none, meeting is adjourned.

This transcript was automatically generated from the official public meeting video and is presented unedited. It reflects remarks made on the public record by elected officials, staff, and public commenters. Transcript accuracy may vary; view the original recording for reference.