City Council - Regular Meeting

Tuesday, June 9, 2026

The Chino City Council held a study session to review an update to the Development Impact Fee (DIF) Nexus Study. Key discussions included a proposed shift from per-unit to square-footage-based residential fees, the elimination of the Congestion Management Plan fee, and significant unfunded infrastructure projects like the Pine Avenue connector. The council provided feedback to staff ahead of the public review period and a public hearing in July.

About this meeting

Government Body
City Council
Meeting Type
City Council
Location
Chino, CA
Meeting Date
June 9, 2026

Transcript

222 sections

0:04 – 1:35Speaker 3

You know, there's smoothie bars everywhere, but do they truly, you know, care about the ingredients? What's in it? Are they organic? And so really, I don't think there's anywhere here in the area that really brings that to the community. So that's truly what sets us apart. And the aesthetic, of course. Sana in Arabic means brilliant praise, and in Spanish it means healthy or healing, and mana is the bread that God made rain, the nourishment, God's nourishment. And so altogether it means praise God's healing nourishment, which is really just taking it back to the root of how he intended us to eat, not the processed foods, really just nurture our bodies with whole food ingredients. And then really the intention behind Sanamana, there's such a bigger picture with the community and how we want to grow. This is our first location, and we have exceeded what our expectation was within the community, and so it's so beautiful to see, yeah. Stay rooted in faith. Stay rooted in your beliefs. And when it gets tough, keep going because there was tons of times where we wanted to give up. But just stay true to your calling and what you believe in your vision and you'll succeed.

1:51 – 3:41Speaker 12

Hello, I'm Chino Mary Unishiloa. Summer is here and as temperatures rise, Chino has plenty of cool things to do all season long. I'm excited to invite you to our summertime events, which are perfect for the entire family. First, mark your calendars for Saturday, June 6th from 10 a.m. to 2 p.m. at Stuby Family Park. We're hosting our first ever Chino in Action event. it's a great opportunity to meet our city staff enjoy a free barbecue and see our brand new police helicopter up close next we're bringing back our chino summer nights movie series happening every friday from june 12th to july 31st except for june 26th this year we're adding a special twist half of our summer movies will take place at the newly opened studio family park in the preserve. That's right, we're giving more Chino residents the opportunity to enjoy our movie nights closer to home. Be sure to bring your blankets, snacks, and lawn chairs and enjoy a beautiful night under the stars watching exciting movies the whole family will love. If live music is more your style, I encourage you to join us for our summer concerts on the lawn presented by the Chino Kiwanis Club. We have a fantastic lineup of bands performing every Thursday from June 12th to July 25th, except July 3rd. It promises to be a toe-tapping good time. And be sure to join us as we light up the Chino night sky during our annual two-day fireworks spectacular on June 26th and 27th at Iola Park. For more information on all our exciting events happening all summer long, visit cityofchino.org forward slash events. With all these events and amenities, Chino is the place to be this summer.

3:56 – 5:23Speaker 24

At Chino's 2026 State of the City, something unexpected happened. A surprise appearance from Oral Hirschheiser delivering big news for Chino. It was a night that brought the community together as the City of Chino welcomed residents, businesses, and community leaders for its annual State of the City presented in partnership with the Chino Valley Chamber of Commerce. Mayor Eunice Ulloa highlighted the progress shaping Chino today while sharing a look at what's ahead, all centered around this year's theme, Always Home. From continued investments in infrastructure and public safety to a growing business community, the momentum is clear. The evening also honored those making a difference, including Business of the Year recipients Royalty Cakes and B&B Lock and Security, and Spirit of Achievement honorees Dale and Sandra Subright, whose impact spans decades. The Chino Valley Chamber of Commerce also highlighted the continued growth of Chino's business community and the opportunities ahead. And then a surprise appearance from none other than Dodger legend Earl Hershiser interrupted the mayor's speech to formally announce his partnership with Chino's legacy business, M.K. Smith's Chevrolet, to rename the dealership Earl Hershiser's Chevrolet. A moment that captured the energy of a city on the rise while staying rooted in what matters most. This is Chino. Always home. Watch the full state of the city at cityofchino.org forward slash SOTC.

5:26 – 6:28Speaker 12

because we're brewing up business. Chino is absolutely a phenomenal place to be. Multi-generational city. We've been here over a hundred years and very business friendly. You're gonna love Chino. As far as businesses are concerned, I personally want to see something for everyone. I want our kids to be able to stay in town, have entertainment places to go. I also want all kinds of entertainment for every age group. We need to stay here, we work here, we live here, and we play here. So I'm looking for businesses that are going to fill any void that we have.

6:35Speaker 1

So welcome to the Business Roundtable. This is the Broker's Edition.

7:02 – 7:30Speaker 12

I was first elected in 1984. Chino used to be very, very heavily agricultural, and over time we have evolved into something for everyone when it comes to housing stock, which is wonderful, and also businesses. We're growing by leaps and bounds. Very, very proud of our community. Multi-generational, so we have grandparents, parents, kids. So Chino's a wonderful place to be, and I'm very, very proud to represent it.

7:42 – 8:11Speaker 19

Hey there, I'm Samantha. I'm the community engagement manager here at the Animal Resource Center of the Inland Empire. We're the new animal services agency for this region. We serve Ontario, Montclair, Chino, and the unincorporated areas of West San Bernardino County. We provide all animal services for this area, things like pet licensing, microchipping your pets, supporting the community when they find stray animals, adoptions, foster opportunities. We also have volunteer opportunities. Come on down, come meet some of our very cute animals.

8:19 – 10:18Speaker 5

Community support since we opened was pretty good, you know, very incredibly supportive. What I understand from the city part, the mayor and all the people around the city was very helpful since we started operation of construction and then, you know, fully operational opening in December 2023. Our business sets apart, I would say, being a Marriott hotel, we more focus on service as well as local community, what we support, and more hospitality, I would say. So it's not only just a basic room and, you know, guests can come and sleep, but we focus as a whole hospitality, more warmth and welcoming. That's what our goal normally we follow. Business grown every year pretty much. I would say since opening December 6th, 2023, right? Now we are at about one and a half year plus, but every year we see significant growth. This year is much more, I would say 10 to 20% more than what we were in the first year. and surrounding area what we see a lot of opportunity still considering our location and one of the biggest location i would say about the baps swaminarayan temple that helps a lot a lot of weddings and a lot of events happening there guests do come and stay here besides that we do get a lot of teams that give us a good growth opportunity and we are still seeing a lot of opportunity around the businesses in the area which we are trying to explore too

11:19 – 12:29Speaker 24

On April 9th, 2026, the City of Chino, in partnership with Adrian's World, hosted an event at the Chino Police Department called Safe and Sound. This inclusive event is for the neurodivergent community to interact with first responders of the Chino Police Department, Chino Hills Sheriff's Department, and the Chino Valley Fire District. Various vendors like the Autism Society Inland Empire and the Special Olympics of Southern California were present, giving out information as well as special needs coffee with their unique brand of drinks. Public safety vehicles like a fire engine and bear cap were on display for exploration and photo ops. There were also demonstrations including the Blue Envelope program, which helps police officers identify and interact with a person with special needs. The Chino Valley Fire District showed off their defibrillator and Chino PD focused on a civil interaction between officers and pedestrians. Safe and Sound is another event bringing inclusivity to residents of all abilities while making it fun to interact with our first responders. Thank you to our sponsors for this event. For more information, please visit www.cityofchino.org

12:38 – 15:22Speaker 8

Well, interestingly, I opened up the very first LA Fitness. That was the very first ground-up they'd ever built here in Chino in December of 96'. and I just had become a new yoga teacher and decided I wanted to open up my own studio and Fit Body was nice enough to let me sublease space from them and it grew from there. About 11 years ago we opened up the space you see here behind me and this weekend we celebrate our 14th year anniversary and this just has become my home community. Most of our advertising is simply word of mouth. And so the fact that people continue to tell their friends to come here is something that we're eternally grateful for beyond words. Not only do we have yoga, but we have heated kettlebell classes where people do barefoot kettlebell to good music in hour-long heated room. And we have ice bath classes in the backyard where people come together and get into the ice. We have sauna and lockers and showers. But I think really what sets us apart more than anything is this vein of mindfulness that we try to thread throughout our offering. To go from a small boot camp spot, subleasing behind Sprouts to this large 4,000 square foot space with lockers and showers and two big yoga rooms is beyond our original vision and literally a dream come true. We're just super grateful that the community continues to show up for us. As long as they do, we're so excited about continuing to show up for them. Continue to persevere. Grit, work ethic is something that goes a long way when you own your own business. We're just super grateful to be here. So I would say more than anything, just the sense of humility that the challenges have brought created this grit and gratitude for what it is we do.

15:29 – 15:58Speaker 18

President of the City of Chino, do you recycle your bottles and cans? Here's something you should know. Bottles and cans are good for the environment when recycled properly. The City of Chino encourages its residents to recycle their bottles and cans on trash day in their curbside recycling cart or by taking them to a certified collection center for a cash refund. Do your part. Keep Chino clean and recycle your bottles and cans. For more information, Visit the City of Chino's website under recycling or call 909-334-3289. This program is being brought to you by the City of Chino.

16:16Speaker 2

Do your part. Keep the city of Chino clean and recycle your bottles and cans. Visit the website of the city of Chino in the recycling section or call 909-334-3289.

17:05 – 17:57Speaker 9

Chino has both modern side and countryside charm. My husband, he likes the countryside. I like the modern side. He loved eating here. He'll even bring his clients here. And when it was up for sale, he took the opportunity and we bought it. And we're very happy because we get to eat food here more often for free and I don't have to cook as much. First, I really need to thank Larry and Shelly. They're the ones who started the Avocado House, and they're the ones who made this a Chino favorite. When we took over, we kept the same recipes. We just upgraded ingredients, switched oil to the avocado oil, and added new menu items. The support from community is awesome. Police officers, city staff, residents from Chino and all around cities, they come and support us, so we're very grateful.

18:05Speaker 21

What sets your business apart?

18:06 – 19:43Speaker 9

First, food. It's homemade food made with love, like grandma would. And that was Shelly's motto, and we really like it, and we're keeping it, too. And second is the high-quality ingredient, especially the avocado oil. It costs us $3,000 more per month to use avocado oil instead of canola oil. But we made the decision to do it because we care for the health of our customers, our employees who eat our food every day, and for our family. If you want cozy countryside warm feeling, you could eat inside the restaurant. And if you want to like a more modern feel, you can eat at a veranda and the backyard, which is everyone's favorite. It's like having a picnic. You can relax and enjoy, you know, nice Southern California weather. We're very grateful as we continue to grow. So we plan to increase ours and we're going to open for dinner. So, you know, people can now enjoy Avocado House all day long. We started a coffee shop called Rabbit and Bean in La Habra and it's really doing well. So we want to open a second coffee shop here. So, you know, customers enjoy specialty coffee and matcha. We're very excited. First, you know, don't focus on money, profit, but just focus on giving joy and happiness to your customers and employees. Always serve high quality food that you would serve your own family. People will notice and they'll come back and also take good care of your employees because they'll take good care of your customers.

19:56 – 20:58Speaker 24

On January 31st, the city of Chino hosted the first annual Lunar New Year's event, an event that celebrated culture, heritage, and new beginnings in the city of Chino. Senryu Taiko and the Laomao Club Lion Dance began the festivities with a fascinating performance as part of the opening ceremony. After words from Councilmember Mark Lucio, the festive confetti popped as the celebration began. Performances by Shaolin Kung Fu showed off incredible martial arts moves with weapons. and the Chino Valley Chinese Alliance Children's Choir brought smiles to the crowd's faces with singing and dancing. Vendors were all around the Chino Civic Center with festive merchandise, art, and a fun zone, making every moment fun and exciting. Food vendors were plenty, giving residents a chance to try out various tasty treats. Lunar New Year is a time for family, gratitude, and connection, and an event like this brings Chino together, honoring diversity while celebrating what unites us. For more information on this and any upcoming events, please visit www.cityofchino.org.

21:49 – 23:20Speaker 6

So my dad came like 45 years ago in the city of Chino. He thought the city of Chino was a good opportunity to open a new business and he was right. First of all, I want to thank the community of the city of Chino because all these years they support us and they love us and I want to say a big thank you to them. quality, the good quality for the products, the good customer service and I think they love what we're doing for that. So we opened the first location four years ago and now we moved like two years ago over here with a bigger, nicer location and we drive through. Because it was the first project for us, it was a little bit hard at the beginning. Thank God, we make it. With the help of the city of Chino, the help of the people of Chino, we are here now to serve them.

25:09 – 27:42Speaker 23

We knew Chino was in demand for more restaurants, but we also knew that the location that we were gonna be going into, that there was a lot of growth and there was gonna be a lot that was gonna come in. But we also knew it was gonna take time to get there, but still just with it, like how it is right now, we're still doing really good. Like we knew coming into it, we were gonna be busy right off the bat. It seemed like a great place for the second location for us to grow and, you know, make our name bigger. The customers, you know, have been awesome with us. You know, we've been busy. It's been a year and we've been busier and busier every day. You know, we've sponsored a lot of the youth baseball teams, football teams. We know customers on a first-name basis and, you know, we have a good set of regulars. So, you know, the community has supported us tremendously and they're keeping this place open. They're keeping it going. We always knew that this is what we wanted to do. Both the owners always wanted to own their own restaurants. I knew them closely. I wanted to own restaurants as well. And that was just the goal behind it was, hey, let's turn Kenwoods into a household name. We love when the kids that come in here, hey, we want to go to Kenwoods. That was the goal to be the next big thing. I would say what sets us apart, one thing is we are a scratch kitchen, so everything is recipe-based, everything is made fresh, everything's made fresh daily. One thing that we really preach is giving the best service possible. Again, it all falls back to, you know, you can have great food, which we do, and a great atmosphere, but at the end of the day, the customers are coming back for the experience, for the service part. And we try to teach our staff every day, hey, make each visit count. Put a smile on someone's face. Get to know them on a personal level. When that customer comes in, we want them saying, hey, is so-and-so working today? You know, we have a lot of good things going on, live music, we do a taco special, we have a brunch, we have a happy hour from 3 to 6, Monday through Friday. So as, you know, the community, you know, hears about us and finds these things out, we just continue to grow. My name is Matt Mraz. I am the general manager of Kenwood's Kitchen and Tap in Chino, located in the Preserve Shopping Center off of Chino and Main.

28:53 – 31:24Speaker 3

Chino is an absolute beautiful community. My husband and I are from Los Angeles. And so we were trying to get closer to family. We have a little toddler and in LA there's wellness bars on every corner. Whereas here we kind of noticed that there was missing link. You know, there's lots of big corporations and franchises. And so we decided this would be the absolute perfect location to bring a little bit of that here. The community in Chino has been the most important part, I think, of growing this business. Word of mouth in this community is so major. Everybody knows somebody and it's such a tight knit community, especially in the wellness world. And so it's just been incredible to, you know, grow with the community. You know, there's smoothie bars everywhere, but do they truly, you know, care about the ingredients? What's in it? Are they organic? And so really, I don't think there's anywhere here in the area that really brings that to the community. So that's truly what sets us apart. And the aesthetic, of course. Sana in Arabic means brilliant praise, and in Spanish it means healthy or healing, and mana is the bread that God made rain, the nourishment, God's nourishment. And so altogether it means praise God's healing nourishment, which is really just taking it back to the root of how he intended us to eat, not the processed foods, really just nurture our bodies with whole food ingredients. And then really the intention behind Sonamana, there's such a bigger picture with the community and how we want to grow. This is our first location and we have exceeded what our expectation was within the community and so it's so beautiful to see. Stay rooted in faith. Stay rooted in your beliefs. And when it gets tough, keep going because there was tons of times where we wanted to give up. But just stay true to, you know, your calling and what you believe in your vision and you'll succeed.

31:40 – 33:30Speaker 12

Hello, I'm Chino Mariunishiloa. Summer is here and as temperatures rise, Chino has plenty of cool things to do all season long. I'm excited to invite you to our summertime events, which are perfect for the entire family. First, mark your calendars for Saturday, June 6th from 10 a.m. to 2 p.m. at Steubee Family Park. We're hosting our first ever Chino in Action event. It's a great opportunity to meet our city staff, enjoy a free barbecue, and see our brand new police helicopter up close. Next, we're bringing back our Chino Summer Nights movie series, happening every Friday from June 12th to July 31st, except for June 26th. This year, we're adding a special twist. Half of our summer movies will take place at the newly opened Stubing Family Park in the Preserve. That's right, we're giving more Chino residents the opportunity to enjoy our movie nights closer to home. Be sure to bring your blankets, snacks and lawn chairs and enjoy a beautiful night under the stars watching exciting movies the whole family will love. If live music is more your style, I encourage you to join us for our summer concerts on the lawn presented by the Chino Kiwanis Club. We have a fantastic lineup of bands performing every Thursday from June 12th to July 25th, except July 3rd. it promises to be a toe-tapping good time and be sure to join us as we light up the chino night sky during our annual two-day fireworks spectacular on june 26th and 27th at iola park for more information on all our exciting events happening all summer long visit cityofchino.org forward slash events with all these events and amenities chino is the place to be this summer

33:45 – 35:12Speaker 24

At Chino's 2026 State of the City, something unexpected happened. A surprise appearance from Oral Hirschheiser delivering big news for Chino. It was a night that brought the community together as the city of Chino welcomed residents, businesses, and community leaders for its annual State of the City presented in partnership with the Chino Valley Chamber of Commerce. Mayor Eunice Ulloa highlighted the progress shaping Chino today while sharing a look at what's ahead, all centered around this year's theme, Always Home. From continued investment in infrastructure and public safety to a growing business community, the momentum is clear. The evening also honored those making a difference, including Business of the Year recipients, Royalty Cakes and B&B Lock and Security, and Spirit of Achievement honorees Dale and Sandra Subright, whose impact spans decades. The Chino Valley Chamber of Commerce also highlighted the continued growth of Chino's business community and the opportunities ahead. And then a surprise appearance from none other than Dodger legend Earl Hershiser interrupted the mayor's speech to formally announce his partnership with Chino's legacy business, M.K. Smith's Chevrolet, to rename the dealership Earl Hershiser's Chevrolet. A moment that captured the energy of a city on the rise while staying rooted in what matters most. This is Chino. Always home. Watch the full state of the city at cityofchino.org forward slash SOTC.

35:15 – 36:17Speaker 12

here because we're brewing up business chino is absolutely a phenomenal place to be multi-generational city we've been here over a hundred years and very business friendly you're gonna love chino As far as businesses are concerned, I personally want to see something for everyone. I want our kids to be able to stay in town, have entertainment places to go. I also want all kinds of entertainment for every age group. We need to stay here, we work here, we live here, and we play here. So I'm looking for businesses that are going to fill any void that we have.

36:24Speaker 1

So welcome to the Business Roundtable. This is the Broker's Edition.

36:51 – 37:19Speaker 12

I was first elected in 1984. Chino used to be very, very heavily agricultural, and over time we have evolved into something for everyone when it comes to housing stock, which is wonderful, and also businesses. We're growing by leaps and bounds. Very, very proud of our community. Multi-generational, so we have grandparents, parents, kids. So Chino's a wonderful place to be, and I'm very, very proud to represent it.

37:31 – 38:00Speaker 19

Hey there, I'm Samantha. I'm the community engagement manager here at the Animal Resource Center of the Inland Empire. We're the new animal services agency for this region. We serve Ontario, Montclair, Chino, and the unincorporated areas of West San Bernardino County. We provide all animal services for this area, things like pet licensing, microchipping your pets, supporting the community when they find stray animals, adoptions, foster opportunities. We also have volunteer opportunities. Come on down, come meet some of our very cute animals.

38:08 – 40:07Speaker 5

Community support since we opened was pretty good, very incredibly supportive. What I understand from the city part, the mayor and all the people around the city was very helpful since we started operation of construction and then fully operational opening in December 2023. Our business sets apart, I would say, being a Marriott hotel, we more focus on service as well as local community, what we support, and more hospitality, I would say. So it's not only just a basic room and, you know, guests can come and sleep, but we focus as a whole hospitality, more warmth and welcoming. That's what our goal normally we follow. business grown every year pretty much I would say since opening December 6 2023 right now we are at about one and a half year plus but every year we see significant growth this year is much more I would say 10 to 20 percent more than what we were in the first year and surrounding area what we see a lot of opportunity still considering our location and one of the biggest location i would say about the BAPS Swaminarayan temple that helps a lot a lot of weddings and a lot of Events happening there, guests do come and stay here. Besides that we do get a lot of teams. That gives us a good growth opportunity and we are still seeing a lot of opportunity around the businesses in the area which we are trying to explore too.

41:08 – 42:18Speaker 24

On April 9, 2026, the City of Chino, in partnership with Adrian's World, hosted an event at the Chino Police Department called Safe and Sound. This inclusive event is for the neurodivergent community to interact with first responders of the Chino Police Department, Chino Hills Sheriff's Department, and the Chino Valley Fire District. Various vendors like the Autism Society Inland Empire and the Special Olympics of Southern California were present, giving out information as well as special needs coffee with their unique brand of drinks. Public safety vehicles like a fire engine and bear cap were on display for exploration and photo ops. There were also demonstrations including the Blue Envelope program, which helps police officers identify and interact with a person with special needs. The Chino Valley Fire District showed off their defibrillator and Chino PD focused on a civil interaction between officers and pedestrians. Safe and Sound is another event bringing inclusivity to residents of all abilities while making it fun to interact with our first responders. Thank you to our sponsors for this event. For more information, please visit www.cityofchino.org

42:27 – 45:12Speaker 8

Well, interestingly, I opened up the very first LA Fitness that was the very first ground up they'd ever built here in Chino in December of 96. and I just had become a new yoga teacher and decided I wanted to open up my own studio and Fit Body was nice enough to let me sublease space from them and it grew from there. About 11 years ago we opened up the space you see here behind me and this weekend we celebrate our 14th year anniversary and this just has become my home community. Most of our advertising is simply word of mouth. And so the fact that people continue to tell their friends to come here is something that we're eternally grateful for beyond words. Not only do we have yoga, but we have heated kettlebell classes where people do barefoot kettlebell to good music in hour-long heated room. And we have ice bath classes in the backyard where people come together and get into the ice. We have sauna and lockers and showers. But I think really what sets us apart more than anything is this vein of mindfulness that we try to thread throughout our offering. You know, to go from a small boot camp spot, subleasing behind Sprouts to this large 4,000 square foot space with lockers and showers and two big yoga rooms is beyond our original vision and literally a dream come true. We're just super grateful that the community continues to show up for us. As long as they do, we're so excited about continuing to show up for them. Continue to persevere. Grit, work ethic is something that goes a long way when you own your own business. We're just super grateful to be here. So I would say more than anything, just the sense of humility that the challenges have brought created this grit and gratitude for what it is we do.

45:18 – 45:47Speaker 18

resident of the city of chino do you recycle your bottles and cans here's something you should know bottles and cans are good for the environment when recycled properly the city of chino encourages its residents to recycle their bottles and cans on trash day in their curbside recycling cart or by taking them to a certified collection center for a cash refund do your part keep chino clean and recycle your bottles and cans for more information Visit the City of Chino's website under recycling or call 909-334-3289. This program is being brought to you by the City of Chino.

46:05Speaker 2

Haz tu parte. Mantén limpia la ciudad de Chino y recicla tus botellas y latas. Visita el sitio web de la ciudad de Chino en la sección de reciclaje o llama al 9093-3432-89.

46:54 – 47:46Speaker 9

Chino has both modern side and countryside charm. My husband, he likes the countryside. I like the modern side. He loved eating here. He'll even bring his clients here. And when it was up for sale, he took the opportunity and we bought it. And we're very happy because we get to eat food here more often for free and I don't have to cook as much. First, I really need to thank Larry and Shelly. They're the ones who started the Avocado House, and they're the ones who made this a Chino favorite. When we took over, we kept the same recipes. We just upgraded ingredients, switched oil to the avocado oil, and added new menu items. The support from community is awesome. Police officers, city staff, residents from Chino and all around cities, they come and support us, so we're very grateful.

47:54Speaker 21

What sets your business apart?

47:55 – 49:32Speaker 9

First, food. It's homemade food made with love, like grandma would. And that was Shelly's motto, and we really like it, and we're keeping it, too. And second is the high-quality ingredient, especially the avocado oil. It costs us $3,000 more per month to use avocado oil instead of canola oil. But we made the decision to do it because we care for the health of our customers, our employees who eat our food every day, and for our family. If you want cozy countryside warm feeling, you could eat inside the restaurant. And if you want to like a more modern feel, you can eat at a veranda and the backyard, which is everyone's favorite. It's like having a picnic. You can relax and enjoy, you know, nice Southern California weather. We're very grateful as we continue to grow so we plan to increase ours and we're gonna open for dinner so you know people can now enjoy Avocado House all day long. We started a coffee shop called Rabbit and Bean in La Habra and it's really doing well so we want to open a second coffee shop here so you know customers enjoy specialty coffee and matcha. We're very excited. First, you know, don't focus on money, profit, but just focus on giving joy and happiness to your customers and employees. Always serve, you know, high quality food that you would serve your own family. People will notice and they'll come back and also take good care of your employees because they'll take good care of your customers.

49:45 – 50:48Speaker 24

On January 31st, the city of Chino hosted the first annual Lunar New Year's event, an event that celebrated culture, heritage, and new beginnings in the city of Chino. Senryu Taiko and the La'o Matero Club Lion Dance began the festivities with a fascinating performance as part of the opening ceremony. After words from Councilmember Mark Lucio, the festive confetti popped as the celebration began. Performances by Shaolin Kung Fu showed off incredible martial arts moves with weapons, and the Chino Valley Chinese Alliance Children's Choir brought smiles to the crowd's faces with singing and dancing. vendors were all around the Chino Civic Center with festive merchandise, art, and a fun zone, making every moment fun and exciting. Food vendors were plenty, giving residents a chance to try out various tasty treats. Lunar New Year is a time for family, gratitude, and connection, and an event like this brings Chino together, honoring diversity while celebrating what unites us. For more information on this and any upcoming events, please visit www.cityofchino.org forward slash events.

51:36 – 53:09Speaker 6

So my dad came like 45 years ago to the city of Chino. He thought the city of Chino was a good opportunity to open a new business and he was right. First of all, I want to thank the community of the city of Chino because all these years they support us and they love us and I want to say a big thank you to them. Quality, the good quality for the products, the good customer service and I think they love what we're doing for them. So we opened the first location four years ago, and now we moved like two years ago over here, with a bigger, nicer location, and we drive through. Because it was the first project for us, it was a little bit hard at the beginning, thank God we made it. With the help of the city of Chino, the help of the people of Chino, we are here now to serve them.

54:58 – 57:31Speaker 23

We knew Chino was in demand for more restaurants, but we also knew that the location that we were gonna be going into, that there was a lot of growth and there was gonna be a lot that was gonna come in. But we also knew it was gonna take time to get there, but still just with it, like how it is right now, we're still doing really good. Like we knew coming into it, we were gonna be busy right off the bat. It seemed like a great place for the second location for us to grow and, you know, make our name bigger. The customers, you know, have been awesome with us. You know, we've been busy. It's been a year and we've been busier and busier every day. You know, we've sponsored a lot of the youth baseball teams, football teams. We know customers on a first-name basis and, you know, we have a good set of regulars. So, you know, the community has supported us tremendously and they're keeping this place open. They're keeping it going. We always knew that this is what we wanted to do. Both the owners always wanted to own their own restaurants. I knew them closely. I wanted to own restaurants as well. And that was just the goal behind it was, hey, let's turn Kenwoods into a household name. We love when the kids that come in here, hey, we want to go to Kenwoods. That was the goal to be the next big thing. I would say what sets us apart, one thing is we are a scratch kitchen, so everything is recipe-based, everything is made fresh, everything is made fresh daily. One thing that we really preach is giving the best service possible. Again, it all falls back to, you know, you can have great food, which we do, and a great atmosphere, but at the end of the day, the customers are coming back for the experience, for the service part. And we try to teach our staff every day, hey, make each visit count. Put a smile on someone's face. Get to know them on a personal level. When that customer comes in, we want them saying, hey, is so-and-so working today? You know, we have a lot of good things going on, live music, we do a taco special, we have a brunch, we have a happy hour from 3 to 6, Monday through Friday. So as, you know, the community, you know, hears about us and finds these things out, we just continue to grow. My name is Matt Mraz. I am the general manager of Kenwood's Kitchen and Tap in Chino, located in the Preserve Shopping Center off of Chino in Maine.

58:43 – 1:01:13Speaker 3

Chino is an absolute beautiful community. My husband and I are from Los Angeles, and so we were trying to get closer to family. We have a little toddler, and in LA, there's wellness bars on every corner, whereas here, we kind of noticed that there was missing link. There's lots of big corporations and franchises, and so we decided this would be the absolute perfect location to bring a little bit of that here. the community in chino has been the most important part i think of growing this business word of mouth in this community is so major everybody knows somebody and it's such a tight-knit community especially in the wellness world and so it's just been incredible to you know grow with the community You know, there's smoothie bars everywhere, but do they truly, you know, care about the ingredients? What's in it? Are they organic? And so really, I don't think there's anywhere here in the area that really brings that to the community. So that's truly what sets us apart. And the aesthetic, of course. Sana in Arabic means brilliant praise, and in Spanish it means healthy or healing, and mana is the bread that God made rain, the nourishment, God's nourishment. And so altogether it means praise God's healing nourishment, which is really just taking it back to the root of how he intended us to eat, not the processed foods, really just nurture our bodies with whole food ingredients. And then really the intention behind Sonamana, there's such a bigger picture with the community and how we want to grow. This is our first location and we have exceeded what our expectation was within the community. And so it's so beautiful to see. Stay rooted in faith. Stay rooted in your beliefs. And when it gets tough, keep going because there was tons of times where we wanted to give up. But just stay true to your calling and what you believe in your vision and you'll succeed.

1:01:29 – 1:03:19Speaker 12

Hello, I'm Chino Mary Unishiloa. Summer is here and as temperatures rise, Chino has plenty of cool things to do all season long. I'm excited to invite you to our summertime events, which are perfect for the entire family. First, mark your calendars for Saturday, June 6th from 10 a.m. to 2 p.m. at Stuby Family Park. We're hosting our first ever Chino in Action event. it's a great opportunity to meet our city staff enjoy a free barbecue and see our brand new police helicopter up close next we're bringing back our chino summer nights movie series happening every friday from june 12th to july 31st except for june 26th this year we're adding a special twist half of our summer movies will take place at the newly opened stevie family park in the preserve that's right we're giving more chino residents the opportunity to enjoy our movie nights closer to home be sure to bring your blankets snacks and lawn chairs and enjoy a beautiful night under the stars watching exciting movies the whole family will love If live music is more your style, I encourage you to join us for our summer concerts on the lawn presented by the Chino Kiwanis Club. We have a fantastic lineup of bands performing every Thursday from June 12th to July 25th, except July 3rd. It promises to be a toe-tapping good time. And be sure to join us as we light up the Chino night sky during our annual two-day fireworks spectacular on June 26th and 27th at Iola Park. For more information on all our exciting events happening all summer long, visit cityofchino.org forward slash events. With all these events and amenities, Chino is the place to be this summer.

1:03:34 – 1:05:01Speaker 24

At Chino's 2026 State of the City, something unexpected happened. A surprise appearance from Oral Hirshhiser delivering big news for Chino. It was a night that brought the community together as the City of Chino welcomed residents, businesses, and community leaders for its annual State of the City presented in partnership with the Chino Valley Chamber of Commerce. Mayor Eunice Ulloa highlighted the progress shaping Chino today while sharing a look at what's ahead, all centered around this year's theme, Always Home. From continued investments in infrastructure and public safety to a growing business community, the momentum is clear. The evening also honored those making a difference, including Business of the Year recipients, Royalty Cakes and B&B Lock and Security, and Spirit of Achievement honorees Dale and Sandra Subright, whose impact spans decades. The Chino Valley Chamber of Commerce also highlighted the continued growth of Chino's business community and the opportunities ahead. And then a surprise appearance from none other than Dodger legend Earl Hershiser interrupted the mayor's speech to formally announce his partnership with Chino's legacy business, M.K. Smith's Chevrolet, to rename the dealership Earl Hershiser's Chevrolet. A moment that captured the energy of a city on the rise while staying rooted in what matters most. This is Chino. Always home. Watch the full state of the city at cityofchino.org forward slash SOTC.

1:05:04 – 1:06:07Speaker 12

We are here because we're brewing up business. Chino is absolutely a phenomenal place to be. Multi-generational city. We've been here over a hundred years and very business friendly. You're going to love Chino. As far as businesses are concerned, I personally want to see something for everyone. I want our kids to be able to stay in town, have entertainment places to go. I also want all kinds of entertainment for every age group. We need to stay here, we work here, we live here, and we play here. So I'm looking for businesses that are going to fill any void that we have.

1:06:13Speaker 1

So welcome to the Business Roundtable. This is the Broker's Edition.

1:06:40 – 1:07:08Speaker 12

I was first elected in 1984. Chino used to be very, very heavily agricultural, and over time we have evolved into something for everyone when it comes to housing stock, which is wonderful, and also businesses. We're growing by leaps and bounds. Very, very proud of our community. Multi-generational, so we have grandparents, parents, kids. So Chino's a wonderful place to be, and I'm very, very proud to represent it.

1:07:20 – 1:07:49Speaker 19

Hey there, I'm Samantha. I'm the community engagement manager here at the Animal Resource Center of the Inland Empire. We're the new animal services agency for this region. We serve Ontario, Montclair, Chino, and the unincorporated areas of West San Bernardino County. We provide all animal services for this area, things like pet licensing, microchipping your pets, supporting the community when they find stray animals, adoptions, foster opportunities. We also have volunteer opportunities. Come on down, come meet some of our very cute animals.

1:07:57 – 1:09:56Speaker 5

Community support since we opened was pretty good, very incredibly supportive. What I understand from the city part, the mayor and all the people around the city was very helpful since we started operation of construction and then fully operational opening in December 2023. Our business sets apart, I would say, being a Marriott hotel, we more focus on service as well as local community, what we support, and more hospitality, I would say. So it's not only just a basic room and guests can come and sleep, but we focus as a whole hospitality, more warmth and welcoming. That's what our goal normally we follow. business grown every year pretty much I would say since opening December 6 2023 right now we are at about one and a half year plus but every year we see significant growth this year is much more I would say 10 to 20 percent more than what we were in the first year and surrounding area what we see a lot of opportunity still considering our location and one of the biggest location i would say about the baps swaminarayan temple that helps a lot a lot of weddings and a lot of events happening there, guests do come and stay here. Besides that we do get a lot of teams. That gives us a good growth opportunity and we are still seeing a lot of opportunity around the businesses in the area which we are trying to explore too.

1:10:57 – 1:12:07Speaker 24

On April 9th, 2026, the City of Chino, in partnership with Adrian's World, hosted an event at the Chino Police Department called Safe and Sound. This inclusive event is for the neurodivergent community to interact with first responders of the Chino Police Department, Chino Hills Sheriff's Department, and the Chino Valley Fire District. Various vendors like the Autism Society Inland Empire and the Special Olympics of Southern California were present, giving out information as well as special needs coffee with their unique brand of drinks. Public safety vehicles like a fire engine and bear cap were on display for exploration and photo ops. There were also demonstrations including the Blue Envelope Program, which helps police officers identify and interact with a person with special needs. The Chino Valley Fire District showed off their defibrillator and Chino PD focused on a civil interaction between officers and pedestrians. Safe and Sound is another event bringing inclusivity to residents of all abilities while making it fun to interact with our first responders. Thank you to our sponsors for this event. For more information, please visit www.cityofchino.org

1:12:16 – 1:15:01Speaker 8

Well, interestingly, I opened up the very first LA Fitness that was the very first ground up they'd ever built here in Chino in December of 96. and I just had become a new yoga teacher and decided I wanted to open up my own studio and Fit Body was nice enough to let me sublease space from them and it grew from there. About 11 years ago we opened up the space you see here behind me and this weekend we celebrate our 14th year anniversary and this just has become my home community. Most of our advertising is simply word of mouth. And so the fact that people continue to tell their friends to come here is something that we're eternally grateful for beyond words. Not only do we have yoga, but we have heated kettlebell classes where people do barefoot kettlebell to good music in hour-long heated room. And we have ice bath classes in the backyard where people come together and get into the ice. We have sauna and lockers and showers. But I think really what sets us apart more than anything is this vein of mindfulness that we try to thread throughout our offering. To go from a small boot camp spot, subleasing behind Sprouts to this large 4,000 square foot space with lockers and showers and two big yoga rooms is beyond our original vision and literally a dream come true. We're just super grateful that the community continues to show up for us. As long as they do, we're so excited about continuing to show up for them. Continue to persevere. Grit, work ethic is something that goes a long way when you own your own business. We're just super grateful to be here. So I would say more than anything, just the sense of humility that the challenges have brought created this grit and gratitude for what it is we do.

1:15:07 – 1:15:36Speaker 18

President of the City of Chino, do you recycle your bottles and cans? Here's something you should know. Bottles and cans are good for the environment when recycled properly. The City of Chino encourages its residents to recycle their bottles and cans on trash day in their curbside recycling cart or by taking them to a certified collection center for a cash refund. Do your part. Keep Chino clean and recycle your bottles and cans. For more information, visit the City of Chino's website under recycling or call 909-334-3289. This program is being brought to you by the City of Chino.

1:15:54Speaker 2

Do your part. Keep the city of Chino clean and recycle your bottles and cans. Visit the website of the city of Chino in the recycling section or call 909-334-3289.

1:16:43 – 1:17:35Speaker 9

Chino has both modern side and countryside charm. My husband, he likes the countryside. I like the modern side. He loved eating here. He'll even bring his clients here and when it was up for sale, he took the opportunity and we bought it and we're very happy because we get to eat food here more often for free and I don't have to cook as much. First, I really need to thank Larry and Shelly. They're the ones who started the Avocado House, and they're the ones who made this a Chino favorite. When we took over, we kept the same recipes. We just upgraded ingredients, which oil to the avocado oil, and added new menu items. The support from community is awesome. Police officers, city staff, residents from Chino and all around cities, they come and support us, so we're very grateful.

1:17:43Speaker 21

What sets your business apart?

1:17:44 – 1:19:21Speaker 9

First, food. It's homemade food made with love, like grandma would. And that was Shelly's motto, and we really like it, and we're keeping it, too. And second is the high-quality ingredient, especially the avocado oil. It costs us $3,000 more per month to use avocado oil instead of canola oil. But we made the decision to do it because we care for the health of our customers, our employees who eat our food every day, and for our family. If you want cozy countryside warm feeling, you could eat inside the restaurant. And if you want to like a more modern feel, you can eat at a veranda and the backyard, which is everyone's favorite. It's like having a picnic. You can relax and enjoy, you know, nice Southern California weather. We're very grateful as we continue to grow. So we plan to increase ours and we're gonna open for dinner. So, you know, people can now enjoy Avocado House all day long. We started a coffee shop called Rabbit and Bean in La Habra and it's really doing well. So we wanna open a second coffee shop here. So, you know, customers enjoy specialty coffee and matcha. We're very excited. First, you know, don't focus on money, profit, but just focus on giving joy and happiness to your customers and employees. Always serve high quality food that you would serve your own family. People will notice and they'll come back and also take good care of your employees because they'll take good care of your customers.

1:19:34 – 1:20:36Speaker 24

On January 31st, the City of Chino hosted the first annual Lunar New Year's event, an event that celebrated culture, heritage, and new beginnings in the City of Chino. Senryu Taiko and the La'ou Matero Club Lion Dance began the festivities with a fascinating performance as part of the opening ceremony. After words from Councilmember Mark Lucio, the festive confetti popped as the celebration began. Performances by Shaolin Kung Fu showed off incredible martial arts moves with weapons, and the Chino Valley Chinese Alliance Children's Choir brought smiles to the crowd's faces with singing and dancing. Vendors were all around the Chino Civic Center with festive merchandise, art, and a fun zone, making every moment fun and exciting. Food vendors were plenty, giving residents a chance to try out various tasty treats. Lunar New Year is a time for family, gratitude, and connection, and an event like this brings Chino together, honoring diversity while celebrating what unites us. For more information on this and any upcoming events, please visit www.cityofchino.org.

1:21:27 – 1:22:58Speaker 6

So my dad came like 45 years ago to the city of Chino. He thought the city of Chino was a good opportunity to open a new business and he was right. First of all I want to thank the community of the city of Chino because all these years they support us and they love us and I want to say a big thank you to them. Quality, the good quality for the products, the good customer service and I think they love what we're doing for that. So we opened the first location four years ago and now we moved like two years ago over here with a bigger, nicer location and we drive through. Because it was the first project for us, it was a little bit hard at the beginning, thank God we made it. With the help of the city of Chino, the help of the people of Chino, we are here now to serve them.

1:24:47 – 1:27:20Speaker 23

We knew Chino was in demand for more restaurants, but we also knew that the location that we were gonna be going into, that there was a lot of growth and there was gonna be a lot that was gonna come in. But we also knew it was gonna take time to get there, but still just with it, like how it is right now, we're still doing really good. Like we knew coming into it, we were gonna be busy right off the bat. It seemed like a great place for the second location for us to grow and, you know, make our name bigger. The customers, you know, have been awesome with us. You know, we've been busy. It's been a year and we've been busier and busier every day. You know, we've sponsored a lot of the youth baseball teams, football teams. We know customers on a first-name basis and, you know, we have a good set of regulars. So, you know, the community has supported us tremendously and they're keeping this place open. They're keeping it going. We always knew that this is what we wanted to do. Both the owners always wanted to own their own restaurants. I knew them closely. I wanted to own restaurants as well. And that was just the goal behind it was, hey, let's turn Kenwoods into a household name. We love when the kids that come in here, hey, we want to go to Kenwoods. That was the goal to be the next big thing. I would say what sets us apart, one thing is we are a scratch kitchen, so everything is recipe-based, everything is made fresh, everything's made fresh daily. One thing that we really preach is giving the best service possible. Again, it all falls back to, you know, you can have great food, which we do, and a great atmosphere, but at the end of the day, the customers are coming back for the experience, for the service part. And we try to teach our staff every day, hey, make each visit count. Put a smile on someone's face. Get to know them on a personal level. When that customer comes in, we want them saying, hey, is so-and-so working today? You know, we have a lot of good things going on, live music, we do a taco special, we have a brunch, we have a happy hour from 3 to 6, Monday through Friday. So as, you know, the community, you know, hears about us and finds these things out, we just continue to grow. My name is Matt Mraz. I am the general manager of Kenwood's Kitchen and Tap in Chino, located in the Preserve Shopping Center off of Chino and Main.

1:28:32 – 1:31:02Speaker 3

Chino is an absolute beautiful community. My husband and I are from Los Angeles. And so we were trying to get closer to family. We have a little toddler and in LA there's wellness bars on every corner. Whereas here we kind of noticed that there was missing link. You know, there's lots of big corporations and franchises. And so we decided this would be the absolute perfect location to bring a little bit of that here. The community in Chino has been the most important part, I think, of growing this business. Word of mouth in this community is so major. Everybody knows somebody and it's such a tight-knit community, especially in the wellness world. And so it's just been incredible to, you know, grow with the community. You know, there's smoothie bars everywhere, but do they truly, you know, care about the ingredients? What's in it? Are they organic? And so really, I don't think there's anywhere here in the area that really brings that to the community. So that's truly what sets us apart. And the aesthetic, of course. Sana in Arabic means brilliant praise, and in Spanish it means healthy or healing, and mana is the bread that God made rain, the nourishment, God's nourishment. And so altogether it means praise God's healing nourishment, which is really just taking it back to the root of how he intended us to eat, not the processed foods, really just nurture our bodies with whole food ingredients. And then really the intention behind Sanamana, there's such a bigger picture with the community and how we want to grow. This is our first location and we have exceeded what our expectation was within the community. And so it's so beautiful to see. Stay rooted in faith. Stay rooted in your beliefs. And when it gets tough, keep going because there was tons of times where we wanted to give up. But just stay true to, you know, your calling and what you believe in your vision and you'll succeed.

1:31:18 – 1:33:08Speaker 12

Hello, I'm Chino Mary Unishiloa. Summer is here and as temperatures rise, Chino has plenty of cool things to do all season long. I'm excited to invite you to our summertime events, which are perfect for the entire family. First, mark your calendars for Saturday, June 6th from 10 a.m. to 2 p.m. at Stuby Family Park. We're hosting our first ever Chino in Action event. It's a great opportunity to meet our city staff, enjoy a free barbecue, and see our brand new police helicopter up close. Next, we're bringing back our Chino Summer Nights movie series, happening every Friday from June 12th to July 31st, except for June 26th. This year, we're adding a special twist. Half of our summer movies will take place at the newly opened Stubing Family Park, in the Preserve. That's right, we're giving more Chino residents the opportunity to enjoy our movie nights closer to home. Be sure to bring your blankets, snacks, and lawn chairs and enjoy a beautiful night under the stars watching exciting movies the whole family will love. If live music is more your style, I encourage you to join us for our summer concerts on the lawn presented by the Chino Kiwanis Club. We have a fantastic lineup of bands performing every Thursday from June 12th to July 25th, except July 3rd. It promises to be a toe-tapping good time. And be sure to join us as we light up the Chino night sky during our annual two-day fireworks spectacular on June 26th and 27th at Iola Park. For more information on all our exciting events happening all summer long, visit cityofchino.org forward slash events. With all these events and amenities, Chino is the place to be this summer.

1:33:23 – 1:34:50Speaker 24

At Chino's 2026 State of the City, something unexpected happened. A surprise appearance from Oral Hirschheiser delivering big news for Chino. It was a night that brought the community together as the City of Chino welcomed residents, businesses, and community leaders for its annual State of the City presented in partnership with the Chino Valley Chamber of Commerce. Mayor Eunice Ulloa highlighted the progress shaping Chino today while sharing a look at what's ahead, all centered around this year's theme, Always Home. From continued investments in infrastructure and public safety to a growing business community, the momentum is clear. The evening also honored those making a difference, including Business of the Year recipients, Royalty Cakes and B&B Lock and Security, and Spirit of Achievement honorees Dale and Sandra Subright, whose impact spans decades. The Chino Valley Chamber of Commerce also highlighted the continued growth of Chino's business community and the opportunities ahead. And then a surprise appearance from none other than Dodger legend Earl Hershiser interrupted the mayor's speech to formally announce his partnership with Chino's legacy business, M.K. Smith's Chevrolet, to rename the dealership Earl Hershiser's Chevrolet. A moment that captured the energy of a city on the rise while staying rooted in what matters most. This is Chino. Always home. Watch the full state of the city at cityofchino.org forward slash SOTC.

1:34:53 – 1:35:56Speaker 12

here because we're brewing up business. Chino is absolutely a phenomenal place to be. Multi-generational city. We've been here over a hundred years and very business friendly. You're gonna love Chino. As far as businesses are concerned, I personally want to see something for everyone. I want our kids to be able to stay in town, have entertainment places to go. I also want all kinds of entertainment for every age group. We need to stay here, we work here, we live here, and we play here. So I'm looking for businesses that are going to fill any void that we have.

1:36:02Speaker 1

So welcome to the Business Roundtable. This is the Broker's Edition.

1:36:29 – 1:36:57Speaker 12

I was first elected in 1984. Chino used to be very, very heavily agricultural, and over time we have evolved into something for everyone when it comes to housing stock, which is wonderful, and also businesses. We're growing by leaps and bounds. Very, very proud of our community. Multi-generational, so we have grandparents, parents, kids. So Chino's a wonderful place to be, and I'm very, very proud to represent it.

1:37:09 – 1:37:38Speaker 19

Hey there, I'm Samantha. I'm the community engagement manager here at the Animal Resource Center of the Inland Empire. We're the new animal services agency for this region. We serve Ontario, Montclair, Chino, and the unincorporated areas of West San Bernardino County. We provide all animal services for this area, things like pet licensing, microchipping your pets, supporting the community when they find stray animals, adoptions, foster opportunities. We also have volunteer opportunities. Come on down, come meet some of our very cute animals.

1:37:46 – 1:39:45Speaker 5

Community support since we opened was pretty good, you know, very incredibly supportive. What I understand from the city part, the mayor and all the people around the city was very helpful since we started operation of construction and then, you know, fully operational opening in December 2023. Our business sets apart, I would say, being a Marriott hotel, we more focus on service as well as local community, what we support and more hospitality, I would say. So it's not only just a basic room and, you know, guests can come and sleep, but we focus as a whole hospitality, more warmth and welcoming. That's what our goal normally we follow. Business grown every year pretty much. I would say since opening December 6th, 2023, right? Now we are at about one and a half year plus, but every year we see significant growth. This year is much more, I would say 10 to 20% more than what we were in the first year. and surrounding area what we see a lot of opportunity still considering our location and one of the biggest location i would say about the BAPS Swaminarayan temple that helps a lot a lot of weddings and a lot of events happening there, guests do come and stay here. Besides that we do get a lot of teams. That gives us a good growth opportunity and we are still seeing a lot of opportunity around the businesses in the area which we are trying to explore too.

1:40:47 – 1:41:56Speaker 24

On April 9, 2026, the City of Chino, in partnership with Adrian's World, hosted an event at the Chino Police Department called Safe and Sound. This inclusive event is for the neurodivergent community to interact with first responders of the Chino Police Department, Chino Hills Sheriff's Department, and the Chino Valley Fire District. Various vendors like the Autism Society Inland Empire and the Special Olympics of Southern California were present, giving out information as well as special needs coffee with their unique brand of drinks. Public safety vehicles like a fire engine and bear cap were on display for exploration and photo ops. There were also demonstrations including the Blue Envelope program, which helps police officers identify and interact with a person with special needs. The Chino Valley Fire District showed off their defibrillator and Chino PD focused on a civil interaction between officers and pedestrians. Safe and Sound is another event bringing inclusivity to residents of all abilities while making it fun to interact with our first responders. Thank you to our sponsors for this event. For more information, please visit www.cityofchino.org

1:42:05 – 1:42:56Speaker 8

Well, interestingly, I opened up the very first LA Fitness that was the very first ground up they'd ever built here in Chino in December of 96. and I just had become a new yoga teacher and decided I wanted to open up my own studio and Fit Body was nice enough to let me sublease space from them and it grew from there. About 11 years ago we opened up the space you see here behind me and this weekend we celebrate our 14th year anniversary and this just has become my home community. Most of our advertising is simply word of mouth.

1:52:24 – 1:52:45Speaker 12

Okay. I'm going to call the City Council and the Successor Agency to the Redevelopment Agency to order. It dates June 9th. Please note that all council members are present. And Council Member Lucio is going to lead us in the flag salute, so if you'd please stand.

1:52:45Speaker 15

Please put your right hand over your heart. Okay. Ready? Begin.

1:52:51 – 1:53:54Speaker 12

I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the republic for which it stands, one nation under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all. Thank you. First thing on our agenda is public communication. Is there anyone in the audience that would like to address the council on an item that is not on the agenda? Okay, seeing none, we'll move on to item number one, which is our study session. This is an overview of our development impact fee nexus study update. I'D LIKE TO CALL ON OUR CONTRACTS AND DIFFERENT ADMINISTRATORS, SILVIA RAMOS AND OUR WILL DAN FINANCIAL SERVICES CONSULTANT, MR. CARLOS VILLARREAL.

1:53:54 – 1:55:22Speaker 20

GOOD EVENING, MADAM MAYOR AND MEMBERS OF THE CITY COUNCIL. BEFORE YOU THIS EVENING IS AN OVERVIEW OF THE DEVELOPMENT IMPACT FEE NEXUS STUDY UPDATE Over the past 12 months, staff has worked closely with Wildan Financial Services to update the city's DIF program to confirm that fees align with current infrastructure needs, future growth, and facilities costs. The purpose of today's study session is to cover several key elements, including the legal framework, methodology, and fee comparisons. Staff is requesting that the city council provide input on the updated NEXUS study prior to releasing the public review draft to the developers and stakeholders. Following tonight's presentation, staff's next step will be to formally release the public review draft and begin the required 30-day public review period. During that time, staff will work with developers and stakeholders to address any questions or concerns and incorporate any necessary changes. Staff will return back to the City Council on July 21, 2026 for the public hearing. to consider adoption of the updated NEXUS study and associated amendments to chapters 3.40, 3.45 of the municipal code relating to the development impact fees, as well as chapter 18 pertaining to the park fees. Before our consultant, Carlos Villarreal, presents the details of the updated DIF program, I would like to provide some background information and highlight key changes reflected in the update.

1:55:32Speaker 14

Thank you. Thank you.

1:55:41 – 2:05:07Speaker 20

One of the major changes to this update is a shift from a per unit residential fee to a square footage based fee structure. Carlos will walk through the details. It should be noted that staff worked closely with Lewis Management Corp., the city's master developer, and reviewed both Lewis and non-Lewis developments to establish average home sizes. This allowed us to compare the current fee structure to the proposed methodology and ensure the transition is equitable and data-driven. Also, an alternative storm drain diff methodology is also proposed. While the primary fee is based on building square footage, certain developments may be charged based on impervious square feet. This applies to projects with relatively low building square footage, but significant stormwater runoff impacts. Moving on to the citywide DIF program. As you may know, the general city area is largely built out with limited vacant land remaining for large scale development. Future growth is expected to occur primarily through infill development, redevelopment, accessory dwelling units, lot splits, and other smaller scale projects. The City utilized and incorporated the Water and Sewer Master Plans completed in 2022. Because DIF funds may only be used for growth-related improvements, only three projects were eligible to be included in the update that we're bringing to you today. It should also be noted that the Master Plan accounts for future growth within the sphere of influence also. Projects serving those areas cannot be included in the DIF program until they are annexed into the City. Through the annual update studies moving forward, The city will continue to look at the master plans and incorporate projects as appropriate when they are attributable to future development and eligible for inclusion in the DIP program. Please note that the storm drain DIP program list remains largely unchanged from the prior study. The primary update consists of construction cost escalations applied to the existing projects only. The city is actually currently working on updating the 2004 storm drain master plan and anticipates completing the 2027 update at the end of next year. Any growth-related capital improvements identified through that effort will be evaluated and included in next year's annual report. And lastly, for the citywide program, now that the city has taken over Euclid Avenue, we've included the ultimate configuration of roadway in the DIP program. This means that future improvements aligned with accommodating growth are planned and the growth-related share of those improvements is funded through the DIF program. As growth occurs, those planned upgrades will help ensure Euclid can handle future demand. Next on the list is the park fee program. The park fees are typically not included as part of the NEXUS study. However, last year when we came to council for the annual update, the cost for the park fee went up 80%. We had some feedback from the BIA and they had concerns. So the city council agreed and approved, I believe a 12% increase in staff recommended to the city council that we would come back this year and include the park fees as part of the next study update to ensure that our fees are in line with what's being charged. So staff identified that We're still calculating the fees using the land acquisition component. However, the Title 18 in the Chino Municipal Code has that the construction cost per acre is actually calculated off the land acquisition. So if the land appraisal in the citywide program is less than the preserve, the fee is lower. It's not really equitable. So it costs the same to build a park in the preserve as it does in the citywide. So we moved away from that methodology as far as the construction cost per acre. And we did an analysis of local jurisdictions and agencies to see what the actual updated cost for park projects was. And then we averaged it out. So we're utilizing 1.16 per acre. So at least we're collecting enough to cover costs for future park expansion. And also the park fees, there's two components. The fee is the same for the Mitigation Fee Act park fee and also the Quimby fee. So the QMB fee are for subdivisions. So when we're collecting those fees, they actually are more flexible, where we could utilize them for replacement, rehab, stuff like that, where the fees collected under the Mitigation Fee Act are more restrictive and only can be utilized for new park projects and expansion. And Carlos will highlight more on that, too. Lastly on this slide, we have the public use facilities fee. The public use facilities fee is being postponed till September. We're still waiting on additional information and staff intends to return to the City Council in September 2026 with a separate analysis so we can get that feedback on the agenda. As you may already know, staff has agendized a few items When it comes to the reconciliation and true-up of the diff credits and construction reimbursement agreements the majority of those agreements are with Lewis management corporation Currently the water and streets and reconciliations have been approved We have the storm drain on the agenda for next week, and then there'll be subsequent true-ups coming your way early July So the purpose of that, it was very intensive. We had to go back, and not even just with Lewis agreements, but with all development agreements that we had construction and credits assigned to other developers, we had to go up and true up everything. Everything that was committed and paid for and just closed out, those projects were removed from the DIF. The only thing remaining now are projects that still need to be funded or constructed or haven't been closed out. And then we're also carrying over any balance that we owe to the developers. So I have a table in the next slide that'll just show you what's being brought forward to be put into the new update. To complement the DIF program also, we hired Proactive Engineering. They're very familiar with the projects in the preserve. That's our primary development activity going on in the city. They prepared updated costs for everything. So everything's... trued up to what it should cost to date. Also, the Atlas maps are very helpful, which I'll go through very quickly after this to show you that what's constructed, what's proposed, what hasn't been accepted. So it's very clear to developers, to staff, to anybody who's referencing these items. And then lastly, on this slide, we have the congestion management plan fee. This fee is in the preserve. It's only charged to the preserve. But it's for projects that are outside the city's jurisdiction. So there's several projects in there that are not very well defined or obsolete or just not even relevant today. So after talking to the city attorney and our consultant and staff, moving forward, because projects, when they come in through entitlements, they're mitigating their impacts to other jurisdictions through their traffic impact analysis. If there's any money owed for projects outside the city's jurisdiction, they're paying the cities directly. So there's no reason to collect this fee anymore. However, this standalone fee is actually going away in our Nexus study because it's not typical to charge a fee like this. But the city is going to retain the fund balance that we have collected. And we've identified a project that would be eligible for the utilization of this fund balance. And we're thinking it's going to go towards the 71 interchange portion of the Pine Avenue Bridge project. So we have a consultant right now doing the Nexus analysis to make sure that the monies that are going to be put towards that Have a direct tie to future and past development in the preserve. So So just real quickly this is the table showing the remaining balances of the true-up of all the construction credit reimbursement agreements that the city has Approved implemented the first column to shows all the validated cost through these multiple agreements the second column shows the credit reimbursements issued to developers and then the third column represents what is left that remains that we still need to essentially pay the developers back with. So you'll see in the project listing that there's a project at the very bottom of the list that shows these balances in these categories. So real quickly, these are the Atlas maps that I referenced. They're very straightforward. These are going to be updated every year as projects are being closed out. This is all the backbone infrastructure. It's just an illustration of all the projects that are included in our DIF program. We have one for our street DIF. We have a storm drain. This is for the preserve. Our water diff, our recycled water, and our sewer diff. So now I'm going to hand it over to Carlos so he can go on with the methodology and the fee calculations.

2:05:14 – 2:19:29Speaker 21

All right, thank you. So I'm going to go through some of the framework that we think of when we're thinking about impact fees. I'll go over some of the requirements from AB 602, which is a piece of legislation that has gone into effect since the city last updated their fees. I'll go through our methodology and how we allocate costs. And then finally, I will present the maximum justified fee schedules in the draft. And then we'll compare those to both the city's current impact fees, but also to some of your neighbors. And just so we're all on the same page, we'll start off with some really basic impact fee 101. Impact fees are a one-time charge typically imposed at the building permit stage, although for most residential projects, they are now charged at certificate of occupancy. They're imposed on all projects within a defined area. In this case, the city has a few varieties. There are some fees that are charged uniformly citywide when a service is provided uniformly citywide. And then there are, of course, fees that vary by the area, so the general city area versus the preserve. that reflect the increased infrastructure needs in the preserve. But the key to all of this is that impact fees fund the facilities that are needed to serve new development, not ongoing costs, not maintenance, not rehab. It's really just the facilities or the capital assets that are needed to serve growth, and our study needs to demonstrate that relationship between new development and the facilities that are needed to serve it. So why would a city charge impact fees? The short answer is we want growth to pay its own way. If you do not mitigate for impacts, then your service levels may decrease. For example, your parks might get more crowded or there might be more congestion. So the impact fees are a funding source that allows developers to sort of mitigate these external costs and they free up your general fund revenue and other general purpose revenues to be used for ongoing services and other needs. In California, it's the Mitigation Fee Act that lays out how a local agency would calculate and implement an impact fee. Several key findings need to be made in any Nexus study. First, we need to demonstrate that new development creates the need for facilities. We need to show that new development will benefit from the use of the fee revenue. And we need to show that the fees are roughly proportional to new development share of facility cost. There's also a couple of housekeeping items. We need to document the purpose of the fee and how the city intends to use the fee revenue. I mentioned AB 602 a little bit earlier on. This went into effect, I believe, in 2022, but several jurisdictions or many jurisdictions haven't updated their fees since then, so some of these requirements are now just coming into play. The first box there, you see there are some transparency and disclosure items. Most cities already comply with these, but now it's official that you need to make your impact fee schedule, nexus studies, and annual and five-year reporting easily available online. One big change, and Sylvia already alluded to this, is that there's a 30-day public notice period before a jurisdiction can consider the adoption of a NEXA study at a public hearing. So it's a little bit more lead time to allow for public review there. And then in terms of technical changes, there's a strong suggestion that residential fees be calculated per square foot. Prior to AB 602, the majority of residential fees were calculated as a flat rate per dwelling unit by type of dwelling unit. So this is a pretty big change in terms of the technical approach. But of course, there are incentives. If you build a smaller unit, you would pay lower fees than if it was just a flat rate. A large jurisdiction needs to include a capital improvement plan as part of the NEXUS study. And in this case, large jurisdictions are defined as cities within a county that have more than 250,000 residents. So this would apply to you. The NEXUS study needs to identify the level of service. And we also need to look back at the original assumptions or the prior assumptions used to calculate the fee if the fees are increasing. This next slide lays out our basic methodology. We start by estimating demand for facilities, and we think about demand coming from people, so people that live and work in the city. We've done this both for the overall city, including the general city area plus the preserve, and you'll also see in the report there's a table identifying these estimates separately for the general city and the preserve for those fees that have different service areas. We can then identify facility standards. The common example here would be park acres per thousand residents, but this concept can be applied to other types of facilities as well. Then using those facility standards, but also any other engineering that the city has done, so water and sewer master plan, for example, we can identify the facilities that are needed to serve the city out into the future. And then we can allocate a share of those facilities to accommodate growth. So in some cases, new development can fully fund all of the costs. In other cases, the facilities might also be benefiting existing development and needed to correct existing deficiencies. So that share that's benefiting existing development or mitigating existing deficiencies cannot be funded by the impact fees. So in the next step, we identify the share that has to come from other sources as opposed to the share that can be funded by the fees. And then finally, we take the costs that have been allocated to new development and allocate those per unit of growth. In this case, all the fees are expressed per square foot for both residential and non-residential with the exception of the fees for hotel rooms. So commercial lodging is charged at a flat rate per room. So we mentioned the different service areas. This next slide here just lays out all the different fees included in the program update. The one exception there is public use facilities, which we'll be bringing back at a later date once we've received a little bit more information. But you can see for water, sewer, storm, and circulation and parks, The fees vary by the service area, so the general city versus the preserve. The miscellaneous residential amenities fees is only charged in the preserve, and it's not charged in the general city area. And then fire, law enforcement, and general facilities are charged uniformly citywide. So just to lay out some overarching assumptions here, this slide here lays out the growth projections assumed in the study. The build out figure comes from your general plan update EIR. We also took a look at the specific plan, sorry, the preserve specific plan. And as you can see, almost 9,000 new jobs, over 10,000 new dwelling units and approaching 36,000 new residents citywide between now and build out, which is pegged for approximately 2045. Consequently, with this increase in demand for facilities, the city needs to provide services and the facilities needed to house those services. And that's sort of the relationship between growth and the impact fees. So we mentioned facility standards or cost allocation a little bit earlier. There are three different approaches that are used in the study depending on the facility category, and I'll give you sort of an overview of how they work. The first approach is the existing inventory approach, and the common example here is parks. So we can quantify the existing parks serving the city, we can quantify existing demand, so residents, and calculate park acres per thousand residents to identify your existing level of service, and then we know how much it costs to acquire and build an acre of parks, for example, so we can use all of those inputs to set the fee so that new development contributes to parks at your existing service standard. Under the planned facilities approach, we might use this approach if we have a master plan that identifies specific facilities and the share of those facilities that are needed to accommodate growth. In that case, we can add up the costs that are needed to accommodate growth and divide it by the increase in demand. An example here might be your sewer fee, where we can identify particular sewer lines that are needed to serve new development, and we know the increase in flow, in sewer flow that can be accommodated by those facilities. So we take the cost, divide it by the increase in flow, and get a cost per gallon per day of flow, which drives the fee calculation. Now, the third approach, the system standard, is sort of a combination of the first two. This is appropriate when there are facilities that are going to serve both existing and new development, and it's sort of difficult to suss out what share of the facility is serving who. This might be applicable for, say, fire facilities, right? You'll build a new fire station, but that new station is going to respond to calls from both existing and new residents. And your existing stations will also provide mutual aid and respond to calls from both existing and new folks as well. So in this case, we take a look at the existing facilities that are currently providing service, identify their replacement cost, add the cost of the future planned facilities that are needed to serve the city as well, and identify the total value of the system at the planning horizon. We can then compare that to demand at the planning horizon. So in this case, 2045, divide the cost of those facilities by your service population in 2045 and get a cost per person that drives the fee calculation. Under this approach, new development can pay their fair share of the identified facilities, but we'll have to identify a share that's needed to serve existing development because the system serves existing development as well. This next slide lays out the approaches that we used in the study. We used the existing level of service approach for parks. We used that system standard approach for fire suppression, general city facilities, and miscellaneous residential amenities in the preserve. And then a planned facilities approach, largely driven by the city's master planning efforts for water, sewer, storm drain, circulation, and law enforcement. This next slide here just gives a high level look at the types of facilities and improvements that are contemplated in the study. Of course, the NEXUS study has a detailed list for every facility category. So for parks, the idea is that the park fees would maintain a three acre standard. The analysis shows that the city has an excess of three acres today in both the general city and in the preserve. For water facilities, we're contemplating recycled water lines and water mains and other related facilities. Same for sewer, so sewer mains and upsizing of facilities to accommodate development. For general city facilities, the city's contemplating a pretty large public work services center, so a new corporation yard. And then for traffic, the project list include capacity expanding, signalization of backbone streets needed to serve the increase in demand. For the public use facilities fee that we'll be bringing back, and again, isn't included in this draft, there is a large significant community center at the preserve. And then finally, for the storm drain fees, like Sylvia mentioned, we are funding the storm drain facilities identified in the prior master plan. Of course, as the city updates its storm drain master plan, we intend to bring back an update to the general city facilities fee at some point in the future. So what does this all boil down to? This is our maximum justified fee schedule here for the general city. And I'll walk you through it. So due to AB 602, the fees will be implemented per square foot for single family and multifamily. But it's kind of hard to judge what a fee per square foot looks like when you've been charging your fees per dwelling unit. So the second two rows there, I showed what the fees would be for the average size dwelling unit. And like Sylvia mentioned, we had information from the city's development partners to identify the average square footage of a single family and a multifamily unit based on future projects going forward. So the average size figures are listed there in the footnote, but about 3,300 square feet for single family and 1,400 square feet for multifamily. So using those assumptions, we could convert the residential fees per square foot into what it might look like if you're building that average size unit in town. Again, this is the fee schedule here for the general city. Again, I think the average size unit is helpful. So for a single family unit, the fee would be a little less than $43,000. And for a multifamily unit, the total fee across all the categories would be a little less than $30,000. This next slide here shows the maximum justified fee schedule for the preserve. Of course, the residential amenities fee or miscellaneous residential amenities fee, I should say, is not charged in the general city. So that would be one difference here. And then for circulation, storm, water, sewer, and parks, the fees are slightly different or a little bit higher than the fees in the general city. And again, that's reflecting the infrastructure needed to support the new growth area out in the preserve. And again, for the purpose of comparison, you can see the maximum justified fees here across these facility categories are just shy of $64,000 for your average sized unit for single family and $44,000 roughly for that multifamily unit. But now I'll give you, oh, before I get to the fee comparison, let me show you sort of the summary of everything. So this next slide here lays out the net project cost, and that would be net of your existing fund balances. So we wanted to make sure that we took into account the funding that the city has on hand. You sum it up across all the fee programs, and this includes the summary for both the General City and the Preserve, so all the numbers are included here. It's total project cost of about $962 million. Of that, the fees, if implemented at the maximum justified levels, would generate about $697 million roughly between now and 2045, and that would leave about $265 million to be funded by other sources. I would just note that of that additional funding required, there are a few sort of big ticket projects that make up the majority of that for storm drainage. There is a. agreement with the developers where they were paying about six million dollars for an improvement and it's in you know seventy million dollars or so so that there's a big a big difference there between the project cost and what the developers are obligated to pay and then I'll have Sylvia help me remember the circulate there's a major circulation system improvement that that has a large unfunded share.

2:19:29 – 2:19:44Speaker 20

So the majority of the unfunded share is line I because the costs have grown exponentially and also the Pine Avenue connector and then we also have the proposed city yard that's included in there. So that's pretty much the unfunded balance.

2:19:45 – 2:22:49Speaker 21

Yeah, exactly. The city yard in general, in general city facilities that nearly $32 million, that's existing development share of the proposed city yard. And with that, I'll share a fee comparison that we put together here. And just to walk you through this slide, we calculated the fees for one single family unit of 3,320 square feet. Some cities are still charging at a flat rate per unit. So we just use the fees per unit there and then other cities are charging per square foot. So that's why I'm kind of laying out all those assumptions there. You can see the city's current fees are in the yellow bars, so for both the general city and the preserve, and then the green bars represent the draft fees at the maximum justified rates. You'll also see that for some other cities, for example, sorry, For example, Rancho Cucamonga has a low and a high. That's because they charge their fees in zones similar to how you do. So depending on where you're building in the city, you might pay one of two or maybe multiple different fee schedules. I believe theirs might be driven by a different storm drain fee. And the City of Ontario is also sort of analogous to your situation. They have a general city fee and a fee in their growth area. So that's why you have two different columns for the City of Ontario. So anyway, this just sort of lays out how the city compares in both the current and draft fees. This next slide here, rather than just compare a single multifamily unit, we took a look at sort of a prototypical development of 20 units at the 1,400 square feet per unit. So that's where we got the 2,800 square feet. And I think all the comparisons will show a similar story where the city's fees are on the upper end of the range of the comparisons. Yeah, again, we're showing the current and draft fees across the board here. Another comparison here, this is for a 10,000 square foot sort of generic retail prototype. And I would say all the comments I made earlier apply to this comparison as well. This next slide here shows the comparison for a 50,000 square foot office building. And I was also just reminded that the city of Ontario is currently updating their fees as well. So can't say for certain, but it's likely their fees will be increasing at some point in the next year or so. And then the final comparison here is for a 100,000 square foot, sort of a generic industrial prototype. So I'll hand it back to Sylvia to discuss the next steps.

2:22:51 – 2:23:45Speaker 20

So next steps is to receive city council feedback to incorporate any suggestions, recommendations before we send out the draft copy to the industry and the developers. We can revise the study based on anything that comes back to us. Once we distribute the information, again, we're going to We tentatively have it scheduled to come back to City Council on the 21st to introduce the ordinances, which is for the Title 18, which is the park and recreational land, and also Chapters 3.40 and 3.45 for the development impact fees and conduct the public hearing. Then we have to wait until September 1st to bring back the adoption and the second reading, and then fees will go into effect about 60 days later, which would be November 1st. That concludes our report. I'd be happy, and Carlos would be happy to answer any questions you may have.

2:23:47 – 2:24:02Speaker 12

Okay. I think before I ask if there's any public comment, I think I'll open it up for council questions first. Chris, do you have any questions you would like to ask?

2:24:02Speaker 6

No questions right now.

2:24:04Speaker 12

Mark, do you have any questions?

2:24:07 – 2:24:34Speaker 15

Yeah. We look at the 260 something or million dollar shortfall that we're gonna have at the end of build-out Now the majority of that is because of the pine avenue connector the you click connector and Light I so what you said That's correct. So what's what's the total number? Just on those three projects

2:24:38 – 2:25:14Speaker 21

So line I is about a $71.7 million deficit. Okay. And then Pine Avenue, let's see here, give me one moment. Pine Avenue is $132.5 million project, only $16 million of which can be funded by the fees. So what's that? Okay. 116 roughly million unfunded. And then the general city facilities, I believe that was about 31 million for the public work center.

2:25:17Speaker 15

So we're looking at 60 something million shortfall. So that's not even counting Euclid, right? That's just counting Pine Avenue? Or is that both Pine Avenue and Euclid?

2:25:26Speaker 21

Right, I was just citing Pine Avenue there. So what's Euclid?

2:25:31 – 2:26:09Speaker 20

Actually, Euclid is programmed in both. So currently the city, well, we utilize trip generation data and we had all of the costs broken down into segments for Euclid. So about 24% is programmed into the preserve and the remaining is programmed into the citywide. But it's looking like it's fully funded for the Euclid. So the $18 million that we're getting with the relinquishment will go towards existing deficiencies. And the projects that are programmed into the DIF now for Euclid will be for expansion of circulation projects. So it's full ultimate improvements.

2:26:09Speaker 10

Sylvia, does that include the bridge as well, or just Euclid from Pine North? Yeah, Pine North.

2:26:18 – 2:26:29Speaker 21

And actually, I'm going to revise what I said. The $132.5 million, that is the total allocated to other funding for Pine Avenue. The total project cost is $148.5 million.

2:26:32Speaker 15

And then I have a question. The congestion management fee, who pays that? Are you saying that other cities?

2:26:43 – 2:27:32Speaker 20

No. So when the program started in the Preserve, there was a traffic study that was incorporated into the fees, and it included projects outside the city's boundary. So for example, there was a project in there for three traffic signals on Archibald, but it's not really well defined, or projects in Riverside County, and the project's listing is pretty archaic and outdated, so ultimately, now through entitlements, traffic mitigation for outside infrastructure is addressed through the traffic impact analysis. So if the developer is required to pay impacts in other cities, they just pay the cities directly. So pretty much that fee was us collecting it. And then we would have to broker the money to other jurisdictions as these projects were being built out.

2:27:33 – 2:27:46Speaker 15

So it wasn't like, let's say, for example, the city of Eastvale that causes a lot of congestion down Pine Avenue to the 71. So we're not charging Eastvale developers for the congestion that they're causing in our city?

2:27:46 – 2:28:10Speaker 20

No. It's for the development that's occurring in the city of Chino, which impacts outside jurisdictions. So we're redirecting the funds that have been collected, which is about $9 million, and we're going to put it towards a project that's outside the city boundary that has a direct... direct tie in nexus to the preserve for past and future development.

2:28:10Speaker 16

It's the opposite of that scenario.

2:28:12Speaker 15

So why wouldn't we have charged other cities for the impact that they're making in our city?

2:28:19Speaker 21

It's just not typically done. To charge a fee in another jurisdiction, it's not common practice and it would be difficult to implement. I'm not really familiar of another program that does that, to be honest.

2:28:30Speaker 10

Did Eastvale collect a fee for their congestion within our city or Ontario? Like if that's what we're doing?

2:28:39Speaker 20

Actually, well, this fee is very, it's not typical for. Hey, Susan. Oh, yeah. Go ahead, hey, Susan.

2:28:46 – 2:29:03Speaker 22

Good evening. Just from my own personal experience, I think other jurisdictions, they collect fees to handle improvements within their jurisdictions. They don't collect monies that they're going to broker to other agencies as far as addressing impacts that their developments might have in those other jurisdictions.

2:29:03Speaker 15

So why would we spend $9 million in somebody else's jurisdiction?

2:29:08 – 2:29:52Speaker 20

Because the fee was actually collected for projects outside of the cities proper, so Ultimately we're looking to utilize that money because it's hard like we're restricted to what we can spend it on so we have to draw it back to and have a nexus in order to redirect it to another project so logically instead of purchase like paying for traffic signals in Corona or Eastville and sending money $13,000 for a traffic signal in Archibald it made sense to reevaluate the projects that were listed are they still relevant today what's relevant today is We need to provide more transportation capacity, and that would look, that would actually have a tie back to the preserve and have a nexus.

2:29:53Speaker 15

Why wouldn't we use that for like Euclid or Pine?

2:29:56Speaker 21

You have to spend the fee revenue that you've collected for the purpose that it was collected. So it was collected for this congestion management program, and you have to spend it for that purpose.

2:30:04Speaker 15

Why wouldn't we use it on the, let's say the Chino Hillside?

2:30:10Speaker 20

That's what we're using it for. So we're going to use it on the interchange, the 71 interchange portion, which is located within the city of Chino Hills.

2:30:18Speaker 15

I thought you said it was going to be on Archibald.

2:30:20 – 2:31:02Speaker 20

No, I apologize. So the projects that are in the existing DIF program that we collected the fee for consist of projects that are outside, like traffic signals on Archibald, in Eastville, in Corona. So we evaluated those projects, and it didn't make sense today for what we need. So what we're doing is we're redirecting the money and looking at something that's more feasible to fund instead of these kind of nondescriptive projects that aren't really well described. So ultimately, we want to utilize the money and redirect it to something that we could use it for, which would be something similar to the 71 interchange in Chino Hills.

2:31:03 – 2:31:16Speaker 15

So let's say, for example, If Chino Hills is supposed to pay a certain portion, is there any way that they pay that certain portion and we credit it on our side and then we use that money to credit it on their side?

2:31:18 – 2:31:44Speaker 20

I think that Haygen and her team has been working with Chino Hills to come up with a funding plan and then an agreement moving into the future when it comes to the Pine Avenue connector, the 71. It hasn't really been worked out. I have a feeling that the city of Chino will probably be more responsible for a lot of the funding, so this is another way for us to kind of leverage the funds that we have and put it towards this project. I don't know if Hajin wants to chime in a little bit.

2:31:46Speaker 10

Well, Hajin's coming up. I'm sure we don't know the origin of why we were charging that fee or how long it's been in our DIF program.

2:31:53 – 2:32:21Speaker 20

It's been in the DIF program for over 20 years. Like Carlos said, it's not typical. So over the years, when we were Mitigating impacts with developers for outside agency projects now We just have the developers pay directly instead of us collecting the fee and then brokering through to other cities so it makes sense just to kind of clean up the diff to You know have this fee just kind of go away and then we redirect the money to a project that we could utilize it for Because there is a Nexus

2:32:24Speaker 15

Do you have anything, Haygen?

2:32:25 – 2:34:30Speaker 7

Yeah, good evening, Mayor and Council. Yes, we are working closely with City of Cheathill staff to finalize our design. So we are actually running concurrent with the actual engineering plans, projects, plans and specifications, as well as running our environmental and traffic analysis. So all of those combined will help us identify what we need at the interchange and definitely the funds that were collected for the traffic impact outside of the city boundary, that fund can be supplemented to construct the interchange and that'll be a good place to spend the money and also reduce congestion in that area. And that's a direct impact from the preserve development. And in terms of funding agreement, Since we don't have a final plans and we're discussing about in the future whether we could work with some of our electives on the state and federal level to advocate for substantial source of that funding. By the time we're done with the design, the approximate construction cost would be about $150 million. So that's something that is not... a local agency can afford. So we're gonna definitely need some federal funding and some support for that. And we would have a better chance of securing that if we work with the agencies around us, including SBCTA and City of Chino Hills and Caltrans. Because this is not just a Pine Avenue for the purposes of serving the preserve community, but it is a corridor that serves, Ontario and Eastvale and Norco, that area, going east and westbound. So we're definitely advocating that other agencies support our efforts to construct this by showing letter of support when we're ready to advocate on the federal level.

2:34:30Speaker 15

I have nothing else for now.

2:34:36 – 2:35:09Speaker 12

I would like to follow on with Mark's question about the congestion management plan. So you mentioned that $9 million that was collected for outside of our community, but now we're going to reallocate it to possibly the 71 interchange. You mentioned that developers now will pay other cities directly. Who calculates the amount that they pay? Who oversees that? Is that between the developer in the other cities, or is that something that we still have to be involved in?

2:35:09 – 2:35:54Speaker 20

No, we're not involved in it anymore. So through the traffic impact analysis that's required during the entitlement process, they determine how much in proportional cost for traffic signals or other traffic calming projects. So ultimately, in the past, we would actually invoice for those deposits for San Bernardino County, for Ontario, Eastville, Adjacent cities and then once we get those deposits in they actually stay in our account and then we have to pass them through So instead of us being the broker the developers are required to pay their fair share directly to those cities But it's still our responsibility to do the calculation maybe who's who's can Provide more information on the entitlement side. He's our expert

2:35:54 – 2:36:25Speaker 22

Right, so it's done through the traffic study. So the developer's traffic engineer prepares the traffic study and it determines what's the fair share that they have to contribute towards other jurisdiction improvements. And so I think what Sylvia's indicating is that we would still need to make sure that the developer is making those payments towards those other jurisdictions to fulfill the mitigation that the traffic study identifies.

2:36:26 – 2:36:43Speaker 12

So the developer does the study that determines how much they have to pay somebody else. We don't collect the money any longer, but now we're gonna be responsible for overseeing to make sure they pay the other community? It doesn't make any sense. I mean, how do we know if they've paid it or not? And if they don't, what do we do about it?

2:36:43 – 2:37:35Speaker 16

So if I may chime in, generally when a developer comes in, we require them to do a traffic analysis. team peer reviews that analysis or maybe uses an outside consultant to assist with that peer review. That analysis explains what that project in Chino and how it would impact surrounding jurisdictions. The way I understood the current process is that we would take that money and sort of be in the middle of trying to work with the other jurisdictions which created I think a little bit of administrative complexity and burden, the developers are conditioned to provide those payments. So the conditions require them to demonstrate, yes, here's a check. I've sent it to the city of Eastvale, the city of Chino Hills, et cetera. So we verify.

2:37:35Speaker 12

So they would have to provide us with like a receipt that they've done it? Right.

2:37:39 – 2:38:10Speaker 15

some something like that right yeah and this is something that cities normally do not do right the cities normally do this yes it's a they collect a fair share they require a fair share if you if you look at the impacts that we've had in our areas as a result of the growth of eastvale i mean we received no lights we've received no improvement on any of the one one i think we had one lane in each direction heading down pine avenue So, I mean, there was never anything that came to us as a result of this.

2:38:10 – 2:38:25Speaker 16

So that's when cities get involved and potentially question an entitlement. If Eastville is proposing to develop a large project, you know, at the time, it doesn't sound like this happened.

2:38:25Speaker 12

So all this time we've been asleep and not paid attention to what Eastville was doing and not asking them to reimburse us for impact?

2:38:32 – 2:38:58Speaker 16

Either they didn't. Craft the right analysis to demonstrate that their projects were creating impacts within Chino. Um, in which case we jurisdictions generally push back and say, you know, you're proving a project that's going to have all the impacts on our streets. So we stayed asleep and didn't I, that was years before I think because even when we close Pine Avenue or any of the streets.

2:38:59Speaker 15

Eastvale immediately starts trying to contact us asking us when we're gonna open our streets and everything because they know that impacts their residents.

2:39:06 – 2:39:43Speaker 11

I think that's a difficult impact to back up. I think you could one could ask themselves like once we broke through on Grand Avenue or in the diamond bar and the diamond bar charges and the impact fee to go through that area and then it just keeps moving out. So I don't know how to track that. I don't know if it's proper for us to track it now. It just seems like where does that impact how do you put the appropriate trail on it when you really look at how far that can reach out? It just seems to me how hard that would be.

2:39:45 – 2:39:59Speaker 12

My point is if we're required, if our developers are required to identify an impact outside of our boundary, Why aren't other developers required to do the same? Why are our developers punished if others are not?

2:39:59 – 2:40:13Speaker 11

The problem I have with that study, Mayor, and us discussing it right now, is it's prepared by the developer, right? And what developer is going to be wanting to add to an impact to a surrounding community, much less to our community? Why do we require our developers to do it? I don't know.

2:40:15Speaker 16

From what I understand, we peer review... I don't know if it's internal or with a consultant, but so that they can't, you know.

2:40:25 – 2:40:43Speaker 15

I mean, there's been cities that have pushed back on other cities with their proposed developments and saying that their developments are going to impact them in certain ways. So I'm assuming when they were building out, we probably should have also at that point voiced our concerns that it was going to impact us and we just never did.

2:40:43 – 2:41:24Speaker 11

I think if you can, I think it depends on the transportation component. Nobody can deny that Pine Avenue is a main arterial supporter. So you're going to look at some of those things or how Grand Avenue has developed into support of transportation now. So I think knowing that, our staff has to do a better job of paying attention to that. But it's really hard, in my opinion, to back that up. But to your point, Mayor, I don't understand how we would why we would require our developers to do it. I think it's a good question. And do we have to do it? Why are we doing it? If you guys can't explain why we're doing it, I don't understand why we're doing it.

2:41:30 – 2:41:54Speaker 15

Well, I mean, because, like, for example, we're building up Euclid and we're building up Pine Avenue, but we realize that it's going to be utilized by the residents of Ontario Ranch, but we're not. requiring Ontario to provide us any money for that roadway that we're gonna be developing, and is that something that we should be looking to? That would be my question.

2:42:01 – 2:43:29Speaker 13

Good evening, Mayor, members of the council. I'm James Edison from Wilda and Financial Services. I can tell you most broadly, cities don't have any power to cause other cities to charge fees for impact fees. They do have sort of crude levers. I mean, cities do sometimes sue each other. They use CEQA for impacts. But what you're describing here is essentially cooperative. I mean, it's sort of a good neighbor policy, if you will. You have no lever to force anyone to do anything. And the fact that some cities are more cooperative than others, well, that's the world we're in. So I can't address past practices, but I can tell you that these kinds of arrangements do exist between cities, and they're entirely cooperative, except for sometimes there are lawsuits, CEQA, and the settlement of the CEQA lawsuit is some sort of arrangement like this, although it's unusual for it to be systematic. Usually it's over some particular improvement or some particular specific plan or some particular interchange that they're not paying their fair share of. It's usually around individual projects. To have a more general arrangement, I think, for us is... unusual to see, but certainly in the context of impact fees, you don't have any authority to cause another jurisdiction to charge an impact fee on your behalf. It's entirely voluntary. For some, for example, fire districts that cover multiple jurisdictions, it's common for the fire district to request the cities to collect impact fees on their behalf, but it's a request. So in answer to sort of the puzzle of this, it's entirely, to my knowledge, entirely voluntary. You've done it in order to cooperate with your surrounding jurisdictions.

2:43:31 – 2:43:54Speaker 12

Looking at our fees, they're so doggone high. If other communities are not... Being nice neighbors and helping us, I hate to be rude about it, but why in the world are we collecting or having our developers pay higher? Because our fees are a lot higher than somebody else. Why are we doing that and passing money to another community if they're not reciprocating?

2:43:54Speaker 15

Not only that, but then if... Once we collect it, we have to spend it in another city. I think that's possible.

2:43:59Speaker 12

Well, we don't collect it. We're requiring the developer to pay for it directly.

2:44:04Speaker 15

And then to spend it in a different city when we don't get the same thing.

2:44:08Speaker 12

Plus, our fees are already so high.

2:44:10 – 2:44:51Speaker 16

So maybe this is me stepping into city engineers' toes, so kick me under the table, hey, Jen, if you disagree, but the theory as I normally understand it is that cities will do this and analyze the traffic impacts that spill out into other jurisdictions because those could create stacking and impacts on our jurisdiction. So if, for example, a turn-in lane is needed, in the city of Chino Hills so as not to create an impact in our city, you wanna assure that those improvements are done. I don't know if that's a fair statement.

2:44:51 – 2:45:05Speaker 12

I get it, I get it. It's just what bothers me is the fact that we're being the good neighbors, but it appears that our neighbors don't give a rip about their impact for us. So it's like, wait a minute, this should be reciprocal.

2:45:05 – 2:45:28Speaker 16

And as I mentioned, I think was underscored by the comments from Will Dent's representative, cities, when they feel like they're going to bear the bulk of the impact and the other city is not providing some fair share of payments, that's when you threaten legal action, a CEQA lawsuit, et cetera, and then it compels them to cooperate.

2:45:28 – 2:45:47Speaker 11

But I go back to the Mayor and Mark's original question. Okay, so this gentleman from Wilden just said we can collect the information and we can provide it next door. It is cooperative, but I mean, what authority do we have to make them pay it? Who's gonna do it?

2:45:48Speaker 12

Nobody's doing it, right?

2:45:49Speaker 11

I mean, why are we making them do it? And the question is, do we have to make the developer do that?

2:45:55 – 2:46:43Speaker 7

If we don't have to make them do it, maybe we don't do it. I think that was a question I was going to ask our consultants and even Fred. I guess it's a past practice that I guess we don't have any history on. They think that it's been around for at least 15, 20 years and whoever started it. Since it's totally voluntary, do we have to keep collecting it if... My understanding is that sometimes we have a hard time finding agencies to give the money to because some of the agencies don't have a program like us, so they don't even have a mechanism to receive the money because It's kind of like us giving money to somebody, but they don't even have a system in which to receive it and invest it back in.

2:46:44 – 2:47:04Speaker 11

So, Hayden, you're reading my mind right now. Like, even if we wanted to do it in a neighboring city, I was sitting here thinking, like, what if they don't have a fund that's equal to it to reciprocate to us? So they would have to dedicate either general fund money or maybe have another project that was aligned with ours. To me, it just seems weird.

2:47:04Speaker 7

So the question is, can we stop collecting that part?

2:47:08Speaker 11

And as it is, we collected it on the far east of the side of the city, and it's nice, but now we're pulling the convenient switcheroo to put it over here.

2:47:16 – 2:47:30Speaker 20

I don't mean that the wrong way, Sylvia, but let's like, okay, well, we can't use it over there, so let's put it over here. So I don't know. And that's the whole purpose, so I just want to clarify. So we want to eliminate the fee, so we're not charging the developers moving forward?

2:47:30 – 2:47:45Speaker 15

So I mean... We already have the highest fees before we increase the fees. So I would suggest that we eliminate that fee so that even if we do increase it slightly, maybe it's a wash. Sure.

2:47:45 – 2:48:40Speaker 20

So that's what we're actually proposing is to eliminate the fee. We've collected $9 million in the fund balance, but we have to redirect the money to a project that has a direct nexus to the preserves. And we have to spend it on what we initially collected it for. So it was to mitigate impacts outside of the city's boundaries. So it makes sense because we are carrying the burden of the Pine Avenue Connector and the costs associated. And as Hagen mentioned, too, that we're going to be seeking federal funds and grants and whatnot. So it would be a good opportunity to utilize that money towards a match or something of that sort. But moving forward, that was the whole intent is just to remove it from the DIF, stop collecting it moving forward. And then any traffic stuff is identified through entitlements and through the traffic studies and whatnot, and it's completely outside the DIF. So that was our initial intent.

2:48:40 – 2:49:09Speaker 15

Unless you can create a DIF that is gonna go specifically to those projects because additional homes are gonna impact that area. And instead of creating a DIF that provides money to outside the city, make it specifically to fund those bridges that we need. I mean, if that's the case, then I would have no problem continuing to collect that diff from the developers, as long as we had it earmarked specifically for those projects.

2:49:09Speaker 12

I think we already are. Anything else?

2:49:15Speaker 17

I think that, go ahead, Adrian.

2:49:17Speaker 10

I just wanted to say one more thing, Mayor. Yeah.

2:49:20 – 2:50:03Speaker 7

Mayor, I wanted to address your concerns about what the staff is doing when other development is happening around, adjacent to the city. We do receive notices occasionally from City of Ontario, and they have some major developments going on, not too far from the city boundary. And we do thoroughly review those traffic reports to make sure that there's no adverse impact to us. And also, we also look at whether there's gonna be truck traffic or additional trips generated that might be in conflict with what we are proposing. So it's not just what they're doing, but in cumulatively with what we are also planning in the region. So we are.

2:50:04Speaker 12

But we don't charge them. We just have to accommodate whatever they add to us.

2:50:09 – 2:50:26Speaker 7

Correct, but we could also provide comments saying that we might need a turn pocket here or there or some kind of a type of improvement and we could collaborate with them. So we are certainly looking at other developments and their traffic studies very closely.

2:50:26Speaker 12

I know when it comes to storm drain, we're certainly taking an uneven hit on the water coming from Ontario, and we're having to face that burden. Because of the historical flows, yeah.

2:50:36Speaker 7

That's right. That one is a California drainage law. There's not much we can do about that. I know. It's just unfair.

2:50:43 – 2:50:55Speaker 17

Okay. Thank you. Kurt? I have several questions about the congestion management fee that have been more than answered now, and I just suggest we put a toll booth up down there on Pine Avenue.

2:50:57 – 2:51:12Speaker 12

Larry, I think it was Larry Walker that years ago thought we needed a toll booth on 71 Pine Avenue. Several, can you imagine? Anything, Kurt, any other questions?

2:51:12 – 2:51:34Speaker 11

Karen? Yes, Mayor, thank you. I'll start with the low-hanging fruit. Early in your presentation, sir, you mentioned that there are some cities that charge the DIF fee connected to a certificate of occupancy. What is the pro and con of doing that? Obviously, we don't do ours. We charge ours up front, as you stated. What is the benefit of them waiting to charge it with the COO?

2:51:34 – 2:51:51Speaker 21

Oh, I think the benefit to the developer is they can hold on to their, they don't have to pay the fee of writing. So it's a benefit to the developer? It helps their timing, yes. Okay. But there are some state laws, and I don't recall them all off the top of my head, but there are some state laws that govern when that situation applies, when a developer is allowed to pay a certificate of occupancy as opposed to building permit.

2:51:51 – 2:52:24Speaker 11

Okay. My only question is that is because sometimes we've gotten people who get, you know, not as much now with our staff because they do a much better job than... three quarters away into the project, and they want a TOC, temporary occupancy permit, and we've gone back and forth with that, and I think our staff knows that we're not willing to do that under most circumstances now, except for under rare occasion. Can you go back to a slide about, just go back a few slides, no, no, no, keep going.

2:52:25Speaker 12

Keep going, keep going, keep going.

2:52:28 – 2:53:43Speaker 11

Yeah, right here. I think, yeah, right here. So in speaking earlier with the city manager on this, and I brought it up to her on this project, like I don't understand, not necessarily in a master-planned area, but where we get into, like when we have infill projects or maybe a warehouse or something that comes up in maybe a more senior area of the city where we have like a sidewalk nexus, like where that fits into, right? We have it for sewer waters, but we've been time and time again, like a project will come up, like the most recent one that I can think of is like at Yorba and Schaefer, how we get a sidewalk nexus study into our development impact fee. I don't understand what study it takes to get that Nexus study into the cost associated with this, but time and time again, we'll have one of these projects come up, and they'll say, well, we only wanna do this, but we think the Nexus is this, right? And that's also, I think, in addition to not requiring developers in the past, because we had a different perspective on it, I understand, but now when it comes to connectivity and different things, we're struggling with some of this stuff as we move along. How do we get it in here and is it appropriate for here or what has to happen for us to understand that?

2:53:43 – 2:54:09Speaker 21

So there are some cities that charge a sidewalk linkage fee type fee. And if I'm understanding you correctly, you're talking about sort of filling in sidewalk gaps. Absolutely. Okay. Yeah, so in those situations, new development can pay their share. And the idea would be that these would provide connectivity on routes of citywide significance. So this wouldn't be something occurring on like a minor residential street, but maybe a collector or an arterial where you're kind of filling in those gaps.

2:54:09 – 2:56:27Speaker 11

So I'm going to tell you right now, I think that's something we need to look at. Because every time it comes up in a project and how we make the modification to it, it's a big old, like we've had to be with developers about connectivity of sidewalk and different things. So to me, that's my first recommendation to the city manager that we also look at before we bring this back to council. The shortfall of money here is huge. I think the thing that's missing in this presentation for when it comes back to council, mostly for staff, is the actual amounts that we're projecting for these projects to be, from Line I to Pine to the Connector, laying those out so that the public understands the capital outlay that this is going to cost. in addition to the funding sources that we intend to seek, because this is a whole lot of money that we have a shortfall on, and maybe a strategy for us to start setting aside a percentage of this money ongoing, because we know that these things aren't gonna be built overnight, but the accelerator in these projects and building them is going to be huge. So, I would say between grants or how we intend the strategy, like the multitude of strategies available for us to fund these projects to the public so they can get their mind around, and us, how this is going to look in the future for each project, what we're projecting at the time. That connects me to the community facilities district, our bonding on that I think is the correct thing. We have long enjoyed a 30 year bond on that. And I think the time may be for us to consider because of especially development just across the city you see like the average house now is almost $100,000 in just development impact fees to construct. and the ongoing impact that development is going to have as the city continues to increase in population and traffic. So I think one of the things that the city may, this council may want to have a presentation on sooner rather than later, because we're on the daily missing opportunities, is whether or not that bonding is appropriate for us and adequate for us moving forward. And that concludes my comments, Mayor, thank you. Okay, Mark, you had something additional?

2:56:28 – 2:57:02Speaker 15

Yeah, and I know that when we're looking at this, we're looking at General City and then we're looking at the preserve. But like for example, I saw that they were talking about 100,000 square foot industrial warehouse. So when we look at these fees, and I think we should be looking at potential development impact fees for the Pine Avenue connector and the Euclid. where we should charge some of these warehouses that we know are more than likely going to come in as a result of some surplus land acts that are coming from the state prison.

2:57:02Speaker 4

Good point, Mark.

2:57:04 – 2:57:35Speaker 15

And be able to start creating a diff fund to charge those developments that are coming in in the future so that when they do come in, We know that those trucks are going to have impacts in those areas, and we need to start collecting some money for that because we're going to need to fund it somehow. And it's time that some of these warehouse and industries start paying for it. So if we're going to look at an impact fee, I think that's something that we need to look at, especially at some of these massive warehouses that we have potentially coming in.

2:57:37 – 2:57:54Speaker 21

Sure, and we can add a land use category for warehousing separate from, differentiate between industrial and light industrial manufacturing type uses versus warehouse uses that potentially generate more trips and add more congestion. We can add that to the fee schedule so you can capture those impacts separately.

2:57:54 – 2:58:36Speaker 12

Okay, any other council comments? I'm going to go through mine, try to do it pretty quickly. I have notes all over the place. I do have one question that triggered. On the slide, preparatory actions required for DIF update under the fee methodology update, there's a comment added, alternative storm drain fee calculation based on impervious area. But we have storm drain retention areas now that are required. required on development, right? Don't we still have that requirement?

2:58:37 – 2:58:55Speaker 22

We do, but that's for water quality purposes. So it's meant to capture a certain storm event that's smaller. It's for like a two year event versus our storm drains. they're meant to capture like a 100-year storm, so it's kind of not the same.

2:58:55Speaker 12

But you're only calculating it on the impervious area, which is the built area, right?

2:59:03 – 2:59:24Speaker 22

Right, so the larger the impervious area, the more runoff is gonna come off the site. So that's why we wanted to have this alternative fee, because there's some projects where they're huge, they have a lot of, let's say, parking space, but they have very minimal building structures, and so it's appropriate that they would pay a higher fee in that case.

2:59:25 – 3:00:00Speaker 12

even though there might be a lot of land and a lot of runoff from the land, they may pay you if the building is relatively small. Like I'm thinking about the new development now that's going on Pine and Euclid, the southeast corner. There's a huge area that's not gonna be built on compared to what can be built because it's under the 566 state line. So there'll be all of that land that's going to have runoff, but you're only going to calculate the fee on the actual part that's being built. Correct. So what's going to mitigate all of the runoff from all of that huge piece of property?

3:00:01Speaker 22

Well, it would be that that runoff is existing. So what's existing? So it's historical? It's historical, basically, yeah.

3:00:11 – 3:00:26Speaker 12

All right. Let's see, okay. Yeah, possibly.

3:00:26Speaker 15

Wouldn't we have more runoff as a result of the asphalt that's gonna be there as opposed to just the dirt that was there before?

3:00:35Speaker 12

Depends on the slope of the land.

3:01:00 – 3:01:45Speaker 12

Can we maybe get copies of the slide presentations before the actual meeting next time? Okay, let me get back to this. On the Will Dan report, on its page 14, the council packet page 21, under land use types, where you're talking about single family residential, the fees are calculated on a per square foot of living space. What about garages?

3:01:47 – 3:02:03Speaker 21

The correlation for demand comes from people. So we correlate demand and we identify the average residents per unit. So the garage space is sort of considered ancillary, but the fee is levied on where the demand comes from and that's where the people live. So it's based on the living space of the unit.

3:02:03Speaker 12

So there's no fees calculated on garages at all?

3:02:08Speaker 21

Correct, yeah. We assume that, yeah, a larger garage doesn't add additional demand for facilities.

3:02:14Speaker 12

No, I understand, I just wondered if we were trying to add more fees on a thing that's not habitable.

3:02:21 – 3:02:39Speaker 21

Right, yeah, there are some jurisdictions that charge it on the total space of the building, including garages. You just need to be consistent whether or not you're charging the fee on the whole space or just the living space. But we feel it's most appropriate to constrain it to the living space, because again, that's where people are housed and that's where the demand comes from.

3:02:40 – 3:02:53Speaker 12

Okay, now I know we don't charge the school fees, I know the school district does. the school district's fees, are they built on, are they based on habitable space, or is it total building including garages? Do you know?

3:02:53Speaker 21

I don't know. I would assume habitable space, but I don't know off the top of my head.

3:02:56 – 3:03:31Speaker 12

Can you find out and let me know? Sure. Okay. Okay, on your page 26, hours 33, we talk about fire suppression facility impact fees. for new development. And then on the next page, we talk about land acquisition for mid-preserve area station and a new fire station in the mid-preserve area. That is the only new fire facility that we're anticipating.

3:03:33Speaker 21

Yeah, that's the only new fire station. I believe this list, oh, well, there's an expansion to the fire station 65, so they're adding square footage there.

3:03:42Speaker 12

That's Ramona, right? Ramona Avenue? Linda, 65 is Ramona Avenue?

3:03:52 – 3:04:09Speaker 21

Yeah, but aside from that, you're correct. Those are the only sort of bricks and mortar that are assumed here. There are new engines and ancillary trucks and things of that nature. I believe this list was reviewed by the fire district, and that's what they had identified as needed to serve the city.

3:04:09Speaker 12

Okay. We don't have anything calculated in here for police, do we?

3:04:14Speaker 21

There's a law enforcement fee.

3:04:16Speaker 12

Okay, but isn't Lewis supposed to provide us some type of substation?

3:04:23Speaker 10

We are working with Lewis on a substation. We don't have all the final details, but we are working on that.

3:04:28Speaker 12

Okay, but that's separate from?

3:04:30Speaker 10

Separate from that Diffie, yes. Okay.

3:04:33Speaker 20

We did include one project for the outfitting and furniture and fixtures for that facility, though. We just added it.

3:04:42Speaker 21

That's on page 23 of the draft study.

3:04:56 – 3:05:28Speaker 12

And then I think my last one. Oh, under planned general facilities, we're including public works. And I know we talked about it earlier. We're going to try to work a public partner program. public-private partnership for a new city hall. But shouldn't we have something in there to help our share of costs when we relocate city hall and rebuild the senior center and stuff like that? Are we strictly gonna try to do it with public-private partnerships?

3:05:30 – 3:05:41Speaker 10

Well, that's our goal. We didn't include any of those facilities for the master plan, right? No, not for any kind of expansion. But that makes sense, Mayor, because what if we can't?

3:05:42 – 3:06:10Speaker 12

Well, that's my point. And then we want to add on to the Carolyn Owens building. That's not going to be a public-private partnership. And we need to do that, so we need a fee. We need income in order to do some of these things that we know are not gonna be covered by a partnership. So I think we have a gaping hole here that we're not addressing. And we're not gonna revisit these fees for another, what, eight years?

3:06:10 – 3:06:30Speaker 20

So the public use facilities fee was pulled out of the update for now. We're bringing that back in September. We haven't finalized the cost in the list, so we're gonna provide that in September when we come back. So that would include any expansion to city-wide facilities such as Carolyn Owens, the Preserve Community Center, and such.

3:06:31 – 3:06:56Speaker 12

I would suggest that we look at that. I mean, we need to at least address best, worst case facility. Okay, I mean it's pie in the sky. We hope to get these partnerships, but if we don't, that means we're not gonna be able to improve. Also, we don't have, in these fees, there's no kind of cost escalator at all based on CPI or anything, is there?

3:06:57 – 3:07:08Speaker 20

Oh yes, so we actually provided new cost estimates in the study, so everything has brand new pricing. And then we do the annual escalator when we bring it back annually.

3:07:09 – 3:07:52Speaker 12

OK. Now, I have one last question, and that is park upgrades. When we look at what it cost us to do Rancho Park, and I know that was exceptional because it was ADA and all that kind of stuff. So it was a little bit, well, it was a lot more expensive than a normal park. But when I was looking at the fees for development, I think it's really woefully short when we look at just what it costs to improve a park now, just to replace the playground equipment and stuff, not even starting from scratch. And we're looking at building brand new parks. I think we're gonna be under-feed. Under-feed, you know what I mean, underfunded.

3:07:53 – 3:08:52Speaker 21

Well, I will mention that and Sylvia alluded to this earlier in the presentation that the park cost improvement in the prior program was calculated as a multiplier of the land value, which isn't necessarily analogous to what it costs to build a park. So in this update, we took a look at some other local jurisdictions and got some fresh park costs and took the average cost per acre. It has increased to about 1.165 million per acre. I will say that recently, in the last week or so, we did get a comparable park cost from the City of Ontario, and they're also updating their Nexus City right now, and we're going to add that to the sample. to make sure that we include the the most accurate park construction costs going forward but that is certainly something that we looked at and it's a more sound methodology to take a look at comparables as opposed to just a multiplier based on the cost per acre because that was ending up with a situation where the park improvement cost was different for the preserve versus the general city when it costs the same to build a park regardless of where you are in the city

3:08:53 – 3:09:22Speaker 12

Well, and a lot of it has to do with how much open space you have as well. Like Rancho Park was tiny. It was only about an acre, but it was like, what, $5 or $6 million. Well, if you have a huge park with a lot of open space, obviously the development cost is going to be less than one that's concentrated like Rancho Park. So I don't know how in the world you would put something like that into a calculation, but it seems like there somehow needs to be a nexus in the size of the park.

3:09:22 – 3:10:11Speaker 21

Yeah, well, we'll take another look at the park construction cost per acre. We want to make sure that we come up with a representative cost that reflects the types of amenities that you're building here as well. So we could take another look at that and make sure that it's right sized for the types of parks that you're building and certainly consider the city's recent experience, but also what other people are paying for parks. And I think your point is well taken that sometimes the scale of the park affects the costs. You know, sometimes those tiny little neighborhood parks cost the most on a per acre basis just because you're jamming so many amenities into a small space. So we'll take a look at that. And one approach might be to kind of weight the cost per acre by the different types of parks that you might be building. So, yeah, we're happy to take a look and make sure that the the assumption that we have for park improvement cost per acre is reflective of the types of things you're going to be building going forward.

3:10:11Speaker 11

There has to be an assumption based off of the programming of the park, whether it's passive or active, so I'm sure there's a way to do that. Yeah, the amenities.

3:10:20Speaker 12

Okay, council have any other questions or comments? Okay, is there anyone from the audience that would like to address the council on this item? Stubby?

3:10:36 – 3:12:34Speaker 4

Good afternoon. I just want to second the motion for the toll road. I think that . Actually, I was thinking about that after you said that. That's why toll roads are built, because people in areas don't cooperate to build them, so they build. That's the same thing that happened like on the 91 toll road things. Just something that struck me. So we're looking at anticipated revenue by charging these fees, but we're charging the fees now on square footages. Fine, except I believe the square footage was 3,300 without a garage. our house, which seems high and 1400 for multifamily, which also seems high. So then we're making a projection that we may fail to achieve. WHERE PREVIOUSLY WE WERE DOING IT PER UNIT, IF THEY BUILT AN 800 SQUARE FOOT APARTMENT OR A 1500 SQUARE FOOT APARTMENT, WE GOT THE SAME DEBT FEES. IT'S JUST SOMETHING TO CONSIDER BECAUSE WE'RE BASICALLY PROJECTING THE INCOME AND IN THE PAST, WITH THE EXCEPTION OF THAT $9 MILLION WE COLLECTED FOR THE STREET LIGHT OVER THERE IN ONTARIO, WE HAVE TRADITIONALLY FALLEN SHORT WITH OUR DEBT FEES. By the way, if you just want to read the history, some of the traffic studies that were done in 2003, 2004 for the preserve, they had outlying impacts on intersections that I couldn't even find on a map. I read them one time. And I think that's where a lot of this money has come from. We collected the money. We can't spend it in Chino because that's illegal. We definitely don't want to give it back. Anyway, I think the square footage might affect the total fees that we collect. So, thank you.

3:12:34 – 3:12:51Speaker 12

Thank you, Stubby. Anyone else? Okay. Then, with that... We will adjourn to a regular meeting, which will be held on June the 16th at 6, with closed session starting no earlier than 4. With that, we are adjourned.

This transcript was automatically generated from the official public meeting video and is presented unedited. It reflects remarks made on the public record by elected officials, staff, and public commenters. Transcript accuracy may vary; view the original recording for reference.